Aller au contenu

Photo

Is Infiltrator with Anti-Material Widow strongly over-powered?


  • Ce sujet est fermé Ce sujet est fermé
102 réponses à ce sujet

#76
sandman7431

sandman7431
  • Members
  • 123 messages
The soldier is a superior killer to the infiltrator. Soldiers get a much higher damage bonus with heightened adrenaline rush than infiltrators do with assassin cloak. They also have the vindicator to mop up the leftovers with unlike the infiltrator, who relies very heavily on the sniper rifle. You can talk about the smg all you want but the fact is that when playing as a sniper, you set up shop far away from your targets. Running low on ammo with infiltrators means that you have to get much closer in order to use the smg or just use the hand cannon. It's really not that bad but the soldier can just whip out the vindi and start doing damage at relatively long range with superior accuracy.



The soldier also has more health, faster storm speed and an eviscerator for close encounters. The only thing the infiltrator has on the soldier is the cloak but unfortunately, when you cloak, enemies often duck behind cover until you reappear. It's very frustrating. Incinerate is a useful skill but it activates the cooldown-preventing you from cloaking. The soldier can adrenaline rush with the widow or vindicator and cause massive damage with a cooldown that is half as long as the cloak cooldown.

#77
rumination888

rumination888
  • Members
  • 1 297 messages

themaxzero wrote...

Well pretty much any area pre the Infiltrator getting enough points to get his passive going. Mordins recruitment with the regenning Krogan and Vorcha (pretty much any Bloodpact area). Any place with lots of Barriers as well. To top it off the Soldier gets to pick up his Widow in Dantius Towers except it's called the Viper.

The Soldier is better against Armour and Health pre Viper and everything post Viper. The Infiltrator only catches up when they get the Widow.


Unless you don't import an ME1 save, you will have enough points to start your passive going at the start of the game.
And because of Zaeed/Jacob/Grunt, the only reason to dump points in Incendiary/Disrupter in the early game is to gimp yourself.

I will concede that the Soldier performs the sniper role better than the Infiltrator once the Soldier picks up the Viper, but that is an even smaller part of the game than all the times before the Viper + all the times after the Widow.

#78
OneBadAssMother

OneBadAssMother
  • Members
  • 1 086 messages
Infiltrators with viper gets to do more damage per shot (ammo wise) with the repeated sniper focus and headshots though - pop pop, duck, pop pop, repeat... Hence I didn't pick up widow for my infiltrator main.

Didn't use cloak at all, didnt need to.

Modifié par OneBadAssMother, 09 mars 2010 - 05:28 .


#79
themaxzero

themaxzero
  • Members
  • 966 messages

rumination888 wrote...

themaxzero wrote...

Well pretty much any area pre the Infiltrator getting enough points to get his passive going. Mordins recruitment with the regenning Krogan and Vorcha (pretty much any Bloodpact area). Any place with lots of Barriers as well. To top it off the Soldier gets to pick up his Widow in Dantius Towers except it's called the Viper.

The Soldier is better against Armour and Health pre Viper and everything post Viper. The Infiltrator only catches up when they get the Widow.


Unless you don't import an ME1 save, you will have enough points to start your passive going at the start of the game.
And because of Zaeed/Jacob/Grunt, the only reason to dump points in Incendiary/Disrupter in the early game is to gimp yourself.

I will concede that the Soldier performs the sniper role better than the Infiltrator once the Soldier picks up the Viper, but that is an even smaller part of the game than all the times before the Viper + all the times after the Widow.


Well he is an example.

In Mordins recruitment mission their is point where you meet Bloodpact for the first time. They are having a shootout with two Blus Suns. In that area there is 2 Krogans, 2 Varren, 2-3 Flamethrower guys and about 10 regular Vorcha. I spend much of that fight under ARush and rotate through all my weapons.  Virtually all my Sniper shots a 1 shot kill headshots. Despite all this I have still watch my ammo. I watch Gatsby's video (who is quite an agressive player) and he fights the same amount of enemies I do.

So I honestly want to know how you approach that fight that leaves ammo a complete no concern.

Modifié par themaxzero, 09 mars 2010 - 06:42 .


#80
Acero Azul

Acero Azul
  • Members
  • 367 messages
 infiltrator and vanguard both own.

#81
OneBadAssMother

OneBadAssMother
  • Members
  • 1 086 messages

In Mordins recruitment mission their is point where you meet Bloodpact for the first two. They are having a shootout with two Blus Suns. In that area there is 2 Krogans, 2 Varren, 2-3 Flamethrower guys and about 10 regular Vorcha. I spend much of that fight under ARush and rotate through all my weapons. Virtually all my Sniper shots a 1 shot kill headshots. Despite all this I have still watch my ammo. I watch Gatsby's video (who is quite an agressive player) and he fights the same amount of enemies I do.


