Loving the last 5 or 6 pages of Garrus discussion! As to the best romance choice for a total Renegade - I say Garrus too! He really is a win-win-win for any personality type. For a Paragon, it's kind of like a true love that was always right in front of you type-thing. For a Renegade, well Garrus has Renegade tendencies himself, so he's a match that way. But he is also very receptive to whatever it is Shepard may be feeling. If she's a bad girl, he plays along, joking and encouraging. If she's a good girl, he ends up learning from her saintly ways. For Paragades, he's there for her too, either way

[quote]lovgreno wrote...
[quote]Cerrydd wrote...
I kind of like that he is a hothead, it's part of his charm. He does the role of the young rebel rather well.
Sure, the endless calibrations are kind of annoying but then again everyone is busy calibrating/cleaning engines/researching/etc...etc...
The fact that he is not a female turian is a bit annoying but I guess I can live with that.
Other than that it's hard to think of any real flaws with Garrus.
[/quote]
I like that he has hotheaded tendencies too. It's part of who he is - a part of his complex whole that we all love so much. And I love when he does hotheaded things, and Shepard calls him out on it making him realize it... it's just so cute when he can admit his mistakes. Kinda like what I was saying above about a Paragon Shep romancing him.
So, I could probably come up with a list of flaws in Garrus, but they are all part of what makes him special. It's hard to imagine if BW made him any other way - I'm not sure I would like him as much.