Aller au contenu

Photo

Why so much Wynne hate?


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
329 réponses à ce sujet

#126
krylo

krylo
  • Members
  • 845 messages

MorningBird wrote...

I have multiple playthroughs, I have romanced many of the Characters, but the Zevran romance is the only one I've seen from start to finish so far (twice).  I think my lack of meta-gaming knowledge may partially be the reason I'm able to see her in a more positive light.  The only perspective of Wynne that I know is that of my City Elf (haven't gotten far enough in the other playthroughts).


...All else aside, this isn't possible, unless in one of your Zev romance play throughs you murdered Wynne at the Circle Tower.

Zevran's romance can't complete until you're jumped by the Crows in Denerim.  This won't happen until you have completed Orzammar, Brecellian Forest, Circle Tower, Redcliffe, and Andraste's Ashes.

In other words, you can not possibly complete Zevran's romance twice without meeting Wynne twice.   Unless you just played the same city elf through twice?

Also: 

I bring this up only to point out that I played a character that was
not as secure in his leadership capabilities as he led others to
believe.  I get the feeling--from reading this thread--that there are
many posters here with born leader PCs (which isn't a bad thing, by any
means) and I think that's where this divide is drawn.

A born
leader PC doesn't need Wynne's advice, nor would they see it as useful
or even correct (and as a leader, they could quite possibly be right on
all accounts).

A self-conscious PC, with a grudge towards their Grey Warden status, would feel more at loss, and more open to her advice.


This probably has to do with why people like her less the more they play.  The whole "I don't know what I'm doing" character is a lot easier to play the first time you play through the game.  The third?  Fourth?  Fifth times?

Yeah, not so much.  By then you just kind of want her to shut up.  At least I do.  Thank God for the ESC key.

I already know what choices I want to make/am going to make and her preaching isn't going to change that.  She offers no insight, and there's only so many times I can listen to her talk about how the Grey Wardens are the shield to humanity or whatever.

On the other hand, Alistair asking me about lamposts in winter never gets old.

Ever.

#127
Charsen

Charsen
  • Members
  • 2 266 messages

MorningBird wrote...
It's funny, a lot of people have commented that if you're a Zevran fan, you'll understand why Wynne is so hated... but Zevran is one of my top five favorite DA characters (possibly ranking #1), IS my favorite romance option, and I personally hold no resentment towards Wynne.

I agree, actually - though I do tease Wynne constantly, it's in good fun. I didn't really take to heart what she said about Zevran & I, I've heard much worse, and so I didn't think what she said was anything more than a motherly/grandmotherly "you're too good for him" speech - it's really a protective thing, and with reason - Zevran did try to kill the Warden and she doesn't know him as well as the Warden.

A born leader PC doesn't need Wynne's advice, nor would they see it as useful or even correct (and as a leader, they could quite possibly be right on all accounts).
A self-conscious PC, with a grudge towards their Grey Warden status, would feel more at loss, and more open to her advice.

For my mage Warden, it was not so much about leadership but about respect. He is a loyalist mage, has great faith in the Chantry and the authority of the Circle. Wynne was a respected elder of the Circle, and he definitely viewed her as a role model. After all, being that my Warden was a spirit/creation mage, it's likely that he even learned from her. And it actually took a lot for him to defy her and stay with Zevran. 

To me, the fact that she says 'we' is significant.  She's saying that despite the demon's efforts to separate you, you were brought back together.

Oddly, when I heard her say that, I was worried she was speaking for herself & her spirit protector.

My two cents. xD *bowing out now*

That was more like two dollars, man ;)

#128
Herr Uhl

Herr Uhl
  • Members
  • 13 465 messages

krylo wrote...

MorningBird wrote...

I have multiple playthroughs, I have romanced many of the Characters, but the Zevran romance is the only one I've seen from start to finish so far (twice).  I think my lack of meta-gaming knowledge may partially be the reason I'm able to see her in a more positive light.  The only perspective of Wynne that I know is that of my City Elf (haven't gotten far enough in the other playthroughts).


...All else aside, this isn't possible, unless in one of your Zev romance play throughs you murdered Wynne at the Circle Tower.

Zevran's romance can't complete until you're jumped by the Crows in Denerim.  This won't happen until you have completed Orzammar, Brecellian Forest, Circle Tower, Redcliffe, and Andraste's Ashes.

In other words, you can not possibly complete Zevran's romance twice without meeting Wynne twice.   Unless you just played the same city elf through twice?


