jlb524 wrote...
I always like to think (in my wild imagination) that Liara feels guilty because of that whole scene. She delayed Shepard a bit with her reluctance to leave with the rest of the crew. If you think about it, if Shepard was just a few seconds quicker retrieving Joker and getting him into the escape pod, she would also have been able to get into the escape pod and would have survived. So I think Liara would blame herself for Shepard's death because of this, especially after hearing Joker re-tell the story of how Shepard died..... 'If I would have just listened to her the first time, she would have made it to the escape pod in time and would still be alive.'
Liara would feel that her love for Shepard was somewhat responsible for her death and this would eat her up inside....tragic stuff.
I think that's the case, J. We know from Redemption that Liara blames herself for Shepard's death, and that already the guilt and pain is beginning to eat her up inside. That's really sad, and like you say extremely tragic. We've theorised so many ways in which Liara has suffered over the past two years, and what kind of pain and worry she's experiencing mentally and emotionally. Every single one of these theories is entirely possible, and would make sense. What if it does turn out to be the case that everything we theorise turns out to be true, and Liara has suffered and been emotionally tormented on a massive scale like that? That would be so heartwrenchingly sad. I feel so bad for Liara, and just how much she's suffered.
Next time I play the intro to ME2, I'm going to have Shepard rush to Joker as quickly as possible in the vain hope that history will change and she'll jump into the escape pod with him. I know it'd never happen, but still.....

Shepard can then be with Liara, and she won't have to suffer.