siltsonata wrote...
I don't really adore Thane, (I've ah...I've never actually managed a playthrough romancing him, I just watched the videos on youtube. It's not my fault! Garrus's is just too good!) I just like him as a non-LI and I can see where his fangirls are coming from. (There was one moment where he really caught me off-guard in my first playthrough: His line about "The taste of another's tongue in your mouth". He had me blushing in a good way, but that was the last time he ever had me.)
Yeah, the tongue-in-your-mouth line kind of snuck up on me too, I
was like "oh reeeeeeally now, hmmmm...hmm hmm hmm." I romanced him one
of the times; I think despite the uberangst
his romance will be rewarding if Shep's able to find a cure for him.
Then all his problems will be solved, yayyy!
I do see where you're coming from with the overly-sappy feeling though: part of the reason Thane's romance doesn't compete with Garrus's for me is the ANGST-ANGST-ANGST that poor Thane has to go through. Dying, yes, that sucks, Oh, your wife's dead, that su-OH, your kid hates you, THAT SUCKS. Man, galaxy: give the guy a break. All those issues aren't appealing to me in a romantic way. Shepard has enough baggage of her own to deal with.
Garrus on the other hand doesn't really dump any of his problems on Shepard except for his revenge-thing, which is interesting because, ISSUES: You know he has them. His dad disapproves of his life, His mentor died and then came back to life, his squad got killed and he blames himself...and yet he doesn't go on and on and on about it. Not saying that Thane doesn't have a right to talk about the things that bother him in pretty much every conversation, I just like that Garrus doesn't. Personal taste.
I do like that about Garrus, but in Thane's defense...Shep IS always asking people to talk about their problems. heh. I just wish that more characters than, well, Jacob, would ask her the same in return.