kglaser wrote...
Yeah, that's why I don't like it...it goes against canon.
This. Garrus is not gay. I have no problem with putting in same/sex LIs. In fact, I encourage it, but demanding that Garrus or Tali be gay is the same as me demanding Leliana and Zevran be straight. I always thought the argument that "he's an alien, therefore if he is open to femshep romance, he should be open to dudeshep romance too" or "putting our sexual orientations on aliens doesn't make sense" were poor arguments. Yes, he's an alien, but turians also behave in many human-like ways which is the only thing that makes alien romances possible in ME. If they had truly "alien" orientations, romance likely wouldn't work at all. Since we've translated so much that is definitely human into ME aliens, sexual orientation does not seem like that weird of a thing to project. Gender does matter in attraction. That's why I'm attracted to Garrus and Thane, but not Tali or Liara. I'm straight and only attracted to things which are male. I don't think it's weird at all for the same situation to be present in alien species, especially ones that have recognizably "male" and "female" genders.
Long rant and I don't mean to offend anyone. I also don't mind sharing an LI (Zevran, Sky, etc.) but ONLY if they were designed to be bi from the beginning.
I know some people will argue that Garrus and Tali were altered to find humans attractive purely for fanservice, but I don't think that that's a valid argument. For one, I don't think they find humans in general attractive but specifically Shepard. I think that Shepard sort of epitomizes the potential of his/her gender. His/her "maleness" or "femaleness" kind of transcends his/her human physiology, and I think it's that coupled with Shep's personality that turns Garrus and Tali's eyes. It's not just that they admire Shepard....darn it's hard to explain. It's like they really admire Shepard's spirit only to begin with and then one day they also realize "wow, Shepard is the opposite gender of me and is a stellar example of that gender" and that's when the sexual attraction starts. Their previous admiration was not sexual, I don't think. Anyway, maybe that makes no sense, but that's how I interpret it anyway. I just don't think sexual orientation is something you can determine by flipping a switch.
And yes, I really mean it when I say I hope the same sex crowd gets the LIs they are looking for as well. I will share Garrus if I must, but if there ever is maleshep/Garrus content, I hope it is well hidden so I can pretend it's not there to maintain my suspension of disbelief.
Wall of text=ouch. Sorry and I really am not trying to ****** anybody off. I apologize if I did.
Modifié par Ragabul the Ontarah, 30 avril 2010 - 12:55 .