I think part of the problem is that we're using the same vocabulary to mean very different things. I, for one, find nothing inconsistent from game to game about an NPC who finds Shepard attractive enough to romance regardless of sex - the game code would be blind to Shep's model when pursuing a romance storyline. Functional sexual orientation in the game's code is quite different from established sexual orientation in real life. I also agree with catabuca that each game playthrough is best viewed as a discrete universe all of its own.Collider wrote...
Tommy, the fact that Shepard is so customizable requires that the other characters are consistent for me. Quite frankly, there IS a canon Wrex, Garrus, Ashley, etc. There would be no character if things were written and established about them by the writer. Ashley believes in God, Wrex was a mercenary, Garrus has a father who disliked the Spectres. Most of the character is canon.
Tommy, I'm not suggesting that it is not plausible that any character can be written as gay or bisexual. I'm saying that I want consistent characters. Having characters change their orientation based upon completely arbitrary (Shepard's gender?) is ridiculous, as you said but seem to go back against. Part of consistent characters is that they are not going change their orientation (which is a horrible idea - sexual orientation changing? that's the stuff religious fundamentalists say) just because Shepard wants them to. You can influence someone's views, but you can't have them change from gay to straight like that. It's disgusting to even suggest.
For an example, take Jacob and his priiize. He has a backstory of having dated Miranda, but nothing else in particular in terms of romance. Blind to the character model, Jacob can be romanced by MShep or FemShep - if MShep, he can be read as bisexual, and if FemShep, straight. But the game doesn't do the identifying, here - the player does; there is no chance of both FemShep and MShep being active in the same game to both be a potential object of affection, thus no universal portrayal of a bisexual character. In the course of the game, Jacob will not waver in his reaction to Shep except as Shep affects the outcome - entirely consistent with catabuca's assertion that orientation would be immutable within the context of a single playthrough and story arc. Just as Shepard is not pure Paragon or Renegade except in a given playthrough, or Ashley's xenophobia can be subdued or flourish, neither is Jacob universally bisexual except in a given playthrough.
Players are already identifying NPCs variably as bi, gay, or straight with and without reference to cut content. This does nothing to add to that, really. That's interpretation of perceived character behaviour, enabled by code. I think Kaidan comes off as interested in Shepard (model blind), but others have read him as gay despite the potential for a FemShep romance, and still others as straight.




Ce sujet est fermé
Retour en haut




