Aller au contenu

Photo

Same Sex Romances


7455 réponses à ce sujet

#1
DaeJi

DaeJi
  • Members
  • 1 045 messages
So, you clicked on this topic and you maybe be thinking, “Shepard isn’t
a fruit” or maybe “why do you guys keep making a new topic. Stop
spamming and drop it.” If these are one of the two thoughts that run
through your brain before you clicked and opened this topic, continue
reading.


FAQ:



  • Why are you guys on the 5th topic or why
    is this the Nth topic of this kind on the first page? This is
    spam.


    The previous threads were closed due to trolling, fighting, length and a brief memorandum issued by Mr. Stanley Woo.

    Mr. Woo posted:

    The last five pages (at least) are full of bickering, personal
    attacks, and politics. This topic gets a brief moratorium until people
    can learn to a) debate like civil, mature individuals, and B) not feed
    the trolls.



    As always, I'm available for questions and concerns, but come on,
    people. You seemed to have a great community and discussion going on in
    here, supporting each other, bringing up some good points. And you let
    one person with an opposing view destroy the thread? Take a breather,
    then let me know when y'all think you can start a new thread without
    the hate against haters. Thank you.

    From: social.bioware.com/forum/1/topic/103/index/1100184/71


    Note: He told us to, "Take a
    breather, then let me know when y'all think you can start a new thread
    without the hate against haters. Thank you.
    " Not cease and desist
    with any threads of this kind. We received his "blessing" per se to
    start this thread so please no "This is spam," or "You're beating a
    dead horse," comments.



    The purpose of this thread is to get other people's opinions. We
    want to know why people *don't* want the option so that we can try to
    find a solution that is agreeable to their desires as well as our own.
    We all want the game to be the best, so why not discuss ways to make
    the game more enjoyable for everyone? Please keep political and social
    norms out of your post.



    Keep in mind we're in no way affiliated to the other same-sex
    topics. We may want the same things, but we're going about it a
    different way.


  • Shepard isn’t a fruit. Why are you trying to force this on me?

    No, Shepard is NOT a fruit, but that doesn’t mean he/she can’t like
    someone of the same-sex. All most of us want is a decent meaningful
    relationship that isn’t tacked on. Some of our ideas include colored
    font so that you can’t accidentally have your Shepard flirt someone you
    don’t want to and choosing a crush or sexual orientation on the import
    screen. We’re also open to any other suggestions.


  • Why do you guys want this so bad?

    As tyddrwsau stated so eloquently:

    Games are great, in contradistinction to other media, because of
    their interactive value. It is a rather different story - in that place
    where imagination fills in the silent voids - if Commander Shepard is
    relaxing with Kaidan after both heroes have learned to relax just a
    little with one another, or if the Commander has passed through Jack's
    brusque shell and confided in the real person underneath, or if the
    Commander fear's Thane's illness and ignominious death to disease more
    than the Reapers. In Mass Effect we play the Hero. Through
    relationships with the squad, and especially the romances, we gain
    access to those precious few moments where we can imagine Shepard the
    person, not Shepard "the-one-who-wields-the-gun."




    For a gay player, used to being treated as a) nonexistent B) comic
    relief c) standard trope tragic figure in various media, the option to
    play a really cool gay hero can be a really meaningful thing. For an
    open-minded player of other persuasions, it's another lens through
    which to imagine a parallel tale: "so THIS is what makes Shepard who he
    is, and THIS is what's important to him!"



    It's about character development. Who *is* Commander Shepard, and
    why do we care? The romance helps us to imagine. A same-sex romance
    broadens the possibilities, and all to the good.


  • Why are people so persistent that BioWare include gay and lesbian relationships in Mass Effect?

    Two of the past 3 BioWare IPs have featured gay relationships.
    (Dragon Age:Origins and Jade Empire) All 3 have featured lesbian
    relationships.



    BioWare has a pretty consistent history on including these types of
    relationships and that is why fans are asking for it to be included in
    Mass Effect as well. Most people just figured that Mass Effect would be
    no different so there was no discussion of the issue until now. Nobody
    is demanding that BioWare include gay and lesbian relationships in
    their games. People are just asking for consistency, which thus far
    they have not provided.



    Between half a dozen new romance options on top of the three
    originals from the first game, it's clear that the developers spent
    quite a bit of time building the romantic subplots and character
    developments seamlessly into the grand ongoing saga of the series. To
    have such a varied and diverse ensemble of interesting romance options
    and yet not a single gay male in sight is incredibly conspicuous, and
    deserves reexamination.


  • Do you plan on turning everyone gay?

