Collider wrote...
What do you think Garrus would advocate in the following scenarios?
1. Toombs
2. Samesh Bhatia
3. Consort (Would Garrus even think helping her would be worthwhile? Etc)
4. Chorban/Jahleed
5. Rita's sister
6. Doctor Michel
7. I Remember Me (Colonist)
8. Jacob's father
For Toombs, it depends on if the meeting was before or after Dr. Saleon. If it was before, Garrus would have let Toombs take the shot. If it was after, and Shepard took the paragon route, he'd try to convince Toombs that bringing in the doctor for trial would be better. However, if it was apparent that Toombs was going to have none of it, Garrus would then let him take the shot. Because Garrus might have learned some patience from Shepard's handling of Dr. Saleon, but he doesn't go completely paragon after it.
For Samesh Bhatia, he would let the Alliance keep the body. The geth were a very real threat and there is very little known about them, the Alliance needs the research. I'm not sure he'd be able to do what my Shepard was able to do, which is explain to Bhatia that his wife was a soldier and, as such, would continue to serve the Alliance even in death so that her sacrifice could save more lives. So yeah, I'm not sure if Garrus would have been crafty enough to explain that.
I doubt Garrus would have much cared for the Consort's problems.
If he spoke with Chorban first... Chorban would have likely never told a C-Sec officer what he was doing anyway. So likely he starts with Jaleed, proceeds to confront Chorban, gets annoyed with Chorban's talk about the data, then kills Chorban's guards and proceeds to interrogate Chorban to figure out what the hell is going on. Then likely Chorban and Jaleed both end up in jail.
For Rita's sister, he likely wouldn't get involved. He knows it's a C-Sec operation and leaves it to whoever has jurisdiction over the case.
For Doctor Michel, he likely has come to view her as a good acquaintance after their first meeting. He'd probably intercede on her behalf. It likely would have ended in gunfire because, again, I don't see Garrus having quite the same persuasive ability as Shepard to talk through a situation.
For Talitha, the former slave, I'm not sure what Garrus could have done. She's human and incredibly distrustful of everyone around her at the moment. She never would have let a turian get as close to her as she did Shepard, so Garrus would have probably told the others to handle it. Get a tranquilizer dart and hope she falls forwards instead of backwards.
For Jacob's father... hmm. Probably leave him for the exiles to finish off. View Jacob's father as not worth the air he's breathing and not worthy the mercy of a quick death.