FatherNestor wrote...
I think this pic fits your description perfectly. Am I right?
Yes, that is one of my more favorite Tali renditions

VettoRyouzou wrote...
God I hope not >.o.
I'm sorry something just isn't right about that picture I have no idea what it is but I dislike it greatly, and it not that it not well done or anything I just hate it with no way to explain why.
...
Why here my fav.
Yes many people are put off by the 4 nostrils, but for me it speaks on so many level from the day dreaming gaze of a longing site of a wanting heart. As well as that of the idea she look human with out being human, that it show what defines aliens do all Human life faces have to look exactly like Ares or can they show the fact way alien life can evolves onto it own unique spin of something so familiar.
Run-on sentence is almost unreadable, periods and punctuation, please

Anyway, from what I gathered, you think that Nightcrawler Tali is alien without being human, and that you like that.
Honestly, I agree with you. I've always defended that picture from critics.
However, I have 2 main issues with that picture:
1) She is still a re-colored human. Dark blue skin, glowing eyes, and the odd dermal creases all over her face make her look non-human, but frankly I think it is still pretty unimaginitive from a design standpoint. To me when I think "alien", I think of things more like a differently-shaped skull, or an elongated neck. In 3-D terms, you could create that picture just by changing the texture on a human model -- the details are mostly superficial. IMO, a real alien design would require changing the geometry of the model. If they are just going to change her texture, honestly I'd rather just have them make her look entirely human.
2) The far more important issue for me regarding Nightcrawler Tali is that it simply doesn't fit Tali's personality. The glowing eyes are cold and inscrutible, and her face doesn't give the impression of being cute or endearing. I don't think her gaze looks "dreamy" at all, and if it is, it is only because of the way she is resting her face on her hand, not because of her expression. I appreciate the effort to make her look alien-but-human, but for me it is far more important to reflect the character's personality in their face, and that concept simply doesn't do that.
Modifié par Pauravi, 19 mars 2010 - 03:14 .