    No, most of us would like the former bisexual squadmates to be
    reimplemented, this includes, Tali, Thane, Jack and Kaidan. (someone
    correct me on that if I'm wrong) We also wouldn't mind a BRAND NEW
    character. Please share your thoughts in the poll or topic if you have
    any ideas for people.


  • I'll be uncomfortable if even gay behavior is even hinted at.

This is why this topic is here. We'd like to here from both sides
of fence. How would you like to compromise this? Some of our ideas
include:

  • Have you choose your crush on the import screen so if you
    choose no one as your crush then no one of the same sex will hit on
    you.
  • Colored font that warns you if you click it you're be stepping
    into a relationship dialogue. We're not hoping for a Zevran type
    character we just want a normal character of the same sex who's open to
    the idea of a same-sex relationship.
    Have it implemented by way of DLC so if you don't DLC then
    there's no way you even know Thane, Tali or whomever is open to
    same-sex relationships.

View post below for more details.



TL;DR? Well, then if this was too long
and you didn’t read and you end up posting something that has already
been discussed in these few paragraphs be sure that you will
be reported. If you'd like for us to elaborate on
certain things or would like to carry on an educated discussion this is
fine, but please no "Hell no" and that's it.


We’d like to keep a clean topic that stays away from politics and
just focuses on how we’d like this implemented. If you have any
questions feel free to ask and vote in our polls.
social.bioware.com/989831/polls/2140/

social.bioware.com/985984/polls/2730/

[/list]

Modifié par DaeJi, 28 février 2010 - 01:36 .


#2
Arik7

Arik7
  • Members
  • 1 095 messages
Marketing
  • Didn’t you read the article by Mazuka?

    Ray Mazuka said:
    Here's how the games are different: Dragon Age is a first person narrative, where you're taking on an origin and a role, and you are that character at a fundamental level. It's fundamentally about defining your character, including those kinds of concepts. In Mass Effect it's more a third person narrative, where you have a pre-defined character who is who he is, or she is. But it's not a wide-open choice matrix. It's more choice on a tactical level with a pre-defined character. So they're different types of narratives, and that's intentional.

    We're not saying that one approach is better than the other. In our previous games, as we did in Jade Empire, as we did in KOTOR, as we did in Baldur's Gate, and many games before and in the future, we enable those kinds of choices, whereas in Mass Effect it's more about Shepard as a defined character with certain approaches and worldviews, and that's just who he or she is. So we constrain the choice set somewhat, but enable more tactical choices and enable a deeper, richer personality, because it's more focused around defining one character, it's not as wide open. But that's by choice.

    It's first person versus third person narrative, and the types of choices you get to make within that are related to that, whether you've got a pre-defined character or a wide-open character. Some of our games have been wide open, and some have been more constrained, and we'll probably continue both kinds of character development in the future.
    -From: http://xbox360.ign.c.../1066954p2.html 


    Yes we have and most of us have come to the conclusion that it made no sense to have a predefined character for everything BUT sexual orientation for male Shepards. This would mean playing Mass Effect as anything other than default male "John" Shepard, the neutral/renegade Soldier, would be "wrong" and technically shouldn't be allowed.

    Shepard is an N7 Operative and a Spectre. That's all that's set in stone. Everything else - sex, personality, personal history, sexuality - that's up to the player.
  • Wouldn't gay characters ruin sales?
No, based on Dragon Age: Origins and Mass Effect sales. Dragon Age sold more in it's first 12 weeks and it contains same-sex romances for both sexes.
-http://tinyurl.com/y9nnqor; Thanks to Jimmy Fury for the graph.
--Note: We did ME1 and Dragon Age: Origins because they both lacked a solid fanbase before coming out.

Modifié par Arik7, 27 février 2010 - 03:56 .


#3
BrianWilly

BrianWilly
  • Members
  • 345 messages
Suggestions:



Suggestion 1:

Jimmy Fury suggested:

Turn the picture frame into a DLC pack.



The way things work now, if you import an ME1 save game with an LI,
Shep has a picture frame in his/her cabin with the LI's picture. So why
not just tweak that same thing (so everything is already in the game,
just needs a wee bit of coding) slightly to allow LI-less players to
choose which picture is shown in the frame. It would work like this:



  • *Only* imported save games that have NO Love Interests and
    New Game players would be able to use the feature. That way it doesn't
    change, or even give the option to change, an existing romance
    storyline.
  • The picture can only be chosen once. Basically you get to the
    cabin, click the frame, and you get to choose between Kaidan, Ashley,
    Liara, and none.
  • Once you choose a picture the game adjusts slightly depending
    on who you picked. The romance-version of the Kaidan/Ashley/Liara
    conversations become available.
  • It includes some coding that makes two Mass Effect 2 squad
    mates (1 per Shepard gender) available for same sex infidelity. Thane
    and Tali probably since they were already planned.



