andysilv87 wrote...
Ieldra2 wrote...
andysilv87 wrote...
Yeah, I certainly don't mind going OT but hopefully we can find something Miranda related to discuss soon. 
All right. Here is a question for you:
How, do you think, does Miranda's and Shepard's future, in fact, their existence as what they are in the first place, relate to the future of humanity as a whole?
*Miranda represents a human optimized at the genetic level, with no changes to morphology. "Human, only better". This is one path that can be taken by the species as a whole.
*Shepard represents optimization by foreign-matter implants. This is another path that can be taken. It can also be taken to the extreme, resulting in characters who aren't really human anymore.
Two more paths are imaginabe:
*Genetic adaptation to different environments, including changes in morphology. That would result in a human species fragmented into differently adapted sub-species, and may in time result in populations becoming a species of their own (a species as opposed to a race is defined by only being able to procreate with others of the same species).
*And the ultra-conservative path: leave everything to random chance as it has been in the past.
And I hope this post does not get drowned in chat so fast that nobody notices its existence.
Well, I have to say you raise some interesting points. Unfortunately it's quite early in the morning at the moment and I'm having a very slow day so I seem to be struggling to get my head around your post.
One thing I will say is I expect Miranda's optimization to be the level all humans strive to reach in the future, her level of genetic engineering will probably become the norm providing the technology becomes more widely available.
Yes, that's what I think, too. Miranda's optimization is unproblematic because it preserves human identity mostly unchanged. It poses no challenge except to fundamentalists.
Foreign-matter implants like Shepards will influence human culture, and decisions will have to be made about what's considered desirable and what not. But they won't change the species as such, because they can't be passed on.
Regarding the other paths, it's interesting to note that no alien species has tried environmental adaptation at the genetic level. I would've thought that with thousands of years of technological civilization, someone would have. But no, the Krell move to a different world without even trying, taking the risk of death by environment-induced disease rather than trying to adapt. An interesting blind eye, since from today's point of view that knowledge may require a hundred years or more of research, but it's less miraculous than FTL spaceflight or biotics.