137512 réponses à ce sujet

[gkillerrin]

Goat_Shepard wrote...

Phil725 wrote...

danteshepard wrote...

Lividity Jones wrote...

Simon9one wrote...
snip

Jacob forever lost his bro status after he pulled that crap.

Not to argue but Jacob was trying to be nice and Tali was a little biitchy...
But even then I just stopped and said. "Oh, diick more there Jacob!"

Yeah, I'm not a fan of Tali in that scene, reminds me too much of what Miranda would do

Its really the only scene that casts Tali in a negative light when you think about it.  She stereotypes Jacob as a Cerberus dog without even trying to get to know him.  That's not my open minded sweet Tali

It isn't like she has no experience with people judging her for other people in her group's actions or anything

What about infiltrating the Flotilla and trying to blow up a starship would make Tali be open minded and sweet?

In jacobs defense that probally happened before he joined cerberus,
thats why he doesnt approve of it

Modifié par gkillerrin, 05 avril 2010 - 03:10 .

[Simon9one]

Phil725 wrote...

danteshepard wrote...

Lividity Jones wrote...

Simon9one wrote...
snip

Jacob forever lost his bro status after he pulled that crap.

Not to argue but Jacob was trying to be nice and Tali was a little biitchy...
But even then I just stopped and said. "Oh, diick more there Jacob!"

Yeah, I'm not a fan of Tali in that scene, reminds me too much of what Miranda would do

Its really the only scene that casts Tali in a negative light when you think about it.  She stereotypes Jacob as a Cerberus dog without even trying to get to know him.  That's not my open minded sweet Tali

It isn't like she has no experience with people judging her for other people in her group's actions or anything

Tali was harsh at first, but all her run-ins with Cerberus in the past had involved killing them and stopping sick experiments so it's understandable IMO.

It can be argued that Jacob was just being an idiot, poorly chosing his words.

But I really think he was hinting at the fact that the Quarians created the Geth.  And that was just a low blow, totally uncalled for.

[Shazzammer2]

le sigh...got classes tomorrow. Gotta go to bed. G'night everyone.

[Grif101]

gkillerrin wrote...

GuardianAngel470 wrote...

gkillerrin wrote...

Goat_Shepard wrote...

shnizzler93 wrote...

It would be awesome if there would be a series similar to Red vs. Blue for the ME universe

snip

Bloodgultch?

I love red vs blue. I have all 102 of the original episodes as well as the out of mind ones on my computer.

♥ RvB also have any of you seen the latest episode
http://redvsblue.com/archive/?id=1191

Hah! Just saw that, I've been waiting forever for them to continue from Recreation!:lol:

[Phil725]

Mukora wrote...

Phil725 wrote...

Yeah, I'm not a fan of Tali in that scene, reminds me too much of what Miranda would do

Its really the only scene that casts Tali in a negative light when you think about it.  She stereotypes Jacob as a Cerberus dog without even trying to get to know him.  That's not my open minded sweet Tali

It isn't like she has no experience with people judging her for other people in her group's actions or anything

Have you read ascension? I would hate him too... and I did when I first met him. I like to think that later Tali apologized and got to know him a little better.

Why hate Jacob?  He had absolutely nothing to do with the attack on the flotilla.  People hate Tali because the quarians invented the geth.  We all see that as wrong.  Why is it OK for Tali to hate all members of Cerberus without further knowledge?  Her and Jacob are in agreement with the attack on the flotilla being something that they're against, but she doesn't know that because she's already labeled him. 

It goes against her character, which is much more understanding.

[Ormagodenator]

Mukora wrote...

gkillerrin wrote...

are you guys talking about the quote where jacob said, introduce yourself to the new ships AI?

Yes.

imagine if no one told Tali about EDI.

Modifié par Ormagodenator, 05 avril 2010 - 03:12 .

[Goat_Shepard]

Phil725 wrote...