See other. There has been a playthrough with CE.

#129
EccentricSage

EccentricSage
  • Members
  • 1 067 messages
Yeah, for me, in my first file, Dalish male named Dristen, he adopted her as sort of the camp elder at first... He misses his Dalish clan, so the party members and travelers he collects at camp are like surrogate clan to him, or at least he'd like them to be. Wynn would be the elder, Alistair would be like his clan brother, Morrigan is like the clan mage and a love interest he wanted to 'bond' with, Lelliana was like the clan storyteller.... But it didn't work out that way.

Wynn and Lel in particular are disappointing to him... Wynn looses her temper with him during conversations instead of being understanding and patient with him. He's only probably 19 or 20, and never knew much about the world outside his clan. So when he was excited about Griffons, for instance, and she was being snappy and impatient about it, it really took him by surprise. And then she wanted him to agree to live in servitude for others asking no reward in return and bearing no grudges... that just sounds like slavery. So they got in an argument about that as well.

Then, Zevran came into his life, and he was so happy to have a fellow elf around, though he tried to hide his eagerness and act cautious. But they understood each other and hit it off great. He broke up with Morrigan for Zev, because she didn't seem to see a future for them anyhow. Zevran wants to get to know him, cheer him up, wants to hear his opinion on things, and respects him when they disagree on things... They adore eachother, and Zev opens up to Dristen about his past and regrets. What does Wynn do at this point? Tell Dristen off for having an inapropriate relationship, and then when he says it's a serious relationship, tries to change her argument and say that Zevran will get hurt in the end. I liked the response that was something to the effect 'That makes sense, hurt him now instead of later, great logic'. He's never looked at Wynn as the wise elder or kindly grandmother type again. After all, he KNOWS Zevran's feelings for him are very serious. It's pretty obvious without him having to say it. But Wynne doesn't ask questions. She doesn't want to have to consider what others are thinking or feeling, nor what they have been through, if it interferes with the judgments she's already formed based on her own prejudices and ethical standards not even she herself lives up to.

He doesn't hate her, he understands to some extent why she is the way she is. But he can't respect her, because she refuses to grow and learn from her mistakes, and she disrespects someone he cares about. Her story about learning from the loss of her elven apprentice rang rather hollow, for sure, considering she still treats people the same way she treated him, and Dristen would like to think that poor mage's life was inherently worth a whole lot more than the lesson his death teaches. That bit of subtext to the convo really bothered him.

Haven't gotten far through my other files yet, but I'm doubting they are going to have any more charitable view than my kindly child of nature Dalish, who sees through her at this point, and frankly rather pities her. My HN will agree with her about duty, but is not going to be able to put up with a stranger patranising him at his age and after what he's been through... And my CE... well, if Wynn rubs her the wrong way, she'll be lucky to leave the tower alive. Wynn might want to hope Zevran is there to give me the sad eyes and tell me about mercy. LOL

*edit*

As for 'born leaders'... Well, my Dalish was not a born leader... he really wanted a simple life with his clan.  He didn't resent Duncan for taking him away, as the Blight is as much a threat to the Dalish as anyone else in Ferelden, and he would die of the taint poisoning his blood without the joining ritual.  But he was absolutely lost in the world, really.  Did Redclif first, because Alistair said Arl Eamon should be the first person they turn to... then did the Tower because my Dalish hated the idea of a sacrafice or killing a child... Then we got Zevran, and he likes to take into acount Zevran's opinions and advice as well, which are usualy pretty apt.  Zevran is a pragmatist with a heart, so he's practicaly co-leader of our little band of misfits at this point.  Wynn doesn't read people well and lets the chantry's views cloud her judgement, so he doesn't look to her for guidence, especialy since she only wants to boss him around, and doesn't seem to care as much about his own ideas and motivations. 

It's funny, I think Zevran likes Wynn and Leliana better than Dristen does at this point.  LOL  (not getting into Lel issues here as it would be OT and irelivent)


"And say 'Wynne struck first' all you like, in means very little to
me.  Someone can call me a big, smelly doo-doo head, but that doesn't
mean I'm going to turn around and chuck a rock at their head. XP"


But Zevran isn't mean to Wynn.  He makes her uncomfortable, yes, but he's generaly very complamentary towards her.  She doesn't exactly meet him half way.  She could laugh it off and ask questions, but instead she patranises him, gets offended, and patranises him some more.  Their exchanges left me with increased respect and admeration for Zevran and his great humor and good natured way of dealing with offensive people, and by contrast left me with distaste for Wynn for having even atempted to breach such a sensitive topic with him in the presence of his peers, and in such a sanctimonius way.  Of course you aren't going to get close to someone who's been through hell by saying to them 'hey, I've got you figured out.  you are this way, and feal that way, now one moment while I pat myself on the back for trying to save your soul'.  Less kindly people than Zevran would have simply told her to **** off.

