Ce sujet est fermé
scmadsen wrote...
LesEnfantsTerribles wrote...
Go with ME2, 100% People need to realise that the presentation in the comic is so poor and contradictory, that you can't really take any of it serious and at face value.
I mean, look at how it doesn't depict Liara handing over the corpse to Cerberus as such a massively traumatising, guilt inducing soul destroyer. It's ridiculous.
The bottom line is, they screwed up by not having Liara state all of her motives for hunting the Shadow Broker, and didn't show all of the emotions and suffering and guilt she's had to deal with for two years, as it's showcased in ME2. ME2 makes it plainly clear that Liara is suffering, and it's because of her love for Shepard. Redemption shows only little of that.
Trust the game, and nothing else, Do not take the comic at face value.
To play devil's advocate here...Liara could be broken up over Feron and not Shepard...if she was truly in this dark place, because she loves and misses Shepard...then why not go with Shepard, and sort it all out on the Normandy...if the very fiber of her being, is that she loves and misses Shepard with all her heart and soul...then wouldn't going with Shepard, no matter what Shepard is now, be more important then anything? Liara isn't going to figure out what Cerberus did to Shepard, or what Shepard has become, by sitting in her office.
Valid arguments, all -- I think, to continue my free-association, that we've found out just how Liara was misled. Liara thinks it's entirely possible that Shepard, at least as she knows Shepard, is gone for good anyway, and she lets Feron get captured/killed for effectively nothing. (I STILL haven't seen the summation on the group, by the way, but most of the salient points have come out already, including the specific quotes I've been going on.) So she feels she has to atone for her selfishness?
Another random thought, in the critically-mixed-reviews-Buffy-Season-Eight comics, written by THE Whedon by the way, Willow says that she brings back Buffy in the Season Six opener, pretty much ... because she couldn't let her go. And she feels guilty about that ... especially accounting for how Buffy made it into heaven and all. This is yet another factor, Shepard might be in a better place according to Liara's beliefs, and she's getting yanked back into this plane of existence... though at least she doesn't have to claw through a coffin and dig herself out like Buffy did.
Retour en haut
