201 réponses à ce sujet

[Jzadek72]

Tell me, how does your brain manage to support your body's systems?

[shinobi602]

Jennifer Hale (Female Shepard). It's not terrible, but it's not a pleasing/charming voice in my opinion. She always sounds like she's forced to do the lines, or sounds either angry, upset, monotone, or just uninterested.

That's my view at least.

Modifié par shinobi602, 24 février 2010 - 11:04 .

[BigGuy28]

This guy is more obsessed with Tali than the creepy Tali fans are.



There really needs to be a way to ignore posters, if there is and I can't find it someone please point me to it.

[Torguemada]

Borschtbeet wrote...

Maj.Pain007 wrote...

Mornith.


/end thread.

Good one.  I'm not sure she was as bad as Tali but she was pretty damn close.  It sounded like she was bored devliering her lines.

Pretty sure that intensional, the bored voice fits the character.

[Sir Ulrich Von Lichenstien]

BigGuy28 wrote...

This guy is more obsessed with Tali than the creepy Tali fans are.

There really needs to be a way to ignore posters, if there is and I can't find it someone please point me to it.

I did create a post about that very idea, sadly it seems to have fallen on deaf ears from Bioware, here is a link.

http://social.biowar...10661/1#1248384

[Jamin101]

Eshaye wrote...

RhythmlessNinja wrote...

FemShep:
"If I chose to I could kill every person in this room and walk out unscathed..."

ManShep:
"If-I-choose-to-I-could-kill-eve-ry-per-son-in-this-room-and-walk-out-un-scathed-beep-beep-I-am-a-robot."

Case closed.

ok now you're just losing your credibility on the whole monotone thing, sounds nothing like that & now your just sounding ridiculous & super bias.

Actually I totally agree with Angry One. FemShep delivers her line effortlessly, it flows like water and is believable, while MaleShep sounds forced and I didn't get where he sounded threatening at all. It was more like :*sigh* I have to wave my gun around.... *more sigh* 

Is it a coincidence people were saying she only likes female voices and since then only a few posters have agreed with her, interestingly enough all were female.

Maybe guys like guy shepard and vice versa

[Jamin101]

Eshaye wrote...

RhythmlessNinja wrote...

FemShep:
"If I chose to I could kill every person in this room and walk out unscathed..."

ManShep:
"If-I-choose-to-I-could-kill-eve-ry-per-son-in-this-room-and-walk-out-un-scathed-beep-beep-I-am-a-robot."

Case closed.

ok now you're just losing your credibility on the whole monotone thing, sounds nothing like that & now your just sounding ridiculous & super bias.

Actually I totally agree with Angry One. FemShep delivers her line effortlessly, it flows like water and is believable, while MaleShep sounds forced and I didn't get where he sounded threatening at all. It was more like :*sigh* I have to wave my gun around.... *more sigh* 

Is it a coincidence people were saying she only likes female voices and since then only a few posters have agreed with her, interestingly enough all were female.

Maybe guys like guy shepard and vice versa

[LiquidGrape]

Mark Meer.

Sorry dude, but you're still about as compelling as sandpaper.

[didymos1120]

Jamin101 wrote...

Is it a coincidence people were saying she only likes female voices and since then only a few posters have agreed with her, interestingly enough all were female.

Maybe guys like guy shepard and vice versa

I agreed.  I'm not a girl.  Lemme double-check...nope still not a girl.  Still don't much like MeerShep either, though he has his moments.

[The Angry One]

Jamin101 wrote...

Is it a coincidence people were saying she only likes female voices and since then only a few posters have agreed with her, interestingly enough all were female.

Maybe guys like guy shepard and vice versa

Considering that's a baseless accusation, it's irrelevant.
I do find it funny how people criticise Hale for playing the character how it's meant to be played, if you consider Shep's history at all.

[JMKnave]

How many troll posts does it take to fill the empty void of one's soul?

[Knoll Argonar]

Meer's good at his job, I liked him a lot, specially in ME2. He was kinda bland in some minor convos, but that happens with Hale too, and more than what people here think/remember.



The only guy I really hate is the Normandy's cooker. Is that voice Udina's? Because I want to punch him in the face no matter what.

[jstne]

Without sounding like a rabid FemShep fan... Mark Meer. At least for important characters, because I'm sure there's some throwaway NPC that was voiced by some guy a Bioware employee met on the bus that sounds awful.

He's not a bad voice actor. He's decent actually, but in a game where dialogue is so important his voice leaves something to be desired, especially for the main character. Hale has nuance in her voice that really leaves me thinking "damn, she really nailed that line" sometimes.

Modifié par jstne, 24 février 2010 - 11:47 .

[TheLostGenius]

Compare Martin Sheen in Apocalypse Now to ME2. ME2 is cringe inducing in comparison to his performance in that. Humanism is far from perfect in video games, and even hiring the best talent to do VOs isn't going to fill in that void. That said he was one of the best in the game, just nothing compared to his physical appearances and performances in film.

[Arhka]

Samara, voice is a bit flat, hard to hear emotion(but maybe that's her character more than the voice actor)

[didymos1120]

TheLostGenius wrote...

Compare Martin Sheen in Apocalypse Now to ME2. ME2 is cringe inducing in comparison to his performance in that.

I've seen it.  Many times.  Willard is an utterly different character, therefore Sheen doesn't act like that. He acts like...a different character. 

[didymos1120]

Arhka wrote...

Samara, voice is a bit flat, hard to hear emotion(but maybe that's her character more than the voice actor)

That's definitely the character.  You can rag on Samara about it a bit depending on the dialogue options you choose.

[Cytonox]

JMKnave wrote...

How many troll posts does it take to fill the empty void of one's soul?

This troll post just fill's my left nut. Which I use to teabeg other trolls for complaining about stuff they don't understand


Go back to the WoW forums (Talking to the author of this thread)

Modifié par Cytonox, 25 février 2010 - 12:46 .

[ExtremeOne]

the voice actor for Tali

[Azint]

You know what? This is just disappointing.
A Borshtbeet thread bashing Tali that is not funny. All of his other "scrogging" threads and such, while completely off-the-wall, were hilarious. I'm a Tali fan and I'm not even upset or offended because how funny the discussions were, but this is just a disappointment.

Also I thought Meer and Hale did a fine job in their roles.

[Ecael]

Is it a coincidence people were saying she only likes female voices and
since then only a few posters have agreed with her, interestingly
enough all were female.

Maybe guys like guy shepard and vice versa

Not true. I think Hale has great Paragon lines and Meer has great Renegade lines.

I don't hate either of them.

[Jimbe2693]

I find the OP's post hilarious tbh, I share his hatred for Tali

[Peavio]

i liked tali's voice alot

[CLime]

Knoll Argonar wrote...

Meer's good at his job, I liked him a lot, specially in ME2. He was kinda bland in some minor convos, but that happens with Hale too, and more than what people here think/remember.

The only guy I really hate is the Normandy's cooker. Is that voice Udina's? Because I want to punch him in the face no matter what.

You shush, Rupert is fantastic.  His voice lends a lot of character to an otherwise minor character.  Whoever is in charge of this stuff at Bioware did a great job casting the crew overall.  Gardner, Donnelly, Daniels, the returning crew from ME1 are all memorable characters despite their small roles thanks in no small part to their distinctive voices.