143 réponses à ce sujet

[Gabey5]

lets say you are forced in me3 to make a decison between your old crew and new ones to serve on the normandy.. tali and garrus would join the old crew.


who would it be?

Original:

Tali
Wrex
Ashley/Kaiden
Garrus
Liara

New
Mordin
Legion
Miranda
jacob
jack
zaeed
Grunt
Thane
Samara/Morinth


provided they are alive.

[JrayM16]

New crew ofcouse. better written, more personality, more diversity. Its a no-brainer.

[Lord Atlia]

What!? You put Tali and Garrus in the old crew you just made this decision infinitely harder.

Modifié par Lord Atlia, 11 février 2010 - 08:40 .

[redguppie]

Have to go with new crew.It's larger, more diverse abilities, and they are all still alive.

Need to put Garrus and Tali in the second column as well.

Modifié par redguppie, 11 février 2010 - 08:41 .

[Remaix]

New crew, if it would include Tali and Garrus. Would miss Wrex, but Wrex alone isn't worth the combined awesome of Mordin, Thane and Garrus >.>

[Sir Ulrich Von Lichenstien]

Why do Tali and Garrus have to join the old crew?



On my Renegade FemShep's story Wrex is dead (of his own doing coz she never recruited him), so is Kaiden, Liara she couldn't give a monkeys about leaving the crazy Ashley....



Oi Garrus, Tali, get with the new crew NAO!



Seriously though, these stupid kind of threads should just not exist. Why do we have to choose? I'd rather have them fused together to form one big frelling army!



Actually if Liara and Ash joined my new crew on my Renegade Femshep, then that'd fill up the spots left by Thane and Jacob.

[Cutlass Jack]

Tali and Garrus were part of both crews, so you can't put that qualifier on them. Sorry.

[Llandaryn]

Part of the old crew (Tali/Wrex/Garrus) with aspects of the new crew (Mordin/Jack/Thane).

I win!

[Lord Atlia]

Llandaryn wrote...

Part of the old crew (Tali/Wrex/Garrus) with aspects of the new crew (Mordin/Jack/Thane).

I win!

This is illogical. The correct response is old crew (Tali/Wrex/Garrus) + new crew (Mordin/Legion/Thane) = WIN

[Niorcs]

Tali - Yes

Wrex - Still being Clan Leader, couldn't join

Ashley/Kaiden - Maybe :/

Garrus - Yes

Liara - She'd be more of an active support character



New

Mordin - Yes, as long as he's not dead ;_;

Legion - Needed for the upcoming war

Miranda - I'm good without her

Jacob- Same boat as Miranda

Jack - Probably would go off and do her own thing

Zaeed - he did his contracted job, probably off on own thing

Grunt - Yes

Thane - Yes

Samara/Morinth - Accomplished the mission and Samara would be doing justice.

[Gabey5]

Cutlass Jack wrote...

Tali and Garrus were part of both crews, so you can't put that qualifier on them. Sorry.

yes butthey prefer old team rather than cerberus... have you talked to em? tali will easily jump ship and so will garrus he can only work with so many criminals.

[Sir Ulrich Von Lichenstien]

Gabey5 wrote...

Cutlass Jack wrote...

Tali and Garrus were part of both crews, so you can't put that qualifier on them. Sorry.

yes butthey prefer old team rather than cerberus... have you talked to em? tali will easily jump ship and so will garrus he can only work with so many criminals.

You mean that crew that is no longer working for Cerberus if you destroyed the base and had Miranda and Jacob in your party when you did so?

Ok... just checking

Everyone on that ship virtually apart from Miranda/Jacob are either original Normandy crew or joined Cerberus because the Alliance became the biggest BS in the galaxy since Shep died, well... part from Admiral Hackett whom I hope we get to meet in person in ME3.

[nitefyre410]

Wait and be stuck with Boring old Kaiden over Mordin... LOL New crew all the way ... With Garrus and Tali

[DarthCaine]

JrayM16 wrote...

New crew ofcouse. better written, more personality, more diversity. Its a no-brainer.

This

[Barquiel]

I prefer the old crew (although I like Miranda, Samara and Mordin too)

Modifié par Barquiel, 11 février 2010 - 09:32 .

[GnusmasTHX]

Old crew except Kaiden. I'd rather have Mordin or Legion instead. Mordin because I like him, and Legion MIGHT become more interesting.

[Cutlass Jack]

Gabey5 wrote...

Cutlass Jack wrote...

Tali and Garrus were part of both crews, so you can't put that qualifier on them. Sorry.

yes butthey prefer old team rather than cerberus... have you talked to em? tali will easily jump ship and so will garrus he can only work with so many criminals.

No one is working for Cerberus at the end of ME2 if you destroyed the base. Everyone chooses you over Cerberus. Even Miranda, the 'Loyalist.'

My preferred crew would be the ones who were most loyal to me. Of your old crew, only half have your back in the second game. Tali, Garrus & Wrex. Ash/Kai had their chance and blew it. Liara, I'm reserving judgement on.

[Barquiel]

Cutlass Jack wrote...


My preferred crew would be the ones who were most loyal to me. Of your old crew, only half have your back in the second game. Tali, Garrus & Wrex. Ash/Kai had their chance and blew it. Liara, I'm reserving judgement on.

What makes Wrex more loyal than Liara?

[Sir Ulrich Von Lichenstien]

Well technically you could still be working with Cerberus even if you destroyed the base, all you did was just ****** TIM off a bit, can't remember what Shep says during the middle dialogue option but I don't think it is akin to "Joker, lose this channel" which he says in the top option of 'Shut up'. Be interesting if that last conversation with him plays a part in the choice.

Edit: @Barquiel not everyone recruited Liara right away, some may have left her to last in which case apart from her giving you to Cerberus (which Shep might not know of), Shep might not care about Liara.

I know this might be hard for some of you Liara fans to accept that, but its the truth. Not every Shep in everyones Galaxy has to like her/consider her loyal.

Modifié par Sir Ulrich Von Lichenstien, 11 février 2010 - 09:40 .

[AGogley]

Mordin is one of the best characters in the game, especially in on board discussions. I thought Ashley was more conversant and the relationship a bit deeper than Miranda's. Wrex was far more interesting as a Character than Grunt. Grunt is good for combat, but says nothing worth listening too...ever. Same for Zaeed. If you didn't use him for combat, he was just a waste of space. I liked Jacob as a crew mate. For me, Kaiden's dead so that's a no-go. Tali and Garrus were on both crews, so no point there. Jack...we'll I never felt the need to use her, and she was so anti-social anyways, what was the point? Thane, good storyline, but not the best conversationalist. Samara vs. Liara...half dozen of one vs. six of the other as far as I'm concerned.

[jlb524]

Old crew, all the way!!



I would miss a few on the new crew, however.

[mp84]

New Crew all the way for me too..

If not, just to hear Mordin sing "Gilbert and Sullivan" (Salarian version) again!

Modifié par mp84, 11 février 2010 - 09:48 .

[XXL RooK]

OLD CRUUUU YOOO

[AirWonderCross]

Custom Crew!