401 réponses à ce sujet

[revan11exile]

 For me i pick Jacob mainly because when i play with my male shepard i always think that the closest person to shepard is Jacob and i think that BioWare made the female shepard flirt with Jacob because it was meant to be.

[LN19]

revan11exile wrote...

 For me i pick Jacob mainly because when i play with my male shepard i always think that the closest person to shepard is Jacob and i think that BioWare made the female shepard flirt with Jacob because it was meant to be.

Kaidan, because he doesn't look at Shepard as a "priiiizzee"

[Exile Isan]

Kaidan without a doubt of those two. Although if you want my opinion on which romance overall fits best with my Shepard then Garrus.

[Pannamaslo]

IMO Thane or Garrus. Jacob's romance resembles a bad porn dialog and Kaidan is a whiny woos.

But if I had to choose I between the two I would say Jacob- less whining.

Modifié par Pannamaslo, 28 février 2010 - 11:11 .

[WilliamShatner]

The correct answer is Liara.

[Schroing]

Jacob, all the way.

[crimsonrhodelia]

Kaidan. He falls for Shepard the woman, not Shepard the commander. Plus, to paraphrase what someone in my favourite thread once said, Jacob's body looks like he slapped hamburger buns to his stomach.

ETA:

revan11exile wrote...
i think that BioWare made the female shepard
flirt with Jacob because it was meant to be.

Following this logic, Kaidan is the right man for Shep, because he was the first guy she got to flirt with in ME1.

Modifié par crimsonrhodelia, 28 février 2010 - 11:13 .

[chem light]

Kaidan for the win. Jacob said he wasn't man enough for Miranda. What makes him think he's man enough for my Shepard?

[LN19]

Pannamaslo wrote...

IMO Thane or Garrus. Jacob's romance is resembling a bad porn dialog and Kaidan is a whiny woos.

But if I had to choose I between the two I would say Jacob- less whining.

Elaborate?

[enormousmoonboots]

Neither of those people are Garrus.

[Vaenier]

both are such annoying characters. I choose Garrus.

[Frotality]

everything about jacob's romanace; dialogue, scene... was just awful. kaiden was boring, but not cringe worthy.

i think i have to take my femshep back thru ME1 just to romance kaiden...between pyscho-eyed frog boy, bad porn dialogue with the black man, bird faced reptile, and the sexually confused asari....she's gonna be very lonely by the end of ME3.

[crimsonrhodelia]

chem light wrote...

Kaidan for the win. Jacob said he wasn't man enough for Miranda. What makes him think he's man enough for my Shepard?

ITA! Besides, Shepard doesn't settle for someone else's leftovers!

[Mondo47]

One word: chest. In comparison to Jacob, Kaidan is built like a boy.

Though if Wrex was on the list I'd kick the humans to the curb in a shot... raaawrrrr

[kraidy1117]

both where terriable roamnces. Kaidan was a Carth wannabe and Jacob just wants sex.

[Schroing]

kraidy1117 wrote...

both where terriable roamnces. Kaidan was a Carth wannabe and Jacob just wants sex.

Exactly, he's a real man.

[Pannamaslo]

LN19 wrote...

Pannamaslo wrote...

IMO Thane or Garrus. Jacob's romance is resembling a bad porn dialog and Kaidan is a whiny woos.

But if I had to choose I between the two I would say Jacob- less whining.

Elaborate?

IMO he is. Starting from his VA (I hated Carth) , through terrible haircut to his lines about  bad childhood, how humanity should be good for aliens and JOKER IS WAITING FOR YOU ON THE BRIDGE. Not to mention he dies too often comparing to other squadmates. Also he is just boring. Whiny woos I say. Sorry. 

Modifié par Pannamaslo, 28 février 2010 - 11:21 .

[The Angry One]

kraidy1117 wrote...

both where terriable roamnces. Kaidan was a Carth wannabe

By that logic ManShep is a Biotic God wannabe.

[epoch_]

kaidan

[LN19]

kraidy1117 wrote...

both where terriable roamnces. Kaidan was a Carth wannabe and Jacob just wants sex.

Aside from Sbarge and being a LI...how exactly is Kaidan a "Carth Wannabe"?

[MICHELLE7]

chem light wrote...

Kaidan for the win. Jacob said he wasn't man enough for Miranda. What makes him think he's man enough for my Shepard?

Exactly...why would Shep want to be with someone that settled for her as their second choice. Jacob is just interested in sex anyway.

[RyrineaNara]

Kaidan! At least he doesn't call the commander a prize. >.< The romance for Kaidan, is well done in my opinion.

[MICHELLE7]

The Angry One wrote...

kraidy1117 wrote...

both where terriable roamnces. Kaidan was a Carth wannabe

By that logic ManShep is a Biotic God wannabe.

:lol:

[Jaarlitar]

I could never romance Kaidan because he reminded me so much about Carth who whined way too much. Jacob is a big no-no too.



If those are my options, my femhep's going to stay single.



Thane is her man.

[Madecologist]

The Angry One wrote...

kraidy1117 wrote...

both where terriable roamnces. Kaidan was a Carth wannabe

By that logic ManShep is a Biotic God wannabe.

That made me chuckle!

As for the OP. Kaiden, hands down. Jacob is maybe cool, but he sure knows how to make femShep feel second best. That line made me cringe.