Vai al contenuto

Foto

"Disc Unreadable" a.k.a. "Open Tray Error" Solution Thread


  • Effettua l'accesso per rispondere
Questa discussione ha avuto 27 risposte

#1
Old Silverbolt

Old Silverbolt
  • Members
  • 89 Messaggi:
I have noticed many threads across at least 5 forums where
gamers reported experiencing the "Disk Unreadable" error. I am hoping
that this thread can be used as a focal point wherein anyone experiencing this
issue can report it under the watchful eye of the games developers, and
possibly learn from the fruits of my research into the issue.



First and foremost, the error is more commonly referred to as an "Open
Tray error" and is recognized by Microsoft as such. If you wish to report
that you are experiencing the problem to Microsoft, explaining that you are experiencing
a "Disc unreadable error" will elicit an immediate response of
"please return your product to the store from which you purchased it for a
replacement." Basically, they will refuse to help you.

Second, I must emphasize that this is not an isolated incident. Many gamers, in
all countries, are experiencing this particular issue with this particular
game. Also there is no guarantee that replacing the game for a new copy will
solve the problem. I myself have been through 5 copies of Mass Effect 2 in an
effort to resolve this issue and been met with slim to nill success. You are of
course welcome to keep trying, I wouldn't presume to stop you. I am merely
hoping to save this community some potentially wasted time.

Now, regarding a solution, I have researched in depth all potential methods to
fix this problem. Everyone from Microsoft to 10 year olds on Youtube have
posted ways to fix the issue and surprisingly, Microsoft's solution is the
least helpful. Having attempted all of the "fixes" myself, I hope
that my explanations are helpful.


The Microsoft solution:
http://support.xbox....tegory=hardware

To sum up what Microsoft suggests:

1. Make sure the disc is clean. (really? wow..never would have thought of that)
2. Try a different game. (Which helps me play ME2 how?)
3. Clear your system cache. (Just in case something in your cache is "clogging" up the disc drive.....)
4. Remove the hard drive. (I think they are just making up solutions now)
5. Disconnect any "memory units" (See 4...)
6. Request a disc replacement. (Shouldn't this have been done first?)
7. Request a repair (or in other words...we lied, you can't fix this problem)

Just incase you do actually want to send your Xbox 360 in for a repair, here is
the link to get you started:
http://support.xbox....spx?step=repair



The "Buy my product" solution:
http://ezinearticles...rror&id=2714277

According to this and the majority of other websites. Microsoft will charge you
$150 for the repair and it will take between 2 to 6 weeks for them to return
the Xbox to you. While the cost is actually more along the lines of $90-$130
(given that your Xbox isn't also RRoD'd), the time estimate is unfortunately
absolutely true. Microsoft takes its time fixing Xbox's, way more time than it
actually takes.

So some entrepreneurial arse decided he would make a booklet / CD set where he
explained how to manually solve any problem you might ever experience with your
Xbox 360. Not a bad idea, props to him for doing it, but the fact is that some
nobody is making a profit off of your misfortune...and that's a reward most
people don't think he deserves.

However, If you actually want to give it a shot...the link to the product is:
http://www.repairxbox360.info/
Best of luck to ya.



The Amateur solution:
http://www.fixya.com...open_tray_error
http://www.ehow.com/...tray-error.html
etc...etc...etc...

The general amateur fix revolves around cleaning a special part of the disc, or
cleaning the laser lens inside the Xbox 360's optical drive with a "Q
Tip". Speaking from experience, neither of these solutions provide a
reliable result....but what do you expect from amateurs? Feel free to give it a
shot, but remember...scratch the lens inside your Xbox and your definitely
screwed.



Finally, the Youtube Solution:
Sorry I cant recall the links to all the videos I watched.

While I can't provide links, I will save you the trouble. 75% of the videos
related to the "open tray error" or the "disc unreadable
error" are snot-nosed brats complaining about how they have the problem
and proving it with a video. 20% are ad's for products like the Xbox 360 Repair
Guide mentioned earlier. The last 5% are actually good-natured people who have
had the problem and found a solution (all-be-it temporary solution, but a
solution none the less).