Issues this would resolve:

-No retconning unless the player actively chooses to do it. Hence it being an optional DLC instead of a patch

  • Those uncomfortable with any sort of Same-Sex romance.
  • No patching of Mass Effect 1.
  • Those in favor of same-sex, get it and new game players get to
    experience the romance storyline of their choosing and carry it into
    Mass Effect 3.
  • It will not just be a "gay love DLC." It's for everyone. Those
    in favor of same-sex romances, people who didn't play ME1, and people
    who just want to play a new Shepard, to try different paths.




Suggestion 2:

octoberfire suggested:

Just like paragon and renegade is color-coded we're hoping that
romance for ALL romances are color coded to pink or some other various
color, and possibly change script so you know when you're about to
accidentally/purposely start a romance. This would be similar to those
of you who've played Vampire: The Masquerade – Bloodlines.



Issues this would resolve:

  • Stop the accidentally started romances (like I did with Jacob)
  • Simple coding because all that would need to be done is change
    the colored font for romance, if it's just those who are already in the
    game, but unlocked.
  • For both same-sex and straight romances.






Suggestion 3:

sw33ts suggested:

Have a new section on the import screen that allows you to choose
your "crush." This can be anyone may it be straight or gay/lesbian.
These are for those people who romanced someone of the opposite sex but
now want to romance someone new or old. First there will be your LI
from ME1 which of course locked in place, if you have one, and then
below it will be a drop down box for other romances. This is where you
can either choose that you had a crush on Tali as a female in ME1 or
Garrus as a male in ME1. This will also work if you choose to import a
Shepard from ME2, so that if you romanced, for example Jacob in ME2 as
a Female, but now want to romance Tali then you can choose Tali and the
same options that were open for Male Shepard is now open for Female
Shepard. If you don't want to romance anyone of the same-sex in ME2/ME3
then just choose no one as your crush and no one of the same-sex will
approach you.



Issues this would resolve:

  • No same-sex options if you choose no crush.




Suggestion 4:

Sabul suggested:

Have the conversation in ME2 you have with Mordin unlock future romances in Mass Effect 3.



Issues this would resolve:

  • If you shoot down Mordin you don't have to worry about it in the 3rd game
  • If you're already romancing someone regardless of sex you don't have to worry about it.




Suggestion 5:

Jimmy Fury suggested:

Since BioWare plans on making DLC to connect the ME: Redemption comics to ME2, that could be used to bring in an LI.

There are two ways it could be done:



  • Introduce 2 new characters (1 female, 1 male) through
    the expansion and have only 1 of them selectable as a squad member at
    the end of the side story. Both can then be LI's for either Shep
    gender. That way everyone benefits from a new squad member. The other
    character can then be brought in for ME3 as an non-romance squad
    member.



    Issues this would resolve:

    • Everyone benefits from a new potential LI, and being able
      to only recruit 1 of them means nobody need fear dialogue that makes
      them uncomfortable.


  • Same thing just use Liara and Feron. Liara is already a f/f
    option and Feron has already been introduced through the comics, so no
    new characters would need to be designed. Again, have only 1 of the 2
    be recruitable as a squad member in ME2 and then bring the other in for
    ME3 and have them die thus making it more dramatic.



    Issues this would resolve:

    • Everyone benefits from a new potential LI, and being able
      to only recruit 1 of them means nobody need fear dialogue that makes
      them uncomfortable.




Suggestion 6:

Just reimplement the former bisexual squad members by way of DLC.

Issues this would resolve:

  • No extra coding
  • Very easy
  • Someone for everyone. This includes, Ashley, Kaidan, Thane, Tali, and Jack.

View the links below. If you find same-sex relationships uncomofortable then don't click.









http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2FCN5f1hEt8&feature=related



For the MShep and Kaidan Love Scene:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lPMOlEfhWGE&feature=related



For the MShep and Kaidan Reunion:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cWq4ZHZ6ExU&feature=related



For FShep and Ashley Love Scene:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Mwiqq-Y5r4&feature=video_response



For FShep and Ashley Reunion:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HCqoQJiy7NE&feature=response_watch




For MShep and Thane:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_d_7VRl87E0



For FShep and Tali voiceclips starts around 6:16:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NtVNqxjiH0Y


Modifié par BrianWilly, 27 février 2010 - 09:06 .


