429 réponses à ce sujet

[Crabhand]

Both games have their strengths and weaknesses. I felt like Mass Effect was more deep with various missions and greater motivation to complete non-essential missions. Mass Effect 2 had more polished combat, but the story beyond the main missions is non-existent. I give Mass Effect points for depth, and Mass Effect 2 points for combat.

[Kalfear]

lukandroll wrote...

Kalfear wrote...

lukandroll wrote...

Kalfear wrote...

lukandroll wrote...

Kalfear wrote...

yoomazir wrote...

DarthCaine wrote...

ME2

I made a poll, some time ago here:
http://social.biowar...596/polls/1670/

The majority says ME2

majority of  what? 140 people? and probably part of them never played the first ME.

I' m really sorry to say it but ME2 is a bad TPS and a bad RPG with a lame story who royaly mess up with how ended the first game.

I suppose that if I want a good tps I should stick with Army of Two or Gears of War and if I want a good (w)rpg I should stick with DA:O or Fallout 3.

And to think that Bioware co-founder Greg Zeschuk bashed jrpgs for being stagnant...

Smile and nod, smile and nod, this the normal "logic" DarthCain (doesnt that name scream 13 year old?) known for here.

So the guy has a point and you insult him, guess who is looking more like a 13 year old??

ROFLMAO!

What point, that his bias poll of 140 people had the result he gimicked to ensure returned?

Wow, doesnt take much to please some of you

You can't talk about bias, when the 120% of your post are completely and utterly pro bioware even when the original poster DO had a point, at least he had a poll and a valid opinion.
If anyone is questionable here, that's you mein freud.

Sure I can, watch this
Justatroll (thats you) is BIAS against Bioware and just comes here to troll the forums looking for the attention he cant even buy in the real world.
Darth Cain is a pro Bioware junky that count create a balanced arguement if his life depended on it and creates fake polls that no one cares about to try and back up his underinformed positions!

See,not only can I talk about Bias, I can use it in a balanced and realistic manner.

Listen Justatroll, I have no problem calling out Bioware on areas they have underproduced (such as ME2 and DLC), just like when they do good, I beleive they deserve credit and not false whiner (thats you again in case you missed it) shame. KotOR was a great game worthy credit. ME1 was the best RPG ever made and worthy credit, DA:O is the best fantasy RPG ever made and worthy credit.

See how this works? 
The good stuff gets credit!
The bad stuff gets shame!

Maybe Darth Caine and you should try to add some balance to your lives Justatroll cause your really coming off as a whiner "Whaaaa, you liked something Bioware did!!! Im going to pout now".

Dont bother replying kid, this thread not about your insecurities and I appoligize to those not flaming and spamming (and making up crap that started all this...DARTH CAINE). Back to topic at hand.
BTW: My reply on topic is found on the first few pages, you wont find a on topic reply from Justatroll or DarthCaine
PS: Im not your freind, my freinds have finished not only jr high school, high school, and post secondary but. well they have real girl freinds and wives. Heck some have kids older then you. Sorry kid, you just dont fit any of the criteria (use a dictionary for meaning of last word)

Wow did I touch some nervers there or what

Nope, standard responce to spoiled children tostupid to accept their betters

[ScriptDiver]

ME1 for story, no doubt there.

ME2 for gameplay.

[james1221]

me1 for me. there wasn't the same feeling of unity or emotion in the 2nd one, rather it was just a bunch of people shooting things. the only way you had emotion is if you played horribly and ended up getting squad mates killed, which i didn't.

[piemanz]

ME1

[Bluemanrule]

Delta426 wrote...

ME2 for gameplay, ME1 for story

I couldn't agree more.  That being siad, it's my favorite Franchise of all-time.  It's like picking your favorite kid.  You love them both the same but you love different things about each.

[lukandroll]

Kalfear wrote...

lukandroll wrote...

Kalfear wrote...

lukandroll wrote...

Kalfear wrote...

lukandroll wrote...

Kalfear wrote...

yoomazir wrote...

DarthCaine wrote...

ME2

I made a poll, some time ago here:
http://social.biowar...596/polls/1670/

The majority says ME2

majority of  what? 140 people? and probably part of them never played the first ME.

I' m really sorry to say it but ME2 is a bad TPS and a bad RPG with a lame story who royaly mess up with how ended the first game.