I spent most of that fight trying to get Jacob to shoot something with his incinary ammo so it will stop regenerating health!!!! Damn they regenerate crazy on insanity.

That was before I learnt how powerful A-rush is however with the sniper rifle.

Modifié par OneBadAssMother, 09 mars 2010 - 06:09 .


#82
rumination888

rumination888
  • Members
  • 1 297 messages

themaxzero wrote...

Well he is an example.

In Mordins recruitment mission their is point where you meet Bloodpact for the first two. They are having a shootout with two Blus Suns. In that area there is 2 Krogans, 2 Varren, 2-3 Flamethrower guys and about 10 regular Vorcha. I spend much of that fight under ARush and rotate through all my weapons.  Virtually all my Sniper shots a 1 shot kill headshots. Despite all this I have still watch my ammo. I watch Gatsby's video (who is quite an agressive player) and he fights the same amount of enemies I do.

So I honestly want to know how you approach that fight that leaves ammo a complete no concern.


Hmm... if that part is what I think it is, then that is one of the areas where you can play the Infiltrator to fit its namesake.

You basically kill off the enemies in front while advancing(i'm almost positive theres a couple of ammo strewn across the room), then infiltrate(cloak) past the enemies to the other side.
At that point you will have cut off the respawn. You can either ignore the enemies after that and proceed past them, or mop the remaining enemies up while your squadmates flank them from the other side.... all done while carrying the mantis.

Modifié par rumination888, 09 mars 2010 - 06:44 .


#83
WillieStyle

WillieStyle
  • Members
  • 1 298 messages

themaxzero wrote...

Well he is an example.

In Mordins recruitment mission their is point where you meet Bloodpact for the first time. They are having a shootout with two Blus Suns. In that area there is 2 Krogans, 2 Varren, 2-3 Flamethrower guys and about 10 regular Vorcha. I spend much of that fight under ARush and rotate through all my weapons.  Virtually all my Sniper shots a 1 shot kill headshots. Despite all this I have still watch my ammo. I watch Gatsby's video (who is quite an agressive player) and he fights the same amount of enemies I do.

So I honestly want to know how you approach that fight that leaves ammo a complete no concern.

Huh?! That fight is crawlilng with thermal clips.  There's 1 or 2 right in front of the entrance to the room. There's 3 or 4 upstairs on the sniper perch.   You can typically get a few more by advancing on the enemy once you've thinned them out. 

#84
themaxzero

themaxzero
  • Members
  • 966 messages

rumination888 wrote...

themaxzero wrote...

Well he is an example.

In Mordins recruitment mission their is point where you meet Bloodpact for the first two. They are having a shootout with two Blus Suns. In that area there is 2 Krogans, 2 Varren, 2-3 Flamethrower guys and about 10 regular Vorcha. I spend much of that fight under ARush and rotate through all my weapons.  Virtually all my Sniper shots a 1 shot kill headshots. Despite all this I have still watch my ammo. I watch Gatsby's video (who is quite an agressive player) and he fights the same amount of enemies I do.

So I honestly want to know how you approach that fight that leaves ammo a complete no concern.


Hmm... if that part is what I think it is, then that is one of the areas where you can play the Infiltrator to fit its namesake.

You basically kill off the enemies in front while advancing(i'm almost positive theres a couple of ammo strewn across the room), then infiltrate(cloak) past the enemies to the other side.
At that point you will have cut off the respawn. You can either ignore the enemies after that and proceed past them, or mop the remaining enemies up while your squadmates flank them from the other side.... all done while carrying the mantis.


And I can ARush past them (the bullets and targetting is too slow) and run into the clinic. But what happens if you actually fight them? Or do you never fight them?

Modifié par themaxzero, 09 mars 2010 - 06:46 .


#85
rumination888

rumination888
  • Members
  • 1 297 messages

themaxzero wrote...

And I can ARush past them (the bullets and targetting is too slow) and run into the clinic. But what happens if you actually fight them? Or do you never fight them?


I'm almost positive theres a bunch of ammo inside that room. So if you wanted to go slow, you can still do the entire thing with just the Mantis and without cutting off respawn.

#86
themaxzero

themaxzero
  • Members
  • 966 messages

rumination888 wrote...

themaxzero wrote...

And I can ARush past them (the bullets and targetting is too slow) and run into the clinic. But what happens if you actually fight them? Or do you never fight them?


I'm almost positive theres a bunch of ammo inside that room. So if you wanted to go slow, you can still do the entire thing with just the Mantis and without cutting off respawn.


You sure you could, have you ever tried it?

#87
rumination888

rumination888
  • Members
  • 1 297 messages

themaxzero wrote...
You sure you could, have you ever tried it?


Would you like me to fraps it?

