50907 réponses à ce sujet

[Ulathar]

pf17456 wrote...

Does anyone consider that your actions regarding SB might be influenced by who exactly the SB is ? I mean suppose it's some Pitney Fore type character as opposed to some evil TIM type.

Who exactly the SB is won't influence my decision, unless it's someone we've already met. If the SB is a totally new character, then my answer to your question would be no. There are things that would have an influence on my decisions concerning the SB though.


And we reached page 1500 - Liara is very pleased

Modifié par Systemlord Baal, 17 juin 2010 - 06:00 .

[Master Wolf]

pf17456 wrote...

Does anyone consider that your actions regarding SB might be influenced by who exactly the SB is ? I mean suppose it's some Pitney Fore type character as opposed to some evil TIM type.

I think the SB is Shai'ra think about it she has access to a lot of secrets after all  and all her clients trust her and almost all of them are importante people.

Modifié par Master Wolf, 17 juin 2010 - 06:03 .

[Andaius20]

hello folks how's the thread progressing?

[Tyrannosaurus Rex]

I haz Evil!Liara


../../../uploads_user/1360000/1359707/31286.jpg

Credit goes to Indigowolfe.

[Derumiel]

Hello, my fellow Liara fans!

Hitting 1500 pages. Awesome! Liara's proud.

[Tyrannosaurus Rex]

Shavon wrote...

That would sure make things interesting if the SB was Shaira.

Well. She does **** all the politicians on the presidium, she must have snagged some sensitive information while doing it.

[Master Wolf]

LesEnfantsTerribles wrote...

I like the idea that the Shadow Broker is that group of 12 Protheans who used the Conduit to reach the Citadel, and alter the keepers. They could be being kept alive artificially by technology.

How would Liara feel about that? The last remenants of the people she's been passionate about for her entire life?

But the SB have been helping the Reapers if in the past these Protheans have fought them why help then now?

[pf17456]

LesEnfantsTerribles wrote...

I like the idea that the Shadow Broker is that group of 12 Protheans who used the Conduit to reach the Citadel, and alter the keepers. They could be being kept alive artificially by technology.

How would Liara feel about that? The last remenants of the people she's been passionate about for her entire life?

Even more conflictual would be if the SB turned out to be Liara's long lost father. Then what ?

[TMA LIVE]

Man, I hate writing in the Nightwriter's Liara thread. All I said is that I don't like Liara asking me to help her with the Observer quest, and that I felt blackmailed (which is just how I felt, people have different views, don't tase me). All I keep getting asked is WHY, WHY, WHY! YOUR WRONG!. Man, it's just my opinion. I just don't like what Liara's becoming at the end of the day. Still want to take her out for dinner in hope I can save the romance one day.

[pf17456]

LesEnfantsTerribles wrote...

Light indoctrination, perhaps.

I speculate the SB may be another Saren, subjected to light indoctrination in order to be transformed into a useful pawn of the Reapers.

Well Liara did kind of feel sorry for Saren. Who knows, SB may be a useful ally and not killing him might assure Liara's presence on the Normandy. I'd like that.

[Master Wolf]

Perhaps after SB failed in recover Shepard's body Harbinger decided to make him pay in a productive way and after the colecter ship misson the report mention something about Harbinger information network being as big as SB and cerberus perhaps that's because he's geting is information from SB, but I think that the SB was only indoctrinated after Redemption because he is prety defiante in the first issue.

Modifié par Master Wolf, 17 juin 2010 - 06:59 .

[pf17456]

TMA LIVE wrote...

Man, I hate writing in the Nightwriter's Liara thread. All I said is that I don't like Liara asking me to help her with the Observer quest, and that I felt blackmailed (which is just how I felt, people have different views, don't tase me). All I keep getting asked is WHY, WHY, WHY! YOUR WRONG!. Man, it's just my opinion. I just don't like what Liara's becoming at the end of the day. Still want to take her out for dinner in hope I can save the romance one day.

Well her 'coffee cup' mentality does suggest her anger is getting the better of her much like the the conflicts raised in the other loyality missions but what's different about Liara's is that you don't have the opportunity to see it through to it's conclusion, at least not yet but opting to not help her in my opinion would have been like telling Garrus that you were not going to the Citidal because murder is wrong.