Modifié par EccentricSage, 05 mars 2010 - 01:39 .


#130
krylo

krylo
  • Members
  • 845 messages

Herr Uhl wrote...

krylo wrote...

MorningBird wrote...

I have multiple playthroughs, I have romanced many of the Characters, but the Zevran romance is the only one I've seen from start to finish so far (twice).  I think my lack of meta-gaming knowledge may partially be the reason I'm able to see her in a more positive light.  The only perspective of Wynne that I know is that of my City Elf (haven't gotten far enough in the other playthroughts).


...All else aside, this isn't possible, unless in one of your Zev romance play throughs you murdered Wynne at the Circle Tower.

Zevran's romance can't complete until you're jumped by the Crows in Denerim.  This won't happen until you have completed Orzammar, Brecellian Forest, Circle Tower, Redcliffe, and Andraste's Ashes.

In other words, you can not possibly complete Zevran's romance twice without meeting Wynne twice.   Unless you just played the same city elf through twice?


See other. There has been a playthrough with CE.

Yes.  playthrough.  Which would have allowed completing the Zevran romance once.

He said he completed it twice.

That is what I am confused about.

You can't complete that romance twice unless you have gotten through all of the beginning quests twice, which his comment about only meeting Wynne with one character precludes from possibility, UNLESS he played the same character through twice, or murdered her in one playthrough.

Follow?

Modifié par krylo, 05 mars 2010 - 11:49 .


#131
Maria Caliban

Maria Caliban
  • Members
  • 26 094 messages

krylo wrote...

This probably has to do with why people like her less the more they play.


Though there are also people who like her more the more they play, and those who like her about the same.

#132
Ahisgewaya

Ahisgewaya
  • Members
  • 553 messages

EccentricSage wrote...

But Zevran isn't mean to Wynn.  He makes her uncomfortable, yes, but he's generaly very complamentary towards her.  She doesn't exactly meet him half way.  She could laugh it off and ask questions, but instead she patranises him, gets offended, and patranises him some more.  Their exchanges left me with increased respect and admeration for Zevran and his great humor and good natured way of dealing with offensive people, and by contrast left me with distaste for Wynn for having even atempted to breach such a sensitive topic with him in the presence of his peers, and in such a sanctimonius way.  Of course you aren't going to get close to someone who's been through hell by saying to them 'hey, I've got you figured out.  you are this way, and feal that way, now one moment while I pat myself on the back for trying to your soul'.  Less kindly people than Zevran would have simply told her to **** off.


I always thought she was just being kind of flirty in a hard to get sort of way. I bet Zevran feels this way too.

#133
Reaverwind

Reaverwind
  • Members
  • 1 724 messages

EccentricSage wrote...

As for 'born leaders'... Well, my Dalish was not a born leader... he really wanted a simple life with his clan.  He didn't resent Duncan for taking him away, as the Blight is as much a threat to the Dalish as anyone else in Ferelden, and he would die of the taint poisoning his blood without the joining ritual. 



Yup, with the exception of my noble characters, who are trained to lead, the rest of mine aren't "born leaders", either. They end up in the leadership position by default, and have been doing rather well at it, long before coming to the Tower. As her dialogue is written, she offers unsolicited advice, often in areas where her own ignorance shines through, and the PC isn't afforded the chance to properly rebut what she says. Her ideals about the Wardens border on pure fantasy, and her relationship advice is so far off-base that you can tell she's never been in a committed relationship in her life.

#134
ejoslin

ejoslin
  • Members
  • 11 745 messages

MorningBird wrote...

And say 'Wynne struck first' all you like, in means very little to me.  Someone can call me a big, smelly doo-doo head, but that doesn't mean I'm going to turn around and chuck a rock at their head. XP


I snipped a lot of good stuff (I'm not dismissing it) but I wanted to address this.  Zevran was kind to Wynne, and respectful.  She overstepped her bounds with him, started talking about things that were none of her business with him, and he countered in a humorous way, making her uncomfortable.  But he still, even in her banters, comes across as teasing and playful, whereas she comes off as judgmental.  He came to enjoy their banters I think ("You have not asked me about my conscious for quite some time, my darling Wynne" hahahahaha).