#88
OneBadAssMother

OneBadAssMother
  • Members
  • 1 086 messages
That room, if you go around the location, behind the mercs and up the stairs you have a great sniping location with about 4-5 clips lying on the floor. All enemies have to charge up the stairs on the other side too, they aren't smart enough to flank. It's a perfect defensable spot. Krogan/Varrens running up the stairs BAM BAM BAM... then go back to your window and snipe the rest (there are 3 - one for each squad mate).

#89
siccore

siccore
  • Members
  • 28 messages

TheLostGenius wrote...

Not when you are cloaked. I have a 70% damage bonus and I wear the 10% head shot visor (which is the coolest looking headset in the game). Unless they are triple layered (barrier/shield/health) Almost every head shot is an instantaneous kill.


sorry - the coolest looking visor is the Dr. Pepper **** :D

Image IPB
Image IPB

geht it here
http://hellforge.gam...Promo-DLC-Codes

Modifié par siccore, 09 mars 2010 - 08:03 .


#90
Breakdown Boy

Breakdown Boy
  • Members
  • 790 messages
I have to say I have never played Infiltrator before but this thread has made me want to. I love playing the soldier and ilove the Reverant, powerfull and lots of ammo, after accurace upgrade it is all nasty! Add AP rounds and it's all over!

#91
siccore

siccore
  • Members
  • 28 messages
and to the topic - i played first with the inflitrator and now with a vanguard. and after watching some vids - for example from Sabresandiego - i find the vanguard more powerfull...if u play it right and have a good group with you. charge is good for offense and defence. same with cloak - but you get faster away out of a tight situation with charge.

#92
bchesson

bchesson
  • Members
  • 129 messages
The Widow is an awesome rifle as far as damage is concerned but I just can't seem to get over it's lack of ammo capacity. I prefer the Revenant for close/medium range and the Viper for long range. The Viper doesn't pack the punch of the Widow but I can set up down range and take out targets all day with it's ammo capacity. Sure I may need 2 or rarely 3 headshots to take down a tough opponent but 8 or 9 shots with the Widow and you get the unnerving silence of an empty clip.

#93
OneBadAssMother

OneBadAssMother
  • Members
  • 1 086 messages
Soldier with widow and a-rush 1-shots majority of enemies so by the time they are all dead, you only need 6 clips to fill it up to 12. (2 shots per clip, compared to 1 shot per mantis clip)

#94
themaxzero

themaxzero
  • Members
  • 966 messages

OneBadAssMother wrote...

Soldier with widow and a-rush 1-shots majority of enemies so by the time they are all dead, you only need 6 clips to fill it up to 12. (2 shots per clip, compared to 1 shot per mantis clip)


Depends on clip. Clips dropped from enemies give 1 clips that a pre placed give 2.

#95
OneBadAssMother

OneBadAssMother
  • Members
  • 1 086 messages
O.o never noticed that!

#96
Lycidas

Lycidas
  • Members
  • 802 messages
I totally agree the Infilitrator is fun and thus needs do be nerfed hard. Same goes for Vanguard and Adept. classes are not supposed to be fun WE want the game to be a damn hard and boring grind...:blink:

Modifié par Lycidas, 09 mars 2010 - 10:06 .


#97
Autoclave

Autoclave
  • Members
  • 388 messages

_-Greywolf-_ wrote...

The Widow is a beast, with my soldier I would choose it over the Revenant any day.

But I have a question, did anyone actually find the Revenant any good? I mean sure it would be good a close range but the spread is horrible even when you burst fire and quite frankly even if I had access to the Revenant I would still use my Vindicator.


Revenant with AP Ammo or Warp Ammo simply tears everyhing into shredds.

#98
Noble 1

Noble 1
  • Members
  • 130 messages

JohnnyDollar wrote...

TheLostGenius wrote...

Whats the Revenant and how do you get it?

It's a heavy machine gun that is only good in close quarters.  The extra weapon achievement is earned at the collector ship.  Only a soldier can pick the Revenanat.


Are you sure? I thought everyone could pick it...

#99
NorrYtt

NorrYtt
  • Members
  • 2 messages
Sniping is fun. Feeling overpowered is fun. This is a single-player game; the notion of "over-powered" doesn't apply because the computer AI doesn't mind that you are being unfair. It's happy to play Whack-A-Mole where you control the whacker and it controls the moles.

"Balancing" Infiltrator-Widow gameplay would probably involve a mechanic like enemies throwing grenades at you when they are being sniped at. But that mechanic would also ****** off all players, Infiltrators included.

In the end, it's more important that the game is fun.

BioWare did it right.

Modifié par NorrYtt, 07 avril 2010 - 11:39 .


#100
Eternalist

Eternalist
  • Members
  • 66 messages
Unless you count short to mid range combat, the Infiltrator is still superior to the soldier with sniping, as the time-warping effects of Adrenaline rush are passive with the Infiltrator.



The Widow is slightly overpowered, but bear in mind when you've the choice, Assault Rifle training can be equally effective.