Within these good-natured helpful video's, one solution I tried actually
worked. Granted it doesn't work every time, and it certainly isn't a permanent
fix, but it had definitely worked when nothing else seems to....not to mention
it is definitely stress relieving.

The solution I'm referring to is actually hitting your Xbox. No not beating the
snot out of it...but giving it a couple dozen aggressive taps over the disc
drive while the CD is being "read."


I swear it actually works...usually...




So there you have it....the fruits of my research have told me to repeatedly
hit my Xbox while the CD is loading....and it works...

Hope this actually helps some of you who are having this issue, and even if it
doesn't...at least you have a head start on where to look to solve your
problem. Please feel free to just throw a word in if you are one of the many
gamers that this issue is affecting, or even if you have your own solution.

Regardless of your reason for reading this....Thanks for your time, and have a
good night.

Modificata da Old Silverbolt, 15 febbraio 2010 - 04:14 .


#2
Guest_Rasmo71_*

Guest_Rasmo71_*
  • Guests
thnxs Silverbolt, i got this error since last Thursday, it suddenly appears without a reason. I was playing like for 2 weeks with no issue at all. But i have this issue not during the game, just when i start my box it wont start the game, play DVD is written were normally the game would be. i can fix it when i open and close my tray for maybe 3 times, sometimes i need 4 or 5 tries. I tried the trick with knocking on the top of the DVD player and this works like charm then. didnt tried the trick with empty the system cache, will do that later on. but till then, knocking is the best trick for that kind of error :)




#3
TWBuck2

TWBuck2
  • Members
  • 45 Messaggi:
I must say, this is one of the funniest threads I have ever read. Im sitting in class and there is a group of us laughin at everything you said. Props to you. I wish this could get stickied.

#4
avm1980

avm1980
  • Members
  • 1 Messaggi:
Belive it or not, but in my case, Disc 2 has a HUUUUUUUUUGE cratch all the way across it!!! My first guess was that someone at the plant sneezed over it, so with all due precautions, I started the cleaning procedue... I ended up staring at the dics 'cause it is the first (and hopefully, the last) time in my life that I see a DVD with a scratch UNDERNEATH plastic - not ON it!!! I'm getting my replacement tomorrow... Hope with the new set I'll never experience anything for which the tips above will come in handy...

#5
TWBuck2

TWBuck2
  • Members
  • 45 Messaggi:
Bumpity?

#6
Duncaaaaaan

Duncaaaaaan
  • Members
  • 673 Messaggi:
I have this problem as well only on disc 1, but the mass effect 2 picture shows up, so the xbox recognizes the game and knows its in there, but it still says "disc unreadable" i have tried cleaning the disc, htere is not a scratch.



After about 15 mins of trying to start up the game it finally starts, but its frustrating, and its geting worse, now it comes up to the red bioware logo thing with the freaky vocal music, then it starts looping it over again and making wierd noises and comes up with that stupid goddamn BS "disc unreadable error mesage.



Curently installing it to the HD, at 81%, hurry up ffs -.-



I hate microsoft with a passion now.

#7
raziel491

raziel491
  • Members
  • 9 Messaggi:
i just got ME2 3 days ago, and a brand new xbox 360 about 2-3 weeks ago, and im getting the disk unreadable error, i get it when i go to the armory and go to the weapons locker, it wont let me go into the locker i get the disk unreadable message plz clean disk, so although very annoyed, i just said ok and hit b when i went to go on a mission instead of changing my weapons, and it worked....for one mission, now not only can i not change my weapon, but the auto save stuck me in the team selection screen so i cant do anything but choose my two teamates and get a disk unreadable message, both the game and the xbox are like brand new there is no reason i should be getting this message, i havent droped my xbox, theres not a scratch on the disk, i figured that if i contacted microsoft id get a call the other company reply, and bioware dosnt seem to think this is an issue since i see no official thread on fixing this solution, so i feel like it being ignored,. the game is great but no good if i cant play it, im going to try getting the disk cleaned tonight and trying it, i doubt it will work considering there is no scratch on the disk but its worth a shot, if it dosnt work, im gonna be rather ticked, ive never had a problem with bioware......i blame ea, if anyone sees an "official solution" plz link it, oh i also tried installing it on my hard drive....it didnt work same message i thought that was rather funny since why does it need too read the disk if its on the hard drive?Posted Image (got the collectors addition not sure if the standard addition is doing this)

Modificata da raziel491, 18 febbraio 2010 - 05:21 .


