Aller au contenu

Photo

Same Sex Romances


7455 réponses à ce sujet

#426
Octorox

Octorox
  • Members
  • 195 messages

Ryzaki wrote...

I think alot of people are missing two words: VIDEO GAME

'Tis ment to be fun. :"( Logical and concise but fun (and sometimes logic and coherency goes bye bye when it comes to fun time.)


How about INTERACTIVE EXPERIENCE

It's meant to be emotionally engaging and believable. I'd just play Mario or something if all I was looking for was fun. I'm looking for being immersed in another world with a gripping plot, and deep and realistic characters.

#427
Jimmy Fury

Jimmy Fury
  • Members
  • 1 486 messages

Octorox wrote...
but your suggestion involves me not only having control of Shepard, but also of every other character in my ME universe. As Shepard I do everything in my power to change things in my world and customize myself however I want, but I shouldn't have the power to make NPC's orientations the way I want them to be. I like the idea that my Shepard is my character who is dropped into this living, breathing universe, not an all powerful character who the universe revolves around. I also don't like the idea of relationships dependent upon numbers and stats...


Just a quick thought.
You already have the ability to control all the other squad members. You select their skills and abilities, their weapons, their armor, and uhm... that one really big important thing that comes up at the end that is a spoiler so I won't say it by name but uhm... it's a big deal to those characters... yeah...
Again though, just a thought.

Modifié par Jimmy Fury, 26 février 2010 - 07:22 .


#428
Jimmy Fury

Jimmy Fury
  • Members
  • 1 486 messages

Collider wrote...
I'm sorry you feel this way, because I have made no intentional effort to any way imply that I thought most same sex supports feel they are entitled.


Oh don't feel sorry for the way i feel, I certainly don't.  I was simply stating that your continued focus on the statement of one person made it appear that you detected that opinion in a majority of our group.

#429
Octorox

Octorox
  • Members
  • 195 messages

Jimmy Fury wrote...

Octorox wrote...
but your suggestion involves me not only having control of Shepard, but also of every other character in my ME universe. As Shepard I do everything in my power to change things in my world and customize myself however I want, but I shouldn't have the power to make NPC's orientations the way I want them to be. I like the idea that my Shepard is my character who is dropped into this living, breathing universe, not an all powerful character who the universe revolves around. I also don't like the idea of relationships dependent upon numbers and stats...


Just a quick thought.
You already have the ability to control all the other squad members. You select their skills and abilities, their weapons, their armor, and uhm... that one really big important thing that comes up at the end that is a spoiler so I won't say it by name but uhm... it's a big deal to those characters... yeah...
Again though, just a thought.


They are placed directly under my command as a starship captain. The decisions I make regarding tactics as well as character interaction affects them. But no matter how loyal she is, I doubt Miranda would magically turn bi if I were playing FemShep and I wanted her to be gay for me now.

Modifié par Octorox, 26 février 2010 - 07:27 .


#430
Ryzaki

Ryzaki
  • Members
  • 34 423 messages

Octorox wrote...

Ryzaki wrote...

I think alot of people are missing two words: VIDEO GAME

'Tis ment to be fun. :"( Logical and concise but fun (and sometimes logic and coherency goes bye bye when it comes to fun time.)


How about INTERACTIVE EXPERIENCE

It's meant to be emotionally engaging and believable. I'd just play Mario or something if all I was looking for was fun. I'm looking for being immersed in another world with a gripping plot, and deep and realistic characters.

'

Then read a book. :mellow: Believe me a video game can have the most epic story eva! If no one has fun playing it it won't sell well. That's why Ninetendo constantly crushes the competition. You think ME2 would have sold as well if they focused on the storyline and the gameplay itself wasn't fun? Pfft.

A game can be fun AND an interactive experience. :mellow: But its primary function is to be fun. If people aren't having fun playing your game. You've FAILED. Its nice to have a good, engaging storyline but there are games (Like MGS4) that are called "Interactive movies" because of failing to balance storytelling and gameplay.

