Pacifien wrote...
Nozybidaj wrote...
Not sure the forum has a big enough :eyeroll: emote for that.
So I take it you didn't really like my theory, but rather than explain why, you decided to go for dismissive. I actually wouldn't mind reading the why.
Me too, actually. (Though given my history with Nozy I understand difficulty in believing that.)
I see possibilities in your take, Pacifien. The problem I have with it is probably the very problem Nozy is rather clumsily alluding to himself -- we Liara fans tend to have fallen for the geeky girl we first saw in the original game. So to suggest that it's not really
her that we first see can be upsetting... plus, I have to admit, some of that original-game personality seems to show through from what I've seen from her in LotSB. I personally think that her awkwardness around Shepard, along with her thirst for knowledge, is still a large part of her character. (That drive she has to do what's right, too, seems to be a significant undercurrent in the first game, then takes over in the comic -- yes, I'm considering it part of my theory. Story-wise, it's not as horrible as people say. Feel free to remember how horrible people consider it when grading that comment; anyway -- to be her primary trait in the retail release... even into Lair.)
To Nozy's credit, he's been very consistent in railing against the recharacterization of Liara as 'grim!dark', which in his opinion was either done to shelve her or sideline her, or just because 'grim!dark' is KEWL. Truth be told the past eight months... well, the first six of the last eight, that is, before some maleShep vs. femShep broke the spine of the fan club ... has been his side arguing that for some reason (EA not wanting the controversy of a lesbian character in the game was a popular choice -- try and guess how many times I mentioned Sims 3 and Dragon Age to counter?), BioWare was clearly trying to eliminate Liara as a character by first making her undesirable... versus lesEnfantTerribles's side arguing that EA wouldn't be so stupid as to derail a character so beloved as Liara. (Most of les's side, myself included, spend most of our time in our group lately.)
And ... well, I'd be so jerky as to declare victory for my side, except that I'll admit, I wasn't fully sure that the problem was understood. (That is, us ME1 Liarasexuals didn't see the connection between who we saw first and the scary kinda ruthless woman sitting behind the desk on Illium. I never really thought it was a derailed character, but I definitely thought we deserved many blanks being filled in, which to Casey and Christina's credit, I think they all were addressed in Lair.) But I guess what I'm trying to say in my long, rambling fashion, is that I really don't think that this was the
true reveal of her character... it was more the fleshing out of the character we already knew, under dire circumstances.