Ce sujet est fermé
Issue is not that is off topic really.runescapeguy9 wrote...
At this point I think it would be better to let them finish the conversation.DarkwanderStorm wrote...
but anyway TALI WOOO
Guest_runescapeguy9_*
Yes, but trying to stop them has already failed. Perhaps if we bring out the big guns....DarkwanderStorm wrote...
screw that
Modifié par sergio71785, 20 février 2010 - 06:19 .
Guest_Commandr Bond_*
cBselfmonkey wrote...
Commandr Bond wrote...
A ruling government where only a few of the constituents are represented shouldn't exist. What gives the turians, asari, and salarians the right to rule over every other race, other than "We got here first."?
And, as I said, while there is no way of knowing whether the races were developing AI or not, it seems HIGHLY unlikely that all three were following that rule.
The council shouldn't exist in the first place.
They get to rule exactly because they got their first. They've got more ships, higher populations, control more territory and thus have more resources etc... The Asari, Salarians and the Turians just have more then the other races at this point so they get to be in charge. Works the same way here on Earth with larger Global 'super-powers'. Whether you try and make it look nice and pretty with laws and rules might will always make right.
As for the Council not existing at all...where does that leave the galaxy as a whole? Even a cumbersome government is more useful then anarchy.
Guest_SU37_*
Hey, don't say things like that.DarkwanderStorm wrote...
screw that
runescapeguy9 wrote...
Yes, but trying to stop them has already failed. Perhaps if we bring out the big guns....DarkwanderStorm wrote...
screw that
Are we back on topic
SU37 wrote...
Hey, don't say things like that.DarkwanderStorm wrote...
screw that
Except would require pressurization and scrubbing of bathroom. Unlikely.sergio71785 wrote...
Hey, I had a thought. You know what'd be a really nice thing? If Shepard gave his private bathroom to Tali. I can see how a private bathroom would benefit her and make her life easier.
"Don't mention it, Tali. It's no real loss for me. In fact, don't tell anyone, but...I didn't even know that bathroom was there until last week when I went to feed my hamster.. "
runescapeguy9 wrote...
At this point I think it would be better to let them finish the conversation.DarkwanderStorm wrote...
but anyway TALI WOOO
Commandr Bond wrote...
cBselfmonkey wrote...
Commandr Bond wrote...
A ruling government where only a few of the constituents are represented shouldn't exist. What gives the turians, asari, and salarians the right to rule over every other race, other than "We got here first."?
And, as I said, while there is no way of knowing whether the races were developing AI or not, it seems HIGHLY unlikely that all three were following that rule.
The council shouldn't exist in the first place.
They get to rule exactly because they got their first. They've got more ships, higher populations, control more territory and thus have more resources etc... The Asari, Salarians and the Turians just have more then the other races at this point so they get to be in charge. Works the same way here on Earth with larger Global 'super-powers'. Whether you try and make it look nice and pretty with laws and rules might will always make right.
As for the Council not existing at all...where does that leave the galaxy as a whole? Even a cumbersome government is more useful then anarchy.
You've got to be kidding me. You believe that because they have bigger guns they have a right to rule over every thinking being in the galaxy?
And I'm not suggesting that no government exist. I'm suggesting that this one, which serves the exclusive purpose of three species, should be replaced by one in which all are represented.
Jake71887 wrote...
runescapeguy9 wrote...
At this point I think it would be better to let them finish the conversation.DarkwanderStorm wrote...
but anyway TALI WOOO
Political discussions are grounds for Thread locking...
Commandr Bond wrote...
And I'm not suggesting that no government exist. I'm suggesting that this one, which serves the exclusive purpose of three species, should be replaced by one in which all are represented.
Himmelstor wrote...
Except would require pressurization and scrubbing of bathroom. Unlikely.sergio71785 wrote...
Hey, I had a thought. You know what'd be a really nice thing? If Shepard gave his private bathroom to Tali. I can see how a private bathroom would benefit her and make her life easier.
"Don't mention it, Tali. It's no real loss for me. In fact, don't tell anyone, but...I didn't even know that bathroom was there until last week when I went to feed my hamster.. "
Guest_Commandr Bond_*
Lareit wrote...
He's not aruging a divine mandate or a morally virtuous right to rule, he's arguing a tactical advantage that allows them to rule through economic and militarial power. It's true it's how the world works.
Might always makes right.
turelhimvampire wrote...
Actually I think this discussion has practically tripped over a very Tali related question...
WHY did the council kick out the quarians, as lets face it - we all agree that it was a harsh reaction to the issue at hand. They have shown a lot more leniency to other species for doing this a LOT worse than creating the geth. I mean come on, the geth haven't even left the veil since around the time they kick the quarians out to the time Saren lead the Heretics against the citadel.
Interesting discussion to have, and very much Tali related, at least as I see it.
Modifié par RaoulG4668, 20 février 2010 - 06:29 .
DarkwanderStorm wrote...
screw that
turelhimvampire wrote...
Actually I think this discussion has practically tripped over a very Tali related question...
WHY did the council kick out the quarians, as lets face it - we all agree that it was a harsh reaction to the issue at hand. They have shown a lot more leniency to other species for doing this a LOT worse than creating the geth. I mean come on, the geth haven't even left the veil since around the time they kick the quarians out to the time Saren lead the Heretics against the citadel.
Interesting discussion to have, and very much Tali related, at least as I see it.
No one has might to contest them. Their or other species' stake is irrelevant.Commandr Bond wrote...
Lareit wrote...
He's not aruging a divine mandate or a morally virtuous right to rule, he's arguing a tactical advantage that allows them to rule through economic and militarial power. It's true it's how the world works.
Might always makes right.
But I was never arguing that the council races didn't have the resources to rule, I'm arguing that the council races shouldn't be the only ones with a stake in the government....
runescapeguy9 wrote...
Yes, but trying to stop them has already failed. Perhaps if we bring out the big guns....DarkwanderStorm wrote...
screw that
Are we back on topic
The_KFD_Case wrote...
runescapeguy9 wrote...
Yes, but trying to stop them has already failed. Perhaps if we bring out the big guns....DarkwanderStorm wrote...
screw that
Are we back on topic
Goddamn that figure can bring a grown man to his knees.....Then again I did study politics and have two university degrees in it so it will take more than that to distract me completely.
Guest_SU37_*
Retour en haut