Gameplay > Storyline most of the time.

Why do you think games like Halo, MW, Rock Band constantly bulldoze anything else? Because of GAMEPLAY. Its FUN. They don't have epic storylines, deep moving characters. They are FUN.

BioWare games have great stories no doubt (even if they keep recycling key points :D ) and are very emotionally engaging. That's what they're good out. They've found a way to balance humor, drama and influencing the game world in a interactive and fun experience.

Modifié par Ryzaki, 26 février 2010 - 07:32 .


#431
Lord Atlia

Lord Atlia
  • Members
  • 506 messages

Heavensrun wrote...

If they decide to make Tali bi, I would hope that it shows up in ME3, possibly with a "I felt this way about you back then, but I felt awkward about propositioning another woman....I never thought of myself that way" kind of line.


OMG...that is just too cute when read in stuttering Tali voice.  Tali x F Shepard was lost yuri gold, they are now the cutest couple that never happened since Kaori and Sakaki :crying:

#432
Madmelendez

Madmelendez
  • Members
  • 8 messages

Octorox wrote...

Ryzaki wrote...

I think alot of people are missing two words: VIDEO GAME

'Tis ment to be fun. :"( Logical and concise but fun (and sometimes logic and coherency goes bye bye when it comes to fun time.)


How about INTERACTIVE EXPERIENCE

It's meant to be emotionally engaging and believable. I'd just play Mario or something if all I was looking for was fun. I'm looking for being immersed in another world with a gripping plot, and deep and realistic characters.


Yes but Mass Effect still isn't a dating sim. Yes Bioware put in the romances and worked very hard on it but its still optional and not needed. And realisticly not everyone in the world is gay or lesbian. So is it really a huge deal that one series of a bioware doesn't have a m/m relationship?

#433
Collider

Collider
  • Members
  • 17 165 messages

Ryzaki wrote...
Then read a book. :mellow:

Implying that someone wanting an immersive story in a video game should read a book instead.
Image IPB


Gameplay > Storyline most of the time.

If you aren't having fun just because you can't have your man on man fantasies detailed on screen, that's your loss.

#434
Ryzaki

Ryzaki
  • Members
  • 34 423 messages

Collider wrote...

Ryzaki wrote...
Then read a book. :mellow:

[i]Implying that someone wanting an immersive story in a video game should read a book instead.

If you aren't having fun just because you can't have your man on man fantasies detailed on screen, that's your loss.



Wow. Dude. Comprehension fail.

That is totally not what I meant. :pinched:

You should use that facepalm pic on yourself.

I meant if a immersive storyline and is the only thing you're after one would be better off looking in a book. Especially if you want "canon".

And...wow. How hostile and inncorrect. I'd tell you to take that stick out of your a** but that might be a bit much.

No. lack of M/M doesn't hinder my enjoyment of ME.

Modifié par Ryzaki, 26 février 2010 - 07:35 .


#435
SkullandBonesmember

SkullandBonesmember
  • Members
  • 1 009 messages

Ryzaki wrote...

Then read a book. :mellow: Believe me a video game can have the most epic story eva! If no one has fun playing it it won't sell well. That's why Ninetendo constantly crushes the competition. You think ME2 would have sold as well if they focused on the storyline and the gameplay itself wasn't fun? Pfft.

A game can be fun AND an interactive experience. :mellow: But its primary function is to be fun. If people aren't having fun playing your game. You've FAILED. Its nice to have a good, engaging storyline but there are games (Like MGS4) that are called "Interactive movies" because of failing to balance storytelling and gameplay.

Gameplay > Storyline most of the time.

Why do you think games like Halo, MW, Rock Band constantly bulldoze anything else? Because of GAMEPLAY. Its FUN. They don't have epic storylines, deep moving characters. They are FUN.


Well, since you place such a high priority on 'SPLOSHUNS, you probably don't know about Heavy Rain. Or at least the critical acclaim it has gotten since release. Many people want story driven games and will welcome them with open arms.

