Guest_Malcolm Theory_*
Zhijn wrote...
Is this about Ash being out of character, or do you find that the game are taking your lord's name in vain?.
Zhijn wrote...
I thought it made perfect sens what she said. Shepard is a goddamn hero and back from the death.
Modifié par Malcolm Theory, 20 février 2010 - 01:03 .
Pauravi wrote...
Also, Delan was a ****** and I wish I could have given him to the Collectors in exchange for Lilith.
luk3us wrote...
Figure of speech, stop reading so much into things.
Pauravi wrote...
I think it is perfectly appropriate, and I know lots of religious people who take the lords name in vain all the time. Clearly she is into sex before marriage, too
I understand your gripe. I felt that way at first, and I still do a little bit, especially in the greeting, but there are some reasonable dialogue options there. You can explain that you were actually out of commission while you were being revived by Cerberus. Of course, that pisses her off just as much. Instead of realizing that you'd still be dead if it weren't for them, she starts raving about how evil they are.Oisrisso wrote...
off the top of my head, I can't think of another point in the game where I didn't find the conversation wheel options satisfactory. You'd have thought he could explain the situation to her properly, at least, as opposed to making it seem like Shepard was out and about, but covert?
Malcolm Theory wrote...
Alright, now this may seem like a pointless little piece of dialogue to pick at, but I'm a huge Ash fan, and as a result, I find the line completely out of character.
I already know that Chris E'letoile didn't write her role in ME2 (it's obvious that her's and Kaidan's cameos were written by the same person), but who on earth came up with that line? Religous people usually don't use the term "god" to describe people.
The first time I watched it, it made me raise my eyebrow. The second time, I shook my head. The third time I cringed. And now I just mute it. It's a ridiculous line, that illustrates the problems of handing over a character to another writer.
I'm not really looking for a discussion, I'm just voicing my opinion on the matter.
Guest_Malcolm Theory_*
luk3us wrote...
Figure of speech, stop reading so much into things.
Modifié par Malcolm Theory, 20 février 2010 - 01:23 .
Guest_Malcolm Theory_*
PiercedMonk wrote...
It's not likley I'll encounter Ashley on Horizon any time soon--unless one of her sisters is a colonist there and has an urn full of radioactive Virmire soil on her mantle--but without having seen the speach myself, that doesn't sound very out of character.
Choosing Kaidan was the right choice from a logistics standpoint. Not having to listen to Ashley's poetry or ridiculous nonsense is just a bonus.
Modifié par Malcolm Theory, 20 février 2010 - 01:28 .
PiercedMonk wrote...
It's not likley I'll encounter Ashley on Horizon any time soon--unless one of her sisters is a colonist there and has an urn full of radioactive Virmire soil on her mantle--but without having seen the speach myself, that doesn't sound very out of character.
Choosing Kaidan was the right choice from a logistics standpoint. Not having to listen to Ashley's poetry or ridiculous nonsense is just a bonus.
Modifié par Ulicus, 20 février 2010 - 01:33 .
Fair enough, fair enough.Malcolm Theory wrote...
Doug84 wrote...
Malcolm Theory wrote...
Religous people usually don't use the term "god" to describe people.
You mean, the people who are religous that you know wouldn't use that term.
Yes, I realise that I generalized. But in this case, that generalization would hold true most of the time no matter what part of the world you are in.
It's a fact: most religous people do not use the term to describe a person. Now I realize ithat she's not serious (do you people think I'm a moron?Don't answer that.), but it's still annoys me to no end.
Malcolm Theory wrote...
PiercedMonk wrote...
It's not likley I'll encounter Ashley on Horizon any time soon--unless one of her sisters is a colonist there and has an urn full of radioactive Virmire soil on her mantle--but without having seen the speach myself, that doesn't sound very out of character.
Choosing Kaidan was the right choice from a logistics standpoint. Not having to listen to Ashley's poetry or ridiculous nonsense is just a bonus.
With all due respect, considering the fact that you obviously don't like, nor care about the character, I don't really hold your opinion on the matter in a very high regard.
Guest_Malcolm Theory_*
Ulicus wrote...
Death closes all: but something ere the end,
Some work of noble note may yet be done,
Not unbecoming men that strove with Gods.
I didn't find it particularly out of character.
Modifié par Malcolm Theory, 20 février 2010 - 01:39 .
Malcolm Theory wrote...
luk3us wrote...
Figure of speech, stop reading so much into things.
Last time I checked, calling someone a "god" isn't a common figure of speech.
And I'm not "reading into things". I'm reacting to some spotty dialogue.
Guest_Malcolm Theory_*
Aedan_Cousland wrote...
Ashley voices her belief in God to Shepard, but that doesn't necessarily make her devout. It could just be that with the threat of imminent death hanging over their heads, Ashley found some faith in the proverbial foxhole.
So I don't necessarily see that comment as being out of character. After all depending on how you play the game, she might also have sex with Shepard, even though they aren't married. If she has no problem breaking the 6th Commandment, why would she have a problem with breaking the 1st?
Modifié par monkeycamoran, 12 septembre 2010 - 03:01 .
Skilled Seeker wrote...
Who says she's christian!? Since when did religious = christian only? Maybe her religion has no problem with sexy time.
Modifié par Funkcase, 20 février 2010 - 01:50 .
Modifié par Funkcase, 20 février 2010 - 01:49 .
Retour en haut