I suppose that if I want a good tps I should stick with Army of Two or Gears of War and if I want a good (w)rpg I should stick with DA:O or Fallout 3.

And to think that Bioware co-founder Greg Zeschuk bashed jrpgs for being stagnant...

Smile and nod, smile and nod, this the normal "logic" DarthCain (doesnt that name scream 13 year old?) known for here.

So the guy has a point and you insult him, guess who is looking more like a 13 year old??

ROFLMAO!

What point, that his bias poll of 140 people had the result he gimicked to ensure returned?

Wow, doesnt take much to please some of you

You can't talk about bias, when the 120% of your post are completely and utterly pro bioware even when the original poster DO had a point, at least he had a poll and a valid opinion.
If anyone is questionable here, that's you mein freud.

Sure I can, watch this
Justatroll (thats you) is BIAS against Bioware and just comes here to troll the forums looking for the attention he cant even buy in the real world.
Darth Cain is a pro Bioware junky that count create a balanced arguement if his life depended on it and creates fake polls that no one cares about to try and back up his underinformed positions!

See,not only can I talk about Bias, I can use it in a balanced and realistic manner.

Listen Justatroll, I have no problem calling out Bioware on areas they have underproduced (such as ME2 and DLC), just like when they do good, I beleive they deserve credit and not false whiner (thats you again in case you missed it) shame. KotOR was a great game worthy credit. ME1 was the best RPG ever made and worthy credit, DA:O is the best fantasy RPG ever made and worthy credit.

See how this works? 
The good stuff gets credit!
The bad stuff gets shame!

Maybe Darth Caine and you should try to add some balance to your lives Justatroll cause your really coming off as a whiner "Whaaaa, you liked something Bioware did!!! Im going to pout now".

Dont bother replying kid, this thread not about your insecurities and I appoligize to those not flaming and spamming (and making up crap that started all this...DARTH CAINE). Back to topic at hand.
BTW: My reply on topic is found on the first few pages, you wont find a on topic reply from Justatroll or DarthCaine
PS: Im not your freind, my freinds have finished not only jr high school, high school, and post secondary but. well they have real girl freinds and wives. Heck some have kids older then you. Sorry kid, you just dont fit any of the criteria (use a dictionary for meaning of last word)

Wow did I touch some nervers there or what

Nope, standard responce to spoiled children tostupid to accept their betters

lol, with that kind of reply, you can't call children to no one 
Talking about spoiled children... did BioWare check came yet? Or are you still working for free?

[arkiva]

ME2, but i loved ME 1 too. The story? The story is the SAME in both games. ME 2 story continues ME1 story. And in a very great way, i think.

Modifié par arkiva, 16 février 2010 - 09:51 .

[FataliTensei]

ME1 it was more of a hybrid, I like it better



ME2 began to pander to the shooter crowd

[Raveos]

Delta426 wrote...

ME2 for gameplay, ME1 for story

My sentiments exactly.  They are both Hall of Fame kick arse games.

[Veex]

I prefer ME2 over the original in every way except story.

[Arawaen]

ME1.

ME2 was two steps forward and two steps backward in my view and the end result is I have less interest in replaying it (beat it twice).  I have finished ME1 3 times since getting ME2.

[Astranagant]

Overall I have to go with 1 just because the story of ME2 feels like a bad filler episode, and that's not counting the pointless, random retcon of Cerberus from some dime-store faceless sidequest antagonist who nobody's ever heard of (example quote from ME1: "Cerberus? I've never heard of it.") to some big bad force to be reckoned with and the central focus of the game even beyond the Reapers. Shifting the focus to some other "THE X" villain felt contrived as well. Not to mention the cheesy plot twists (on board the collector ship, for instance.)



Even though the gameplay is much better, and the graphics are great, and it's generally higher quality, I still like the original more for at least not being schizophrenic and losing focus. It seems to me like Bioware never had a real plot outline for a trilogy and just came up with the changes and retcons in ME2 to buy time to figure out what to actually do with the plot.

[lumen11]

ME2 without a doubt,... but I expect a sequel to be better so it's difficult to make a fair comparison.

[Argent Csero]

ME1



I liked ME2, just not as much.



I'm hoping for a mix of the two in ME3.

[Habelo]

I gotta go with ME1. Better story, more twists, more mystery.