He has a fun and funny personality in many of the banters, and he never used teasing to try to hurt anyone. I may be a minority in this among Zevran fans but I don't think he was bothered by Wynne's prying.  I don't think she was trying to hurt anyone either; but she does not understand boundaries, obviously, and wants to be everyone's counselor, whether she's built a relationship with them or not.

Edit: And what many Wynne-haters say is we'd like her a lot more if we had more dialog options,ones that establish our warden as the leader without sounding petulant.

Modifié par ejoslin, 05 mars 2010 - 12:49 .


#135
Ahisgewaya

Ahisgewaya
  • Members
  • 553 messages

ejoslin wrote...


He has a fun and funny personality in many of the banters, and he never used teasing to try to hurt anyone. I may be a minority in this among Zevran fans but I don't think he was bothered by Wynne's prying.  I don't think she was trying to hurt anyone either; but she does not understand boundaries, obviously, and wants to be everyone's counselor, whether she's built a relationship with them or not.

Edit: And what many Wynne-haters say is we'd like her a lot more if we had more dialog options,ones that establish our warden as the leader without sounding petulant.


I still think she's just trying to flirt with him and  doesn't know how. She has been literally stuck in a tower her whole life remember.

#136
ejoslin

ejoslin
  • Members
  • 11 745 messages

Ahisgewaya wrote...

ejoslin wrote...


He has a fun and funny personality in many of the banters, and he never used teasing to try to hurt anyone. I may be a minority in this among Zevran fans but I don't think he was bothered by Wynne's prying.  I don't think she was trying to hurt anyone either; but she does not understand boundaries, obviously, and wants to be everyone's counselor, whether she's built a relationship with them or not.

Edit: And what many Wynne-haters say is we'd like her a lot more if we had more dialog options,ones that establish our warden as the leader without sounding petulant.


I still think she's just trying to flirt with him and  doesn't know how. She has been literally stuck in a tower her whole life remember.


She managed in her past, however!

Edit: Wynne I think I would forgive a lot more if she opened up more.  She does hint at it in her relationship advice that she was hurt, deeply.  Maybe it was related to her son, maybe it's not.  But a lot of her concern there I think stems from what she went through, and what she was willing to give up for her love.  And perhaps she herself would have sacrificed the world for her love so she's worried that the warden would do the same.  Who knows.

Modifié par ejoslin, 05 mars 2010 - 01:07 .


#137
knittzu

knittzu
  • Members
  • 123 messages
Wonderful posts, EccentricSage.

#138
KentGoldings

KentGoldings
  • Members
  • 976 messages
It's the old person smell.



(j/k, I'm old)

#139
EccentricSage

EccentricSage
  • Members
  • 1 067 messages

ejoslin wrote...

MorningBird wrote...

And say 'Wynne struck first' all you like, in means very little to me.  Someone can call me a big, smelly doo-doo head, but that doesn't mean I'm going to turn around and chuck a rock at their head. XP


I snipped a lot of good stuff (I'm not dismissing it) but I wanted to address this.  Zevran was kind to Wynne, and respectful.  She overstepped her bounds with him, started talking about things that were none of her business with him, and he countered in a humorous way, making her uncomfortable.  But he still, even in her banters, comes across as teasing and playful, whereas she comes off as judgmental.  He came to enjoy their banters I think ("You have not asked me about my conscious for quite some time, my darling Wynne" hahahahaha).

He has a fun and funny personality in many of the banters, and he never used teasing to try to hurt anyone. I may be a minority in this among Zevran fans but I don't think he was bothered by Wynne's prying.  I don't think she was trying to hurt anyone either; but she does not understand boundaries, obviously, and wants to be everyone's counselor, whether she's built a relationship with them or not.


Yeah, he seems to bare no ill will at all.  I always thought he genuinly likes her, overall.  But it certainly made Dristen cringe.  I think he's more sensitive than Zev.

Edit: And what many Wynne-haters say is we'd like her a lot more if we had more dialog options,ones that establish our warden as the leader without sounding petulant.


This.  A thousand times, this.  Same goes for my fealings with Leliana... the few times you get to tell them you have a problem with them are ether childish petulant reactions, playing the race card, or just being an evil bastard steriotype... and when it comes to their personal quest related dialogue, I don't even remember having THOSE sorts of options.  :blink:


(And thanks, knittzu)^_^

Modifié par EccentricSage, 05 mars 2010 - 01:46 .


