drunken pyromaniac wrote...
Collider wrote...
You should put the full details of what you think in the group, after you're done the romance or have done another conversation.
Sure, will do. I don't think I have any new takes on her character or anything though. I'm just trying to figure out why you guys like her so much.
Here are a few points:
(1) I was drawn by her emotional detachment. I dislike how all too often being emotional is painted as some kind of virtue in a woman. Being the more careful type myself, I immediately connected with her.
(2) She's a woman with enough competence and confidence to stand up to you as Shepard. On the previous page, you said she insulted your pride. I feel the exact opposite: who wouldn't be flattered if a woman like Miranda showed interest? And as "Shepard the Hero" you should have enough confidence yourself to brush her more critical comments off with either a good counterargument (even if the game doesn't let you, do it in your mind), or an amused smile if appropriate.
(3) This confidence and competence also gives her an impressive presence. Forgive me for being poetic, but she'll never be only another's satellite, always a star in her own right.
(4) This makes me feel that she actually adds something to Shepard in the romance, that Miranda/Shepard as a whole is not only more than Shepard alone, but more than the sum of its parts. Is Tali/Shepard significantly more than Shepard alone? Is Jack/Shepard? I don't think so.
(5) I appreciate her ruthlessness. A refreshing change from those fictional women who always push the hero to the less controversial, Paragon decisions.
(6) There's the physical, of course. She's beautiful.
(7) For the romance: she's human. It's a factor for me.
I think those are the pertinent points. The only aspect of her I don't like is her Cerberus apologetics - it's the one aspect of her life where would profit from more emotional distance. But she can learn. My Shepard can certainly learn a few things himself from her, for instance not to be such a bulldozer.
I don't know if any of these reasons appeal to you, but I think most of us here are drawn by some of them. For myself, I think I may be a special case because I can actually identify with her to some degree. That is why I would like a game where I can play as her. Having her as Shepard's romance feels strange at times...