#4
CarpeOmnios

CarpeOmnios
  • Members
  • 191 messages
I'll admit I didn't read most of that, but I think it's good that Bioware implements gay relationships in their games. Not everyone is from the same cookie cutter, and gay people can be anyone. Even soldiers.



I don't understand why it would make anyone feel uncomfortable, though. Your sexuality isn't being questioned, after all...even if it was, shouldn't you be secure enough to not feel uncomfortable about it? Just sayin' in generall, not directing it at anyone.

#5
tmelange

tmelange
  • Members
  • 546 messages
I think your formatting has broken the table. It's hard for me to read but of course I support this thread.

Modifié par tmelange, 26 février 2010 - 02:11 .


#6
ARK of ILKS

ARK of ILKS
  • Members
  • 541 messages
I was on the previous thread related to this. Support it 100%.

#7
Lightice_av

Lightice_av
  • Members
  • 1 333 messages
Well, there's one thorough FAQ. At least from now on all the trolls can just be directed at it instead of trying to handle them one by one. If they don't want to read it, that's their loss.



The YouTube links seem to need a bit of work, however.

#8
Arik7

Arik7
  • Members
  • 1 095 messages

CarpeOmnios wrote...

I'll admit I didn't read most of that, but I think it's good that Bioware implements gay relationships in their games. Not everyone is from the same cookie cutter, and gay people can be anyone. Even soldiers.

I don't understand why it would make anyone feel uncomfortable, though. Your sexuality isn't being questioned, after all...even if it was, shouldn't you be secure enough to not feel uncomfortable about it? Just sayin' in generall, not directing it at anyone.

The reason we have this thread is because same-sex romances are NOT in Mass Effect 2.

There is a small f/f fling, but not a full romance.  As in ME1, there's ZERO indication that male homosexuality exists in the ME Universe.  (I am aware of Mass Effect Ascension and its gay character, however, I am talking about the Mass Effect games.)

#9
jlb524

jlb524
  • Members
  • 19 954 messages
I support this thread.

#10
Athelius

Athelius
  • Members
  • 109 messages
I'm thinking that part of it has to do with localisation in countries with anti-homosexuality laws, was a big enough problem with ME1 liara...

Also public pressure even in more legally modern countries.



Would be impressed if they passed up on money to do it anyway, but I can understand that they won't.

#11
Lightice_av

Lightice_av
  • Members
  • 1 333 messages

I'm thinking that part of it has to do with localisation in countries with anti-homosexuality laws, was a big enough problem with ME1 liara...



No. The only problem I heard of was in Singapore, and that ban was pulled as soon as they realized it wasn't porn.



Dragon Age sold better than Mass Effect 1 despite of having male homosexual content in it.

#12
Arik7

Arik7
  • Members
  • 1 095 messages

Athelius wrote...

I'm thinking that part of it has to do with localisation in countries with anti-homosexuality laws, was a big enough problem with ME1 liara...
Also public pressure even in more legally modern countries.

Would be impressed if they passed up on money to do it anyway, but I can understand that they won't.

DAO contains both M/M and F/F romances.  How come we haven't heard about any of these anti-homosexuality laws when DAO was released? 

#13
javierabegazo

javierabegazo
  • Members
  • 6 257 messages
Just a note about DAO sales vs. ME1 sales. ME1, in it's first 12 weeks of release was only available for the XBOX, where as this was not at all the case with DAO, just sayin' :)



Impressive work on the OP. Just keep things clean and civil, preferably without expletives, so I don't get PM'ed complaints :P

#14
Lightice_av

Lightice_av
  • Members
  • 1 333 messages

Just a note about DAO sales vs. ME1 sales. ME1, in it's first 12 weeks of release was only available for the XBOX, where as this was not at all the case with DAO, just sayin' :)



The statistics are only available from XBox sales, at least as far as the FAQ knows. So in practice the difference can be even greater.

#15
Arik7

Arik7
  • Members
  • 1 095 messages

javierabegazo wrote...

Just a note about DAO sales vs. ME1 sales. ME1, in it's first 12 weeks of release was only available for the XBOX, where as this was not at all the case with DAO, just sayin' :)
 

I believe only XBOX comparison was used in this case.  Moreover, DAO is more of PC game than a console game, yet it rivaled ME1 in XBOX sales.

Modifié par Arik7, 26 février 2010 - 02:19 .


#16
SirWalliss

SirWalliss
  • Members
  • 69 messages
Heres a complaint, to all the pro gay people, please stop pushing your views on everyone, there is plenty of gay stuff out there for you dont ruin our games as well.

