150 réponses à ce sujet

[EtTuBrute]

No one's suggested Peter Berg yet?

[AK118]

Michael Jackson.

[Farkingrouse]

The Mitchell brothers

[Nostradamoose]

Paul Verhoeven

Come on, Starship Trooper guys!

[FiOth]

Uwe Balls! (or was it Boll? xD)



No, I am just kidding. I would go for Danny Boyle, I have great respect for the man and he has proven that he can make even the most overused of settings seem fresh.

[ShadyKat]

mnrqz wrote...

MarloMarlo wrote...

Ridley Scott or James Cameron

Ridley Scott or George Lucas.


James Cameron are you kidding me?

The movie under Cameron would end up being some kind of hippy left-wing moral of a movie, besides....

Cameron has a distaste for gamers.

“We were showing that Grace doesn’t care about her human body, only her avatar body,” Cameron said. Augustine’s destructive behavior “is a negative comment about people in our real world living too much in their avatars, meaning online and in video games.”

So he basically just slapped you and RPGs in the face and challenged you to a messy duel.

Besides Avatar kinda blew, he muddled it with his own leftist political messages, since when did the Taliban become blue people with bows and arrows? but I suppose he would be better off just copy and pasting the script of mass effect as he did with Avatar.

http://failblog.org/...atar-plot-fail/

You'd rather have Lucus instead of Cameron? George Lucus is by far worst, and hasn't made a good movie since the Empire Strikes Back.

[mnrqz]

ShadyKat wrote...

mnrqz wrote...

MarloMarlo wrote...

Ridley Scott or James Cameron

Ridley Scott or George Lucas.




James Cameron are you kidding me?

The movie under Cameron would end up being some kind of hippy left-wing moral of a movie, besides....

Cameron has a distaste for gamers.

“We were showing that Grace doesn’t care about her human body, only her avatar body,” Cameron said. Augustine’s destructive behavior “is a negative comment about people in our real world living too much in their avatars, meaning online and in video games.”

So he basically just slapped you and RPGs in the face and challenged you to a messy duel.

Besides Avatar kinda blew, he muddled it with his own leftist political messages, since when did the Taliban become blue people with bows and arrows? but I suppose he would be better off just copy and pasting the script of mass effect as he did with Avatar.

http://failblog.org/...atar-plot-fail/

You'd rather have Lucus instead of Cameron? George Lucus is by far worst, and hasn't made a good movie since the Empire Strikes Back.

George Lucas is the fall guy at best, frankly my other choice directors would most likely not like to indulge in a science fiction movie, Scorcese, Eastwood, Coens, Nolan etc. The guy from the LOTR movies might be able to make it work, or his protege (District 9)

But yes, I would rather have George Lucas than Cameron. Cameron hasn't made a good movie since Terminator, and even he managed to make it an estrogen-fest of "Z0mg all war is t3h evil" once Judgement day released. 

Modifié par mnrqz, 24 février 2010 - 08:42 .

[HeavyTankZA]

James Cameron, nuff said

[Massadonious1]

Avatar Effect 2: Return to Pandora.

[SirVincealot]

ShadyKat wrote...
You'd rather have Lucus(sic) instead of Cameron? George Lucus is by far worst, and hasn't made a good movie since the Empire Strikes Back.

George LucAS did not make EMPIRE STRIKES BACK.

In fact, his relationship with Gary Kurtz started to sour over many of the decisions made for this sequel - notably in regards to the tone and choice of director - and broke over RETURN.

But that's a story for another time.

FactoCop SirV

[mnrqz]

[quote]SirVincealot wrote...

[quote]ShadyKat wrote...
You'd rather have Lucus(sic) instead of Cameron? George Lucus is by far worst, and hasn't made a good movie since the Empire Strikes Back.
[/quote]

George LucAS did not make EMPIRE STRIKES BACK.

In fact, his relationship with Gary Kurtz started to sour over many of the decisions made for this sequel - notably in regards to the tone and choice of director - and broke over RETURN.

But that's a story for another time.

FactoCop SirV
[/quote

Bazing!

