First off most of the DLC items are not tier 1-3, most scale depending on the level you acquire them.
Well, it's weird. I knew nothing about the game auto scaling stuff for you. For example, it seems like some of the RtO stuff is Tier 5 no matter what level you decide to RtO.
I had read about mods where you can auto scale your items to Tier 7 (or whatever) but never used them yet.
Until reading the forums recently, I didn't know this was something you could do yourself sans mods ... that just by putting them in the party chest or buying them back from merchants later they would "auto upgrade". I had no idea.
It's interesting because there are a few good DlC and NON DlC items that are only Tier 4, 5, or 6 and would be even more awesome were they 7 ... now I know I can scale them.
However, like I said, even Tier 7 epics of Origins might start paling compared to the Tier 8 starting equipment of Awakening.
One would assume BioWare will give your character a starting set of gear so characters who are decked out in DLC items don't have to start the game naked.
Well think about it. If you start a new from scratch Orlesian warden, he's likely to start out equipped. And unlike your original lvl 1 dude starting out with leather armor, a dagger, and a piece of bread, since he's starting prolly at level 18-20 my guess is he may even start the game with decent equipment, some of it magic.
So if a new char starts that way, don't you think your returning char could get decked out similarly, maybe as an option?
The third issue is role play. My character Cassiel, has the Warden Commanders Armour, not for the stats, but because she looks amazing in it. Plus by the end of the game she had become the Warden Commander so it really suited her from a story point of view as well.
I'm not pure powergamer by any stretch and I understand your point. #1, a lot of the DlC armor just plain LOOKS very nice on your char, probably a lot better than the garden variety stuff. #2, a lot of it is clearly storyline important, I mean, come on, who's just going to throw the former King Cailan's armor in a trashbin or sell it to somebody in dust town, after having recovered it from the battlefield?
#2 is where I see your POV.
The third issue people have with DLC items not carrying over is that we essentially payed for them.
Like I said, I hear you. I love Shale. I love his (her) unique abilities. Dog just growls, charges, and knocks people down. Shale can throw boulders at them, rain them with rocks, slam them back into walls, knock them off their feet with a mini quake, give off a burst of energy that stuns them and buffs him, etc. I'm going to miss him a lot. Although I guess s/he was DlC I
*didn't* pay for.
But you gotta move on in life... I'm hoping they'll be a unique character like him/her/it waiting for us in Awakenings.