[pf17456]

LesEnfantsTerribles wrote...


I actually hope that we can convince Liara that killing the Shadow Broker will not ease her of her pain and grief, and will not result in her feeling happy again. I want to comfort Liara, try to console her, help ease her emotional pain and torment. Liara would then hopefully realise that offing the Shadow Broker is not going to solve anything.

What I would then like is the ability to take the Shadow Broker into custody, and have him stand trial infront of the Citadel Council. I still feel that he's a menace that must be removed.

That option would be consistant with most of the other loyality missions.

[TMA LIVE]

pf17456 wrote...

TMA LIVE wrote...

Man, I hate writing in the Nightwriter's Liara thread. All I said is that I don't like Liara asking me to help her with the Observer quest, and that I felt blackmailed (which is just how I felt, people have different views, don't tase me). All I keep getting asked is WHY, WHY, WHY! YOUR WRONG!. Man, it's just my opinion. I just don't like what Liara's becoming at the end of the day. Still want to take her out for dinner in hope I can save the romance one day.

Well her 'coffee cup' mentality does suggest her anger is getting the better of her much like the the conflicts raised in the other loyality missions but what's different about Liara's is that you don't have the opportunity to see it through to it's conclusion, at least not yet but opting to not help her in my opinion would have been like telling Garrus that you were not going to the Citidal because murder is wrong.

Well, I do do the quest in the end, but I (me personally) didn't like that she asked me to help kill someone, and that if I didn't help, she'd kill all 5. That's it. And I said that, because (from my Shepard's POV), he doesn't know about the Shadow Broker and his body. He just knows Liara wants to kill him because he might have Feron, and that killing the Observer makes her closer to killing him. I would continue with more to say, but I'm really, really, really tired of typing the same thing.

[jlb524]

TMA LIVE wrote...

Well, I do do the quest in the end, but I (me personally) didn't like that she asked me to help kill someone, and that if I didn't help, she'd kill all 5. That's it. And I said that, because (from my Shepard's POV), he doesn't know about the Shadow Broker and his body. He just knows Liara wants to kill him because he might have Feron, and that killing the Observer makes her closer to killing him. I would continue with more to say, but I'm really, really, really tired of typing the same thing.

I think it comes down to this:  does your Shepard trust Liara, trust that she is doing the right thing, or not?  Perhaps your Shepard doesn't trust her enough.  We (and Shepard) don't have much information on the whole Liara/SB deal, so 'blindly' helping Liara is a sign of trust.

[Master Wolf]

TMA LIVE wrote...

Well, I do do the quest in the end, but I (me personally) didn't like that she asked me to help kill someone, and that if I didn't help, she'd kill all 5. That's it. And I said that, because (from my Shepard's POV), he doesn't know about the Shadow Broker and his body. He just knows Liara wants to kill him because he might have Feron, and that killing the Observer makes her closer to killing him. I would continue with more to say, but I'm really, really, really tired of typing the same thing.

I also didin't like wear Liara ask me to kill someone, but to be fair she has killed a lot of people  for Shepard.

[TMA LIVE]

jlb524 wrote...

TMA LIVE wrote...

Well, I do do the quest in the end, but I (me personally) didn't like that she asked me to help kill someone, and that if I didn't help, she'd kill all 5. That's it. And I said that, because (from my Shepard's POV), he doesn't know about the Shadow Broker and his body. He just knows Liara wants to kill him because he might have Feron, and that killing the Observer makes her closer to killing him. I would continue with more to say, but I'm really, really, really tired of typing the same thing.

I think it comes down to this:  does your Shepard trust Liara, trust that she is doing the right thing, or not?  Perhaps your Shepard doesn't trust her enough.  We (and Shepard) don't have much information on the whole Liara/SB deal, so 'blindly' helping Liara is a sign of trust.

Well when it comes to my Shepard, he feels like he doesn't know her anymore. He wants to trust her, but doesn't, because he feels like she's a completley different person, and won't talk to him (at least that's how I felt on my first playthrough). That's just my POV, anyways. Well, I don't know about "Don't trust". Maybe it's just too hard to believe. I don't know.

Modifié par TMA LIVE, 17 juin 2010 - 07:16 .