#436
Guest_rynluna_*

Guest_rynluna_*
  • Guests

Madmelendez wrote..


Yes but Mass Effect still isn't a dating sim. Yes Bioware put in the romances and worked very hard on it but its still optional and not needed. And realisticly not everyone in the world is gay or lesbian. So is it really a huge deal that one series of a bioware doesn't have a m/m relationship?


It is when they allow female shep to be a lesbian and male shep can't be gay.

#437
Collider

Collider
  • Members
  • 17 165 messages

Ryzaki wrote...
Wow. Dude. Comprehension fail.

That is totally not what I meant. :pinched:

Reread what you said. The poster you were responding to said he wanted an immersive story, otherwise he'd just play mario instead. your response? "Then just read a book."

You should use that facepalm pic on yourself.

No, it still stands because you were unable to effectively communicate your point.

#438
Grunt420

Grunt420
  • Members
  • 308 messages
is female Shepard gay in mass effect 2

#439
didymos1120

didymos1120
  • Members
  • 14 580 messages

LOST SPARTANJLC wrote...

Correct , to further the species through extracting genetic material from either male or female races.But for all points they're female in every way possible.


Actually, they don't even do that.  It's sort of Asari urban myth that they get anything from other species.  As best I can tell, the melding seems to be a mechanism for inducing mutations.  Who knows how it works biochemically, but they basically, all they get from the other partner is a source of entropy for the randomizing "algorithm".  Talk to the bartender on Ilium, or the angry lady at Baria Frontiers, and they'll bring it up.   The Codex mentions it too, I believe.  The only tangible benefit to melding with non-Asari seems to be that it doesn't trigger the Ardat-Yakshi mutation.  And frankly, that seems fairly dubious to me. Plus, your only source for this is Samara, who certainly believes it, but Asari don't seem to be completely reliable on the subject in general (I'm looking at you, Dr. T'Soni in ME1), so I don't entirely buy it.   It could easily be a chicken-egg thing:  did the prejudice against purebloods come first, and spawn the "Ardat-Yakshi Syndrome is only a pureblood problem" meme, or was it really Ardat-Yakshi who started the whole move away from Asari-Asari pairings because it is a pureblood problem? 

Sorry.

Valiant attempt to seem on-topic:  You know, that whole pureblood prejudice is sort of like an Asari version of homphobia, don't ya think?

#440
Jimmy Fury

Jimmy Fury
  • Members
  • 1 486 messages

Grunt420 wrote...

is female Shepard gay in mass effect 2


She can hit on Kelly, Samara, and Morinth.
So yes, she can be.

#441
Ryzaki

Ryzaki
  • Members
  • 34 423 messages

Collider wrote...

Reread what you said. The poster you were responding to said he wanted an immersive story, otherwise he'd just play mario instead. your response? "Then just read a book."


Hm...might not have been clear. I meant protizing a immersive story over enjoyment actually playing the game = being better off reading a book.

Modifié par Ryzaki, 26 février 2010 - 07:39 .


#442
Ryzaki

Ryzaki
  • Members
  • 34 423 messages

SkullandBonesmember wrote...

Ryzaki wrote...

Then read a book. :mellow: Believe me a video game can have the most epic story eva! If no one has fun playing it it won't sell well. That's why Ninetendo constantly crushes the competition. You think ME2 would have sold as well if they focused on the storyline and the gameplay itself wasn't fun? Pfft.

A game can be fun AND an interactive experience. :mellow: But its primary function is to be fun. If people aren't having fun playing your game. You've FAILED. Its nice to have a good, engaging storyline but there are games (Like MGS4) that are called "Interactive movies" because of failing to balance storytelling and gameplay.

Gameplay > Storyline most of the time.

Why do you think games like Halo, MW, Rock Band constantly bulldoze anything else? Because of GAMEPLAY. Its FUN. They don't have epic storylines, deep moving characters. They are FUN.


Well, since you place such a high priority on 'SPLOSHUNS, you probably don't know about Heavy Rain. Or at least the critical acclaim it has gotten since release. Many people want story driven games and will welcome them with open arms.