#140
Helios969

Helios969
  • Members
  • 2 748 messages
Wynne is one of the truly good companions.  Is she nosey? Yes.  Is she bossy? Yes.  Is she more than a little hypocritical? Most definitely.  But her heart is in the right place and in general her advice is good.  And most of the great leaders of history had counselor(s) to guide them and help them through times of self-doubt, which is the role Wynne was designed to fulfill.  And she never states you must do this or you must do that, she just presents an alternative point of view so we can make an informed choice.

She reminds me of more than a few people I've know in life.  I would imagine many of us here have a father/mother, uncle/aunt, grandmother/grandfather, or close family friend who have at various times throughout our lives "stuck their nose" into our business - our lifestyle, relationships they didn't approve of, behaviors they labeled self-destructive, etc. - despite us never asking.  Their intentions are good though often unwanted.  Still, when I put Wynne on the scales, it tilts in her favor.  If the worst thing I can say about someone is that they're a bit of a busybody, I can live with that.  Plus, if you get her early and spec her correctly, she's also lethal.

#141
ejoslin

ejoslin
  • Members
  • 11 745 messages
Ok, if there was ONE dialog line that would make me like Wynne more, it would be a city elf one. Never mind her trying to get the CE for accepting the blame for the rape of her cousin. Never mind the relationship advice. IF at Caladrius, when he's doing the last plea for his life, if when Wynne said, "Blood magic! I hope you're not considering this" or whatever it is she said, if my CE could have answered, "Do you honestly think I'd kill my FATHER?" I may like her more.



The real problem I have with Wynne and her advice is it's so generic. I think it's deliberate that it's that way. She spouts off platitudes without taking into consideration the actual circumstances. It's why she's likable in the first playthrough or two. In fact, even what she says at that gauntlet isn't so bad if you're not a CE or a HN (telling either of those characters that they should accept the blame for either the rape of their cousin or the murder of their parents is awful, though). Her main concern being blood magic when the CE's father would die as a result is also terrible (her concern was NOT for the elves, but for the blood magic). If she didn't get so upset when the warden would disagree with her -- she gets downright angry at points if the warden tries to tell her s/he sees things another way, and this CAN be polite.

#142
Helios969

Helios969
  • Members
  • 2 748 messages
Well, you can always just ignore her if you don't like the advice. That's what I did when she was telling me to break it off with Leliana and Morrigan at different points in different games. She admitted she was wrong about both later on.



I'm not familiar (or recall) the city elf thing you discussed above. What triggers that?

#143
ejoslin

ejoslin
  • Members
  • 11 745 messages

Helios969 wrote...

Well, you can always just ignore her if you don't like the advice. That's what I did when she was telling me to break it off with Leliana and Morrigan at different points in different games. She admitted she was wrong about both later on.

I'm not familiar (or recall) the city elf thing you discussed above. What triggers that?


When you go to Andastre's temple, you have to do a series of tests to get to the ashes.  You speak to a guardian who reveals the most personal, painful thing about the companions there.  The question is always about the Warden's recruitment.  If you're unaware of the City Elf origin, for the female, she and her bridal party are kidnapped on their wedding day by the Arl of Denerim's son.  His guards kill one of the women before taking all the elves except the CEF, whom they're saving for last.  Her cousin Soris and her finace Nelaros manage to get into the estate, Soris gets to her while Nelaros stands guard at the end of the hall. So the CEF and Soris start killing their way to the women.  They get to Nelaros just in time to see him murdered.  She can stop and grab his wedding ring, and then she and Soris keep going, fighting, killing, doing everything in their power to get to the women.  But by the time they get there, Shianni has been gang raped and is on the floor crying.  So she kills the noblemen, and they get the rest of the bridal party and go back to the alienage.  Of course, the guards come, and that's when Duncan conscripts her.

Anyway, Wynne has generic answers at the Gauntlet.  If you say that you are not to blame for whatever it is, she tells you it's sometimes hard for you to see the outcome of your actions at the time.  If you say you are responsible, she tells you you need to accept your failings.

Both those pieces of advice are grossly inappropriate for CE and HN origins.  They're not so inappropriate for the other origins.  But at the same time, the Guardian does ask Wynne if she ever doubts her advice, that she only spouts platitudes, and she acknowledges she does have doubts, only a fool is certain always.  But given her advice is SO generic, and sometimes good, sometimes inappropriate, it can come across as either wise or as insulting, depending on the situation.