[mnrqz]

Frankly, everyone cept cameron or boll or shymalan however the hell his name is spelled is good in my book

Modifié par mnrqz, 24 février 2010 - 09:03 .

[Costin_Razvan]

Peter Jackson/Sir Ridley Scott/ Steven Spielberg.

[Balerion84]

Woody Allen. Period.

And he should play the Illusive Man.


Ok, if I had to choose seriously, then Ridley Scott. Cameron and Spielberg are just mainstream pleasers.
Blade Runner+Alien=Win.
Mass Effect has too much of Blade Runner included already, so Ridley would be the best option in my opinion. 

Modifié par Balerion84, 24 février 2010 - 09:28 .

[kariod]

On the whole, I would agree with the many suggestions of Ridley Scott. Mass Effect in a Blade Runner style sans the noir element (which was practically removed in the Director's Cut, anyway) would be amazing. That said, I also agree with the idea that it should be full CGI, and any characters from the game series should be voiced by the same actors.



I skipped a page of this thread, so I'm not sure if it was mentioned (probably not), but perhaps

Christophe Gans. I can't say I know much about his work, but he directed the Silent Hill adaptation, and I have always stood by the opinion that it was one of--if not the--best video game adaptations ever. But it would depend on his ability to handle sci-fi for one, and having a chance to play the games as he did with SH, for another.



In any event, any potential director or writer should be REQUIRED to play the entire series.

[Karlojey]

Quentin Tarantino so that it'll be bloody violent

Modifié par Karlojey, 24 février 2010 - 02:52 .

[Balerion84]

Karlojey wrote...

Quentin Tarantino so that it'll be bloody violent

Tarantino's movies aren't about "bloody violence"... your average action movie has more blood and violence than Tarantino's movies... his movies are about dialogues, sheesh, I'm so tired of this Tarantino myth <_<

[Sailears]

kariod wrote...

On the whole, I would agree with the many suggestions of Ridley Scott. Mass Effect in a Blade Runner style sans the noir element (which was practically removed in the Director's Cut, anyway) would be amazing. That said, I also agree with the idea that it should be full CGI, and any characters from the game series should be voiced by the same actors.

I skipped a page of this thread, so I'm not sure if it was mentioned (probably not), but perhaps
Christophe Gans. I can't say I know much about his work, but he directed the Silent Hill adaptation, and I have always stood by the opinion that it was one of--if not the--best video game adaptations ever. But it would depend on his ability to handle sci-fi for one, and having a chance to play the games as he did with SH, for another.

In any event, any potential director or writer should be REQUIRED to play the entire series.

I agree with those two statements in particular.

[Master Smurf]

h_pepon wrote...

JJ Abrams or Christopher Nolan.

This!!! - The other big names mentioned are good but I think their visions might detract from ME lore.

Ridley Scott over James Cameron if they went with mega director.
Antoine Fuqua could do it as if they save all the loot for effects 

[Garndell]

With the major focus on chartacter & story, it could only be Anthony Minghella; may he rest in peace, but since that's impossible i'd say Luc Besson, after all he directed & wrote Leon.

[Balerion84]

Garndell wrote...

With the major focus on chartacter & story, it could only be Anthony Minghella; may he rest in peace, but since that's impossible i'd say Luc Besson, after all he directed & wrote Leon.

What does Leon has to do with a dark sci-fi? If you said Fifth Element you'd have been a lot closer to what Luc Besson's Mass Effect movie would look like.

[drag-once]

the guy who directed the ME games

[geekeffect]

Going serious for a second, I can think of District 9's Neill Blomkamp (produced by Peter Jackson as well, why not). If you've seen the short films for the Halo movie (canceled, apparently), you can see that this guy has real energy and vision.



Back to the nightmare list featuring Uwe Boll, McG and... George Lucas [ehe sorry for that], you can add Joel Schumacher in there.

[Magimel]

As film maker I hope they never make it, there is no way to ever capture the depth this game provides in a 2-3 hour movie. Besides I've gotten attached to the way my Shepard has progressed the story. The fact that there are so many different ways to shape the story, and a movie couldn't show all of them, there could be a lot of people not happy with the end result.

Please leave this wonderful story in the world of video games.