Right and that's why my "sploshuns!" games will undoubtly outsell it right? <_<

And yeah I do know about Heavy Rain. I actually enjoy story-driven games so how about you stop making assumptions about people's experiences.

ME2 wants to appeal to a mass market. It needs to be fun in addition to having an awesome story. Why do you think they bothered changing the combat system then? 

List the top 10 best selling games in the last 5 years. Let's so how many are story driven and how many are game-play driven.

Modifié par Ryzaki, 26 février 2010 - 07:45 .


#443
Grunt420

Grunt420
  • Members
  • 308 messages

Jimmy Fury wrote...

Grunt420 wrote...

is female Shepard gay in mass effect 2


She can hit on Kelly, Samara, and Morinth.
So yes, she can be.


thats about it nothing esle happens

#444
didymos1120

didymos1120
  • Members
  • 14 580 messages

Octorox wrote...
Yes, danman that was a bit out of line. You really need more of an argument than "why should they?" and to call other forumgoers "angry people" for expressing their opinions is a bit absurd...


Honestly, I appreciate that, Octorox. You get it: You and I certainly don't agree on some stuff, and I can and will be blunt and acerbic at times about people's arguments if I think they're wrong, but I'm not expecting kid glove treatment for anything I say either, and it has nothing to do with being angry.  Disagreement is not a personal attack.  Yes: I did say one of your arguments was absurd. I don't even remotely think you're absurd. 

Besides, it's actually fairly difficult, like on a neurological level, for me to be angry right now:  I had a crown and a root canal today...and then I got me some Vicodin. Sweet, sweet Vicodin....

#445
Madmelendez

Madmelendez
  • Members
  • 8 messages

rynluna wrote...

Madmelendez wrote..


Yes but Mass Effect still isn't a dating sim. Yes Bioware put in the romances and worked very hard on it but its still optional and not needed. And realisticly not everyone in the world is gay or lesbian. So is it really a huge deal that one series of a bioware doesn't have a m/m relationship?


It is when they allow female shep to be a lesbian and male shep can't be gay.


But technically she really isn't lesbian. Asari are one gender AND they are aliens, not even human can you base a human-alien relationship on its gender? Since you know they can be both a father/mother of their own children or whatever. And yeah I understand its because they are modeled to look like females and such.. But couldn't that be changed if Bioware intoduced an Asari that looked like a male instead?

#446
asaiasai

asaiasai
  • Members
  • 1 391 messages

Octorox wrote...

asaiasai wrote...

Octorox wrote...

asaiasai wrote...

I agree with the OP and i support relationships for the PC with any NPC regardless of sex. It should not matter to anyone how an individual wants to play thier character, this whole discussion to me is like trying to debate a character build. One infiltrator build versus another infiltrator build in a game where neither builds will be pitted against each other, is somewhat specious, it should have been in from the beginning. The option for whatever romance the player wants to engage in should have been included from ME just like it was in DAO.

I think the simplest way to resovle this issue is to open up the romances to any NPC but the player MUST build the character to make it possible. Let me explain by example.

In both games we have stats called persuasion/intimidation that influences the NPC's attitudes towards the PC. If a male shep wanted to engage in a relationship with Garrus or Jacob they would need to build a higher persuasion character at the detriment of another stat like weapon accuracy. The player would have to make a consious decision to build for a specific romance where it would take less persuasion/intimidation for the same PC to romance Jack or Tali, as the relationship is more "traditional".

Now i also think that taking my idea above and adding to it a specific dialog option to initate a romance with any NPC, something along the lines of "Express Romantic Interest". The player would HAVE to select that option while in a conversation with the character of thier choice, they would also need sufficent persuasion/intimidation before the dialog option would even present itself.