Mukora wrote...

Phil725
wrote...

Yeah, I'm not a fan of Tali in that scene, reminds me
too much of what Miranda would do [smilie]../../../images/forum/emoticons/unsure.png[/smilie]

Its
really the only scene that casts Tali in a negative light when you
think about it.  She stereotypes Jacob as a Cerberus dog without even
trying to get to know him.  That's not my open minded sweet Tali [smilie]../../../images/forum/emoticons/sad.png[/smilie]

It
isn't like she has no experience with people judging her for other
people in her group's actions or anything [smilie]../../../images/forum/emoticons/uncertain.png[/smilie]

Have
you read ascension? I would hate him too... and I did when I
first met him. I like to think that later Tali apologized and got to
know him a little better.

Why hate Jacob?  He had
absolutely nothing to do with the attack on the flotilla.  People hate
Tali because the quarians invented the geth.  We all see that as wrong. 
Why is it OK for Tali to hate all members of Cerberus without further
knowledge?  Her and Jacob are in agreement with the attack on the
flotilla being something that they're against, but she doesn't know that
because she's already labeled him. 

It goes against her
character, which is much more understanding.

Don't remember the scene exactly, been a month since I played. Jacob was nice at first but Tali was not immediately trusting as she should have. She trusted Shepard but wanted it to be clear that she only trusted him and those he commands. Jacob probably said the AI thing because of his broken pride, I woulda prolly done the same if she gave me that attitude. lol yeah right I'd crumble.

Modifié par Goat_Shepard, 05 avril 2010 - 03:13 .

[Simon9one]

Phil725 wrote...
snipped

People hate Tali because the quarians invented the geth.  We all see that as wrong.  Why is it OK for Tali to hate all members of Cerberus without further knowledge? 

She was Quarian by birth, not by choice.

And everyone has heard of Cerberus' dark past.  She saw Jacob as soneone willing to join an organization she hadn't heard a single good thing about.

[Lividity Jones]

Phil725 wrote...

Mukora wrote...

Phil725 wrote...

Yeah, I'm not a fan of Tali in that scene, reminds me too much of what Miranda would do

Its really the only scene that casts Tali in a negative light when you think about it.  She stereotypes Jacob as a Cerberus dog without even trying to get to know him.  That's not my open minded sweet Tali

It isn't like she has no experience with people judging her for other people in her group's actions or anything

Have you read ascension? I would hate him too... and I did when I first met him. I like to think that later Tali apologized and got to know him a little better.

Why hate Jacob?  He had absolutely nothing to do with the attack on the flotilla.  People hate Tali because the quarians invented the geth.  We all see that as wrong.  Why is it OK for Tali to hate all members of Cerberus without further knowledge?  Her and Jacob are in agreement with the attack on the flotilla being something that they're against, but she doesn't know that because she's already labeled him. 

It goes against her character, which is much more understanding.

Does Jacob even mention the attack on the Flotilla?

[BTG_01]

Simon9one wrote...

Tali was harsh at first, but all her run-ins with Cerberus in the past had involved killing them and stopping sick experiments so it's understandable IMO.

It can be argued that Jacob was just being an idiot, poorly chosing his words.

But I really think he was hinting at the fact that the Quarians created the Geth.  And that was just a low blow, totally uncalled for.

Apparently I'm the only one who remembers that scene as being relatively civil. Sure there was tension in the room, but I don't think that AI comment was some kind of subtle jab at Quarians.

btw, what can I get for my Simon points?

[Phil725]

Jake71887 wrote...

Phil725 wrote...

danteshepard wrote...

Lividity Jones wrote...

Simon9one wrote...
snip

Jacob forever lost his bro status after he pulled that crap.

Not to argue but Jacob was trying to be nice and Tali was a little biitchy...
But even then I just stopped and said. "Oh, diick more there Jacob!"