#8
exboomer

exboomer
  • Members
  • 327 Messaggi:
Hitting your xbox certainly is a novel approach to solving the problem. It sounds like the laser is misaligned and hittng the console must knock it back into alignment somehow. I hope I don't run into this issue even though I have a second xbox unit I can use.

#9
Digital torture

Digital torture
  • Members
  • 4 Messaggi:
So I'm having this problem with my copy of mass effect 2. During the zaeed loyalty mission, after the choice to go after the target or save the people, it pops up with the "dis unreadable, please remove and clean disc" message. I have tried to install, uninstall, deleted and re-dl the dlc, restart the mission, tried it on a friends 360 and swapped discs and I keep getting the same problem over and over in the same exact spot each time. I'm going to try to clear the cache, maybe that will work.



Any other suggestions?

#10
Digital torture

Digital torture
  • Members
  • 4 Messaggi:
and clearing the cache didn't work. *sigh*

#11
Old Silverbolt

Old Silverbolt
  • Members
  • 89 Messaggi:

Digital torture wrote...

So I'm having this problem with my copy of mass effect 2. During the zaeed loyalty mission, after the choice to go after the target or save the people, it pops up with the "dis unreadable, please remove and clean disc" message. I have tried to install, uninstall, deleted and re-dl the dlc, restart the mission, tried it on a friends 360 and swapped discs and I keep getting the same problem over and over in the same exact spot each time. I'm going to try to clear the cache, maybe that will work.

Any other suggestions?


If your getting the problem with 2 different discs, on 2 different 360s, after having tried installing the game, clearing the cache, and redownloading the DLC....sounds like your screwed dude. Only thing I can come up with is that somehow your savegame file is corrupted.

#12
Old Silverbolt

Old Silverbolt
  • Members
  • 89 Messaggi:
I'll go ahead and tell ya'll for reference... (in other words I don't expect it to actually help anyone, or that anyone will care but yea) I was able to fix the problem a day or so ago with a laser lens cleaning disc. Granted, its only been two days..but the ME2 loads up practically instanteously now, as does everything else on my xbox for some reason I'll never fathom (why the hell would an optical drive cleaning disc speed up the NXE dashboard pop-up window's loading time?).

Anyway if ya'll are willing to spend 15 bucks, I purchased the GameDr "Premier" Laser Lens Cleaner (premier..as in lets give it a fancy name and charge them 10 bucks more) and it works now. No problems...it just works.

If ya'll want to fork out the 15 bucks and give it a shot, here's the link for the product:
http://www.digitalin...ns-cleaner.html
And heres the link to the only sensible place to buy it:
http://www.amazon.co...66640321&sr=8-4

#13
walkeram

walkeram
  • Members
  • 15 Messaggi:
I had the same problem. This is what you need to do. down load the disks to your hard drive. I played through the game twice before doing this and had the disk unreadable  error show up many times. Not even one time after I down loaded the game to my hard drive. The quality of the overall game play was improved also. It is just too much game to be played straight from the disk.

Semper Fi:devil:

#14
walkeram

walkeram
  • Members
  • 15 Messaggi:
download the game to your hard drive. it will play without the error message. i played the game for seven hours one night and not even once did it show up. the graphics are just too much to be read straight from the disk. after you down load and play for some time you will see the quality over playing straight from the disk.



Semper Fi

#15
Old Silverbolt

Old Silverbolt
  • Members
  • 89 Messaggi:

walkeram wrote...

I had the same problem. This is what you need to do. down load the disks to your hard drive. I played through the game twice before doing this and had the disk unreadable  error show up many times. Not even one time after I down loaded the game to my hard drive. The quality of the overall game play was improved also. It is just too much game to be played straight from the disk.

download the game to your hard drive. it will play without the error
message. i played the game for seven hours one night and not even once
did it show up. the graphics are just too much to be read straight from
the disk. after you down load and play for some time you will see the
quality over playing straight from the disk.