#17
BrianWilly

BrianWilly
  • Members
  • 345 messages
Links are working now...thanks again!

Heh, this is the first time I've actually heard all of the f/f Tali dialogue. It's pretty cute, actually. I mean it's the same lines as m/m, but y'know.

Modifié par BrianWilly, 26 février 2010 - 02:21 .


#18
FataliTensei

FataliTensei
  • Members
  • 1 449 messages

SirWalliss wrote...

Heres a complaint, to all the pro gay people, please stop pushing your views on everyone, there is plenty of gay stuff out there for you dont ruin our games as well.


Please read the FAQPosted Image

#19
SirWalliss

SirWalliss
  • Members
  • 69 messages

FataliTensei wrote...

SirWalliss wrote...

Heres a complaint, to all the pro gay people, please stop pushing your views on everyone, there is plenty of gay stuff out there for you dont ruin our games as well.


Please read the FAQPosted Image


I dont care about the FAQ I'm sick of seeing this stupid topic.

#20
BrianWilly

BrianWilly
  • Members
  • 345 messages

SirWalliss wrote...

Heres a complaint, to all the pro gay people, please stop pushing your views on everyone, there is plenty of gay stuff out there for you dont ruin our games as well.

Gay content in games is becoming less taboo, this is true...and much of it is thanks to Bioware itself, ironically enough.  And there's still a fairly finite amount of games with gay content, much less gay male content, so I wouldn't describe it as "plenty." Again, a lot of them are in fact Bioware or EA games.

And why does a game have to be yours or ours?  Why can't it be everyone's?  Would "your" game really be ruined by optional gay content that you wouldn't even have to see if you didn't want to?  There was lesbian content in Mass Effect 1, after all, and I'll go out on a limb to assume that it didn't exactly ruin the game for you.

Modifié par BrianWilly, 26 février 2010 - 02:27 .


#21
Console Cowboy

Console Cowboy
  • Members
  • 464 messages
i think same sex romance is swell.

#22
Cat Lance

Cat Lance
  • Members
  • 1 119 messages
I'd like to add my vote of being able to choose a sexuality at character creation/import. A simple straight/bi/gay toggle so that those that only want to access some of the content don't have to be "bothered" with the rest of it and those of us that want to see everything also can.

*edit, and yes, I realise this would possibly be a lot of work to implement, but I think the pay off in sales and fanlove would be completely worth the zots spent on it.

Modifié par Cat Lance, 26 février 2010 - 02:28 .


#23
Athelius

Athelius
  • Members
  • 109 messages

Arik7 wrote...

Athelius wrote...

I'm thinking that part of it has to do with localisation in countries with anti-homosexuality laws, was a big enough problem with ME1 liara...
Also public pressure even in more legally modern countries.

Would be impressed if they passed up on money to do it anyway, but I can understand that they won't.

DAO contains both M/M and F/F romances.  How come we haven't heard about any of these anti-homosexuality laws when DAO was released? 


Hmm... good point, as did the KOTOR games I think...
So yeah, perhaps that wouldn't be a problem after all. I guess any countries with those laws probably wouldn't allow the game anyway, hence it never happened.

In that case, yeah, don't see why not. If it was as tame as the scenes in ME2, I can't see why people should object really.

#24
FlyinElk212

FlyinElk212
  • Members
  • 2 598 messages

SirWalliss wrote...

Heres a complaint, to all the pro gay people, please stop pushing your views on everyone, there is plenty of gay stuff out there for you dont ruin our games as well.


Let's say the roles were reversed, and only homosexual relationships existed in ME2. Wouldn't you want Miranda, Jack, and Tali to be potential love interests?

See, that's the beauty of the love interests: you don't have to engage in the relationship if you don't want to! So simply don't. In our previous scenario, I wouldn't consider you "pushing your views" onto anyone if you wanted to have a possible Miranda relationship that I or others could pass on.

#25
Lightice_av

Lightice_av
  • Members
  • 1 333 messages

Would "your" game really be ruined by gay content that you wouldn't even have to see if you didn't want to? There was lesbian content in Mass Effect 1, after all.



Don't try logic, it's just a spammer. They go away when they're ignored, or get banned if they don't.

And as for the actual topic, I don't think that anyone immature enough to be banished by the very thought of gay content is part of the target audience, anyway. RPGs are generally marketed for mature, intelligent gamers. F/F content in the first game certainly didn't lower the interest in the slightest.

Modifié par Lightice_av, 26 février 2010 - 02:29 .