The Angry One wrote...
So you base this judgement on 2 soldiers you know, both of which are different from each other.
I like the comparisons between Ashley/FemShep too, because they
don't act that different other than Shep is more experienced and an
officer, and commits the crime of having a different voice.
2 is always more than 0 in my book.
No, femShep and Ashley are nothing alike, at all.
First of all, Ashley talks more like an actual woman being a woman. She's a soldier, but she's not shy about what she is, a FEMALE soldier. While femShep sounds more like she's trying to hide her femininity by actually forcing her voice to a lower and more serious pitch. This might be just me, but that's how I experience Hale's voice-achting.
Second, Ashley clearly defends her position as a female soldier. Clearly even 200 years ahead of us, people are still prejudiced about women in the army, Ashley tries to show that she can be a good soldier and still a respectable woman. She does this without losing her femininity. And about emotions, not to be sexist or anything, but most women are not good at hiding or pushing away their emotions, neither is Ashley, so that's a plus on BioWares writing skills.
Now femShep, she doesn't have anything of all this. She's just maleShep reskinned with a female model and a female voice-actress.
And while I'm okay with a harsh and cold male Shepard that rarely shows his true emotions and when he does it looks awkward, I'm all perfectly fine with that because it suits the male character. But femShep? No, she's to much of an ice queen to me.
Modifié par Luc0s, 24 février 2010 - 11:18 .