Yeah, I'm not a fan of Tali in that scene, reminds me too much of what Miranda would do

Its really the only scene that casts Tali in a negative light when you think about it.  She stereotypes Jacob as a Cerberus dog without even trying to get to know him.  That's not my open minded sweet Tali

It isn't like she has no experience with people judging her for other people in her group's actions or anything

I think it portrays her perfectly, she's always defensive of her people; and cerberus attacked the flotilla so she's still cautious of them. Though the fact she's willing to work on a cerberus vessel does show how accepting she is, even of people she doesn't trust or particularly like.

I don't know, I see Tali more likely to be cautious towards Jacob until she knows how he feels about Cerberus as whole.  She is openly hostile with him to start the relationship.  Surely she doesn't think that all Cerberus people are exactly the same.  She should be more understanding before labeling a whole group like that.

[gkillerrin]

Ormagodenator wrote...

Mukora wrote...

gkillerrin wrote...

are you guys talking about the quote where jacob said, introduce yourself to the new ships AI?

Yes.

imagine if no one told Tali about EDI.

*Tali goes down to Engeneering*
*Tali Walks down to her Station*

Tali: Ahh finaly were here how lets see whats up here

EDI: Hello Tali

Tali: WTF what was that

*takes out shotgun*

Tali: Who's there

*EDI Apears*

EDI: Me? why?

Tali: What a Ship AI...... SHEPARD

[Lividity Jones]

runescapeguy9 wrote...

Lividity Jones wrote...
Does Jacob even mention the attack on the Flotilla?

Tali brings it up.

So we don't really know his opinion on it?

[Simon9one]

BTG_01 wrote...

Simon9one wrote...

Tali was harsh at first, but all her run-ins with Cerberus in the past had involved killing them and stopping sick experiments so it's understandable IMO.

It can be argued that Jacob was just being an idiot, poorly chosing his words.

But I really think he was hinting at the fact that the Quarians created the Geth.  And that was just a low blow, totally uncalled for.

Apparently I'm the only one who remembers that scene as being relatively civil. Sure there was tension in the room, but I don't think that AI comment was some kind of subtle jab at Quarians.

btw, what can I get for my Simon points?

My approval and respect.

Also, I may sell smilies in the future.

[Goat_Shepard]

Simon9one wrote...

Phil725 wrote...
snipped

People hate Tali because the quarians invented the geth.  We all see that as wrong.  Why is it OK for Tali to hate all members of Cerberus without further knowledge? 

She was Quarian by birth, not by choice.

And everyone has heard of Cerberus' dark past.  She saw Jacob as soneone willing to join an organization she hadn't heard a single good thing about.

Wow, Phil juss got owned I like these discussions

[Phil725]

*delete*

Modifié par Phil725, 05 avril 2010 - 03:16 .

[Lividity Jones]

BTG_01 wrote...

Simon9one wrote...

Tali was harsh at first, but all her run-ins with Cerberus in the past had involved killing them and stopping sick experiments so it's understandable IMO.

It can be argued that Jacob was just being an idiot, poorly chosing his words.

But I really think he was hinting at the fact that the Quarians created the Geth.  And that was just a low blow, totally uncalled for.

Apparently I'm the only one who remembers that scene as being relatively civil. Sure there was tension in the room, but I don't think that AI comment was some kind of subtle jab at Quarians.

btw, what can I get for my Simon points?

I'm sorry, but you just don't bring up the one thing that lead to the attempted genocide of a culture without it being a "jab".

[gkillerrin]

runescapeguy9 wrote...

Lividity Jones wrote...

runescapeguy9 wrote...

Lividity Jones wrote...
Does Jacob even mention the attack on the Flotilla?

Tali brings it up.

So we don't really know his opinion on it?

He states he had nothing to do with it, and that he wants to work with Tali anyways.

Its also a fact that Jacob doesnt trust Cerberus, TIM says so himself, and so does Jacob if you walk to him about it.