I know what some folks are thinking why is there a penalty for this type of option? Look at it more of a way to compromise. I am a hetero male who drives nothing but femsheps, I am willing to trade a few stat points to engage in a F/F romance of my choice, it really is more of a matter of how you look at it, the folks for who this would not be an option will use thier stat points elsewhere. In the end seriously does 10% less accuracy and a 2 sec longer cool down in order to build enough persuasion points to engage in the romance partner of your choice really matter? This seems to be a way to provide the options with out really having to call any more attention to them.

Just a thought

Asai


Now this is exactly what I'm against. Everyone is the galaxy shouldn't be straight but they shouldn't all be bi either. Being able to romance ANY character regardless of their sexual orientation would just ruin the idea of romance in Mass Effect for me.



You are missing the point entirely, it is a single player experience, what MY universe offers as opposed to what YOUR universe offers SHOULD be completely different experiences. It is already a completely different experience because you build your character differently than i would build mine. The precedent is already in the game because of the choices you made in your build means you approach combat differently than i do already. My way creates an opportunity for for the player to play in a universe of thier choice. If you do not want to have a same sex romance then do not spend the additional points to necessary to boost your persuasion to a level sufficient to enter in a same sex romance.

I will attempt to be more concise.

Taking the curent player options for builds there are 8 stats in ME2 that determine the effectivness of the player in combat or interactions with the NPCs. To max out the persuasion/intimidation stat requires 10 total points. At 6 points expended all store discounts and dialog options are open, you as a player do not need to max out your persuasion/intimidation stat because you will not be looking to engage in a same sex romance, in a sense you max out at 6 where as i max out at 10, because the option to engage in same sex romances is more important to me than maxing out another stat. You never have to worry about a dialog option even popping up in a conversation with a same sex crew member because your stats will not allow it. The choice for a same sex romance becomes a consious choice, that i have to choose to make, period.

What you seem to be saying is that i have to play in your universe, which in a sense i already am right up until i spend the additional 4 points necessary to max out my persuasion/intimidation stat. It is only then that my universe changes compared to your universe, and that change is a small one. You will never have to play in my universe and that is fine by me, all i am saying is that you should be willing to allow me the same courtsey that i am extending to you. This is imho the simplest compromise because it puts the onus on the player to consiously make the choice that in reality should be thier's to make anyway.

Asai


but your suggestion involves me not only having control of Shepard, but also of every other character in my ME universe. As Shepard I do everything in my power to change things in my world and customize myself however I want, but I shouldn't have the power to make NPC's orientations the way I want them to be. I like the idea that my Shepard is my character who is dropped into this living, breathing universe, not an all powerful character who the universe revolves around. I also don't like the idea of relationships dependent upon numbers and stats...


Only if you spend the 4 additional talent points do you have that kind of power, if that bothers you the solution is not to spend those 4 points. Problem solves itself for you and me. How can you object to a solution that has no effect unless you choose to enable that solution?

Asai

#447
cutthecameras

cutthecameras
  • Members
  • 868 messages

Grunt420 wrote...

Jimmy Fury wrote...

Grunt420 wrote...

is female Shepard gay in mass effect 2


She can hit on Kelly, Samara, and Morinth.
So yes, she can be.


thats about it nothing esle happens

a few other examples:
cuddles scene with Kelly, tiping Asari strippers, dancing with girls (i love this line: "I'll dance next to you; you wanna think we're dancing together go ahead")

#448
Jimmy Fury

Jimmy Fury
  • Members
  • 1 486 messages

Grunt420 wrote...
thats about it nothing esle happens


And that is irrelivant in the grand scheme of sexuality. You don't have to have sex with someone to have a sexuality, you only need to express an interest in it. Since female Shepard can express interest in 4 different females, it means she has the option to be played as a lesbian. The fact that she can't have sex with 3 of them just makes her a very frustrated lesbian.

#449
Grunt420

Grunt420
  • Members
  • 308 messages
i've seen straight women in strip clubs, dance together, and yes in even cuddle it does not mean there gay

#450
cutthecameras

cutthecameras
  • Members
  • 868 messages

Jimmy Fury wrote...

The fact that she can't have sex with 3 of them just makes her a very frustrated lesbian.

hahaha, ftw