Semper Fi:devil:


Not only does downloading the game to the hard drive NOT solve the problem with the disc, but most people that have this problem couldn't install it even if it did. The "install to hard drive" option doesn't work when the Xbox wont read the disc, since it has to download the software from the disc (the same one it can't read).

Don't get me wrong, I appreciate your suggestion. It's just not too thought out, considering how even after you install the game to the hard drive, your Xbox still needs to read the disc to acknowledge that the disc in the tray is ME2 before it will even let you play the game from the hard drive. What you're suggesting is just not a permanent solution.

More often than not, the "disc unreadable" error coinsides with the optical drive not recognizing that there is a disc in the tray 90% of the time you put the game in (or start your Xbox for that matter). If you aren't having that kinda trouble (where you gotta open and close the tray 10 times before your Xbox 360 realizes there's actually a CD in the slot) then you probably just had a scratched up disc.... in which case congratulations, you got it better than most.

But thanks again for the post


PS. Semper Fi with a devil emoticon next to it actually mocks the Marines...since it seems more like your saying "Always faithful..hah, yea right" which is just effing insulting. If you wanna show respect, drop the emoticon...if you wanna represent, then (from one Marine to another) say it like you know what it means...Semper Fidelis, Oorah!

Modificata da Old Silverbolt, 20 febbraio 2010 - 09:23 .


#16
raziel491

raziel491
  • Members
  • 9 Messaggi:
OK, i fixed my problem, seems xbox dosnt know the difference between a disk and a hard drive, heh, as i said before i got the collectors addition and when i downloaded the collector suit and weapon, it must not have downloaded properly, i deleted my downloaded content, and redownloaded it, and everything worked just fine, no error messages and im running from the disks, dont have it installed on my hard drive anymore, hope this helps anybody haveing the same problem i did

#17
raziel491

raziel491
  • Members
  • 9 Messaggi:
and i agree with old silverbolt, theres no reason it shouldnt be read from the disk, if you have an arcade system its very possible you dont have a hard drive, so why the hell would you have to install the game to a hard drive to play it?


oh and dont rely on ea's help too much, i was told to clean the disk, (had already done that) and when that didnt work they told me to try it in anouther xbox, lol like i just have anouther xbox lying around, and i live 45 minutes out of any town, so an acreage its not like i wanna spend the gas money to go to a friends and try it out lol ( fortunately i got it fixed without their help thanks ea)

Modificata da raziel491, 20 febbraio 2010 - 03:34 .


#18
Old Silverbolt

Old Silverbolt
  • Members
  • 89 Messaggi:

raziel491 wrote...

OK, i fixed my problem, seems xbox dosnt know the difference between a disk and a hard drive, heh, as i said before i got the collectors addition and when i downloaded the collector suit and weapon, it must not have downloaded properly, i deleted my downloaded content, and redownloaded it, and everything worked just fine, no error messages and im running from the disks, dont have it installed on my hard drive anymore, hope this helps anybody haveing the same problem i did


Appreciate the tip Raz, that could very well solve some people's problem. Congrats on fixing yours.

Score:
Dedutive reasoning: 2 ~ Microsoft: 0

#19
Nomii

Nomii
  • Members
  • 33 Messaggi:
I hate it when they tell you that there's something wrong with your xbox... My xbox just returned from being repaired... and nothing changed...

#20
gropax

gropax
  • Members
  • 114 Messaggi:
well i had a refurbished 360 come back with a broken dvd drive so i can tell you why they want you to remove the hard drive . as the tech told me since i have a 120 gig hard drive some early production models of the 360 can't read 120 gig hard drives. oh and on a side note if wen you get a new refurbished 360 you have to go and reinstall all your games back to the hard drive. i went to play mass effect 1 and was like why is my game playing from the dvd til i hit play from hard drive and got the error this game was installed on a different console.

#21
Sibuya Sempai

Sibuya Sempai
  • Members
  • 139 Messaggi:

Old Silverbolt wrote...

walkeram wrote...