But ME2 had much better combat fps.

[DarkWarSoldier]

Schneidend wrote...

I find ME2 to be superior in every conceivable way.

[Marilynn-22]

DarkWarSoldier wrote...

Schneidend wrote...

I find ME2 to be superior in every conceivable way.

^^^^^^^^^

[Schneidend]

I love both games, but prefer ME2. I'm likely going to play ME1 again sometime soon, though, since I only have one Shepard ready to import.

EDIT: ...ROFL. Didn't read the last page, and therefore didn't realize I'd posted in this already, and to even be quoted. That's sweet, guys. I still definitely feel that way, that ME2 is just overall the better game, but ME1 will always have a special place in my heart. Easily still in my top 5 games of all time.

In no particular order:

• Mass Effect
• Mass Effect 2
• Baldur's Gate 2
• Final Fantasy Tactics: War of the Lions
• Castlevania: Symphony of the Night

Modifié par Schneidend, 16 février 2010 - 11:34 .

[Serpenttt92]

Mass Effect 2

[Dinkamus_Littlelog]

Its really heartening to see so many folks sticking to their guns and siding with ME1.



ME2 did some things right for sure, but lets just say it is definitely the game out of the two that desperately needs a strong DLC following, because right now its a struggle to play the damn game anymore.



I exhausted almost everything in game (unless you count seeing the story from a renegade perspective) in one single playthrough of ME2, bar each individual romance obviously. With ME1, I was still getting the occasional surprise on my third playthrough.

[Raptor43321]

Sorta new to the fourms..but I just got done with Mass Effect 2...which I only found after looking for something to play after Dragon Age, saw the extremely high ratings it got, and said "Hey, this looks like a pretty awesome game!". Just beat it after like 35 hrs, and I gotta say, I'd put it in the 9-10 range...probably the largest thing that pissed me off was the suspense killing camera shift at the end with Tali, I;m sure you know what I;m referring to. Besides that...eventhough I really dont play a lot of FPS games..I enjoyed walking around, going into adredaline rush mode, and picking someone's head of with my Widow Anti Material Rife...loaded with heavy warp ammo of course



I'm about to install Mass Effect 1 and play it..which after reading on here for a half hour or so..seems like a bit of a mistake playing 2 and then 1 (sort of like how the star wars movies went lol) So thanks for all these posts so now I know what to expect in ME1 so I won't be automatically biased against it once I start I think they're both going to be great games

[lumen11]

Dinkamus_Littlelog wrote...

Its really heartening to see so many folks sticking to their guns and siding with ME1.

ME2 did some things right for sure, but lets just say it is definitely the game out of the two that desperately needs a strong DLC following, because right now its a struggle to play the damn game anymore.

I exhausted almost everything in game (unless you count seeing the story from a renegade perspective) in one single playthrough of ME2, bar each individual romance obviously. With ME1, I was still getting the occasional surprise on my third playthrough.

Why is it heartening?
And I have a hard time believing you exhausted everything in one playthrough. I'm in my third playthrough now and finding plenty of new stuff.

[SSH83]

absolutely ME2. much more well-rounded in the character roaster and story, and a blast to play. I loved all the characters except Jacob, what a boring wuss!!



ME1 was a bit too straight-faced for me, I was almost suffocating from the stale Star-Trek air it gives off.

[yoomazir]

lumen11 wrote...

Dinkamus_Littlelog wrote...

Its really heartening to see so many folks sticking to their guns and siding with ME1.

ME2 did some things right for sure, but lets just say it is definitely the game out of the two that desperately needs a strong DLC following, because right now its a struggle to play the damn game anymore.

I exhausted almost everything in game (unless you count seeing the story from a renegade perspective) in one single playthrough of ME2, bar each individual romance obviously. With ME1, I was still getting the occasional surprise on my third playthrough.

Why is it heartening?
And I have a hard time believing you exhausted everything in one playthrough. I'm in my third playthrough now and finding plenty of new stuff.

you know,it's not like there was hundreds of secondary quest, weapons & armors in ME2. Are you saying that in three playthroughs you never fully explored the game? it may be hard to believe for you but some people have discovered every location/done every side quest in only one playthrough without rushing the game.
It's not like there was so much content anyway, hell, even a moderator here said he got 1015/1015 achievements in one playthrough, something that was not doable in ME1.