HK01 wrote...
Katosu wrote...
sergio71785 wrote...
Letting the migrant fleet die would result in Tali hating you forever. You basically let her entire race go extinct--and yes, Quarians would go extinct at that point. No way the remaining few throughout the galaxy could repopulate them.
With that said, I would probably let her live too. Just because I like her a lot, and fortunately it's a video game so I don't have to face the consequences. 
You guys are right; Migrant Fleet is too extreme.
What if we said it was her original ship? The Neema that you had to choose between?
Even easier, wouldn't endanger the whole species and fewer dead.
Yeah, that makes a lot more sense from a gameplay perspective. We would all pick Tali obviously. She would be upset that she was picked over the ship/other quarians, but I think you could convince her that she was too important to you to let die. I still don't want lose/lose situations, but this one seems like it could be implemented well into the game and wouldn't ruin everything.
The other situation is just over the top.