I had the same problem. This is what you need to do. down load the disks to your hard drive. I played through the game twice before doing this and had the disk unreadable  error show up many times. Not even one time after I down loaded the game to my hard drive. The quality of the overall game play was improved also. It is just too much game to be played straight from the disk.

download the game to your hard drive. it will play without the error
message. i played the game for seven hours one night and not even once
did it show up. the graphics are just too much to be read straight from
the disk. after you down load and play for some time you will see the
quality over playing straight from the disk.

Semper Fi:devil:


Not only does downloading the game to the hard drive NOT solve the problem with the disc, but most people that have this problem couldn't install it even if it did. The "install to hard drive" option doesn't work when the Xbox wont read the disc, since it has to download the software from the disc (the same one it can't read).

Don't get me wrong, I appreciate your suggestion. It's just not too thought out, considering how even after you install the game to the hard drive, your Xbox still needs to read the disc to acknowledge that the disc in the tray is ME2 before it will even let you play the game from the hard drive. What you're suggesting is just not a permanent solution.

More often than not, the "disc unreadable" error coinsides with the optical drive not recognizing that there is a disc in the tray 90% of the time you put the game in (or start your Xbox for that matter). If you aren't having that kinda trouble (where you gotta open and close the tray 10 times before your Xbox 360 realizes there's actually a CD in the slot) then you probably just had a scratched up disc.... in which case congratulations, you got it better than most.

But thanks again for the post


PS. Semper Fi with a devil emoticon next to it actually mocks the Marines...since it seems more like your saying "Always faithful..hah, yea right" which is just effing insulting. If you wanna show respect, drop the emoticon...if you wanna represent, then (from one Marine to another) say it like you know what it means...Semper Fidelis, Oorah!



There's one more issue with installing the game. The system needs to authenticate against the original disc. If you have an open tray error, and get past installation, you still need to deal with the error every time the game starts up.

I've been having this problem recently myself. Oddest thing about it is that I'm having the problem specifically with two discs -- Dragon Age : Origins, and my lens cleaner. Both discs are clean, with no visible scratches, and Dragon Age was working complete with save games and DLC downloaded and intact yesterday. It seems I'll have to wait until my disc decides I'm allowed to play again.

<_<

#22
ckcc

ckcc
  • Members
  • 3 Messaggi:
I am also facing this problem with Disc 1. I was able to play it at first. However after starting another new game due to my ugly shepard, the game froze before the character creation scene a few times. now i keep getting 'open tray' with the disc. ps, the first time disc 1 updated my console, it failed and the 'disc unreadable' message appeared. my whole dashboard turned green and my avatar became a dark figure. after that, i inserted disc 2 and the update was successful. then, my dashboard and avatar returned to their normal state. disc 1 was still readable after that for a few times before this issue happened. btw, if i format the console, will i lose all my previous console updates?

#23
Old Silverbolt

Old Silverbolt
  • Members
  • 89 Messaggi:

ckcc wrote...
if i format the console, will i lose all my previous console updates?


Short answer, yes.

#24
Conquerthecity

Conquerthecity
  • Members
  • 1065 Messaggi:
Bumping a one month old thread. Dunno if I'll get any response, but I might as well try.

Anyway, I played through ME2 twice before. Had no problems whatsoever. I started playing again two days ago and everything seemed fine. Until I got to where it told me to insert Disk 2. I did so, but my x-box started making grinding noises and all it did was keep telling me to instert the disk. So I went to the dashboard, ejected disk 2, and put disk 1 back in. It would get to the red Bioware logo, then the unreadable disk error would pop up. Both disks look undamaged and are clean. I recleaned them anyway and repeated the process. No luck still. I tried everything Microsoft says, the tapping thing, and a youtube trick. No luck there either. Other games read and load perfectly fine.

Not really sure what I should do. Replacing the disks sounds like it may not work and from what I've read the grinding noise can be a precursor to the RROD. So maybe I should get it repaired. Considering the possibility of having to buy a whole new X-box. But that seems a little hasty when every other game is working except this one. Mass Effect 2 is my favorite though...

#25
SpinDoctor15

SpinDoctor15
  • Members
  • 10 Messaggi:
Any updates on this? I posted a new thread on it: http://social.biowar...7/index/7619230