#144
Sabriana

Sabriana
  • Members
  • 4 381 messages
Yes, because the CE and the HN only reacted, they did not start any action. One sees murder and rape happening, the other the complete massacre of her family and her house, and Fergus is MIA after Ostagar.

#145
Reaverwind

Reaverwind
  • Members
  • 1 724 messages

ejoslin wrote...

Anyway, Wynne has generic answers at the Gauntlet.  If you say that you are not to blame for whatever it is, she tells you it's sometimes hard for you to see the outcome of your actions at the time.  If you say you are responsible, she tells you you need to accept your failings.

Both those pieces of advice are grossly inappropriate for CE and HN origins.  They're not so inappropriate for the other origins.  But at the same time, the Guardian does ask Wynne if she ever doubts her advice, that she only spouts platitudes, and she acknowledges she does have doubts, only a fool is certain always.  But given her advice is SO generic, and sometimes good, sometimes inappropriate, it can come across as either wise or as insulting, depending on the situation.


Both those pieces of advice also fail for the mage origin. If your PC helped Jowan voluntarily, the confrontation with the templars is beyond the PC's control - how can he/she take responsibility for that? If the PC goes to Irving - the PC is given no choice but to do what the First Enchanter says. Wynne's advice at this point is hypocritical at best.

#146
Herr Uhl

Herr Uhl
  • Members
  • 13 465 messages

Sabriana wrote...

Yes, because the CE and the HN only reacted, they did not start any action. One sees murder and rape happening, the other the complete massacre of her family and her house, and Fergus is MIA after Ostagar.


Same can go for the Dalish, Dwarves (yes, both) and mage. Even though you can be the one in charge there.

#147
ejoslin

ejoslin
  • Members
  • 11 745 messages
While yes, the way the stories play out you end up really having no choice, I think blaming the Warden for the gang rape of a cousin or the murder of her family and loss of everything goes beyond the pale. With the Dalish, for instance, you CAN ask yourself, maybe we should have gone to the keeper. With the mage, you can ask yourself, maybe I should have taken the other alternative. I mean, the ways the stories play out you end up a grey warden, but I think the rest of the origins leave some margin for doubt. Ok, maybe not Dwarf Casteless. I don't see what else she could have done differently either, actually.  But she's not being blamed for these horrific things that happened.

Modifié par ejoslin, 05 mars 2010 - 03:05 .


#148
Sabriana

Sabriana
  • Members
  • 4 381 messages
Yeah, I forgot the mage,and I haven't played the dwarfs yet *is ashamed*, but the Dalish sort of just wander into the ruin and start looking around. Tamlen even touches the mirror. That whole thing could've been avoided if they just returned to camp and spoken to their keeper.

Of the two dwarf origins, I think that Brosca had less choice than Aeducan. She needed to protect her sister, Rica, iirc. But like I said, I can't be sure because I've yet to play them.

ninja'd - sort of :ph34r:

Modifié par Sabriana, 05 mars 2010 - 03:09 .


#149
Aynslie

Aynslie
  • Members
  • 435 messages
 I feel like she is my grandma in the game. :)  And I think that is probably what she is suppose to be like.  I like her.  She isn't my favorite character because the others are just incredibly interesting compared to her but he when the world is falling apart around me I like that little bit of encouragement from her.  Shes the camp mommy.  Without her Alistair wouldn't have dry socks and his shirts would all have holes in them.

#150
Reaverwind

Reaverwind
  • Members
  • 1 724 messages

ejoslin wrote...

While yes, the way the stories play out you end up really having no choice, I think blaming the Warden for the gang rape of a cousin or the murder of her family and loss of everything goes beyond the pale. With the Dalish, for instance, you CAN ask yourself, maybe we should have gone to the keeper. With the mage, you can ask yourself, maybe I should have taken the other alternative. I mean, the ways the stories play out you end up a grey warden, but I think the rest of the origins leave some margin for doubt. Ok, maybe not Dwarf Casteless. I don't see what else she could have done differently either, actually.  But she's not being blamed for these horrific things that happened.



True, but Wynne's advice pertaining to the mage-origin is also off-base considering that:

1) Jowan's a bloodmage. Wynne's tacit approval for the Warden's assisting a maleficar is just.... baffling.

2) The confrontation with the templars is out of the PC's control - in the case of the PC going to Irving, it should be very clear that  the Circle is watching Jowan's (and his associates') moves rather closely. While my PC regrets speaking to Irving, she's painfully aware Jowan's escape plan was going to fail anyway.