TGFKAMAdmaX wrote...
Phil725 wrote...
TGFKAMAdmaX wrote...
Phil725 wrote...
*snip*
I find that situation incredibly unlikely. You're basically completely ignoring Tali's personality to this point. 
not really. she has shown that she doesnt trust the geth or really think of them as people...
Yes, but she's also very intelligent, and isn't a complete moron. At no point would there be no choice to dissuade Tali against complete annihilation of the geth, unless the geth have made it perfectly clear that they intend to kill all the quarians or something. She isn't a random quarian who is so caught up in bred hatred that she can't think for herself. If there is a better solution (which there would be,) Tali would be open to it.
All indications we have so far are that the geth are willing to accept peace, and that peace is the only realistic way for the quarians to reclaim their homeworld. If you have to ignore that for the hypothetical situation, it starts to lose some meaning.
when u talk to legion he states that he does not have an opinion on the talks of peace... and the geth have never declared war on the quarians...only the quarians have engaged the egth...and tali could very likely try to kill all of them for her people... so there is nothing i am ignoring...
Again, there is no indication anywhere that Tali would try to kill all of the geth for her people. She, more than any other quarian has seen the perspective of the geth (from Legion.) She has worked side by side with them, and knows that they don't want to fight the quarians. What possible motivation would she have for suddenly wanting to kill them all?
If the only way to dissuade Tali from that view was to kill her, that isn't the same Tali that's been with me for the first two games.