113 réponses à ce sujet

[Marilynn-22]

Liara

[Azorgamer]

I admit Liara has become a bit strange in ME2 but in the end I'd choose her. I still can't get past the little sister vibe I get from Tali, I cannot romance her because of that issue, it just feels wrong. Tali's one of my favorite characters but she seemed like a little sister in ME1 and I just kept that feeling in ME2.

Like I said, Liara, has become a bit wonky, but I blame Bioware writers for that mistake. On the other hand, she did save your dead charred body from becoming a Collector plaything and I think if Liara comes back as a major character in ME3 then she'll be more like her ME1 self. Just an opinion.

[Knoll Argonar]

I like Liara from ME2 better than the "ey, i'm interested in you, let's f*ck" from ME1. In ME2 she feels more like a person with purpose, feelings and intentions than the always-fainting-school-girl from ME1. Then again, I like her, but as an old friend who has lost her path somehow, not as a LI.



For a LI, I choose Tali right away. Liked her siluete, her movements, her behaviour, her voice, her feelings, thoughts, opinions and overall evolution as a Character.



I think that, unless you loved the "ey I didn't kill Dr Heart because Shepard told me it was wrong to focus so much on revenge, but in ME2 i'm doing exactly the same" thingy (I did, Garrus is incredible in ME2), you may have to consider that Tali is like the best developed character the ME series has so far, considering both games.



You can really tell the difference between the girl from ME1 and the woman from ME2.

[ShadyKat]

Wild Still wrote...

They are both aliens and therefore inferior.

Ashely is that you?

[Landline]

There is no best romance, and no worst romance, it all comes down to personal preference.



My personal preference is Tali, that doesn't mean that she is better then the others, it just means that I like her more.

[screwoffreg]

Just play multiple games and you can have it all!!!!

[SnakeHelah]

Miranda.

[izmirtheastarach]

Both. Also, Jack.

[RighteousRage]

Tali is racist

[Seanylegit]

Liara. Then Jack. Or maybe Jack then Liara, I don't know. lol

Tali's voice and weird legs freak me out.

Modifié par Seanylegit, 07 mars 2010 - 09:19 .

[RighteousRage]

Liara

Tali

Miranda

Ashley

Jack

[tdb023]

I've got to say Tali, if you romance her, she basically tells you that she's, unexperienced, for a lack of a better term. In my mind, and my morals, she basically falls head over heels for you, and I personally wouldn't want to break her heart.

[RighteousRage]

Yes haha, I have trouble rejecting Tali also. But she's nice, besides being severely bigoted toward the geth, so I don't mind that much.

[Quaay]

Tali. I always thought Liara was annoying in ME1 and Tali was cool. Plus I got to know Tali better in ME2 and be by her side when she learned about her father and the whole trial, was just really emotional waiting to hear the decision. On my 2nd playthrough she was exiled and I just felt sooooo bad. Never felt that close to Liara but hopefully she gets some DLC soon and more depth to her character.

[GuardianAngel470]

DarthCaine wrote...

Every ME2 LI is better written than any ME1 LI

However I'd go with Liara 'cos I'd kinda feel like a pervert if I ever romance Tali and I don't like nerdy girls. Plus I don't like not knowing what she looks like (she could be a she-male for all we know)

Romancing Tali seems wrong and creepy

Tali's more like Shepard's little sister rather than his girlfriend IMO

Are you serious with this post?  You dont like nerdy girls so you choose an archoelogist/scientist over an engineer/Soldier thing.  You'd feel like a perve for romancing Tali when the romance with liara felt like romancing a 12 year old virgin.  I think you've got everything backwards.

That's just my opinion, though, no need to go spreading it around.

[GuardianAngel470]

RighteousRage wrote...

Yes haha, I have trouble rejecting Tali also. But she's nice, besides being severely bigoted toward the geth, so I don't mind that much.

She comes around after the Tali/legion confrontation.

[Knoll Argonar]

Mukora wrote...

RighteousRage wrote...

Yes haha, I have trouble rejecting Tali also. But she's nice, besides being severely bigoted toward the geth, so I don't mind that much.

Yeah, but everyone's bigoted towards the geth. Even Shepard before meeting Legion.

And I think that even Tali accepts Legion if you paragonise that Legion vs Tali scene in ME2 =/

She's just like you if you accept Legion: once she knows that Geth are not how she though they were, she accepts it and moves on.

[Barquiel]

Liara



Tali is just a fair-weather friend

[JeanLuc761]

Tali was the obvious choice for me. I liked her character a lot in the first game and I was thrilled when I found out she was an option in ME2. What I like so much about the relationship is that both characters like/love each other because of who they are, rather than what they look like (glances at the rather shallow Miranda relationship). They've had a lot of history together, and Tali's loyalty quest made it clear (assuming you got her cleared) that Shepard is devoted to her.



Also, little side note; is it just me or did ME2 seem heavily biased towards a Tali romance?



- She was the first friend you met after being resurrected

- She was the only person to really express genuine shock that you're alive

- Her recruit mission has several "hints" that she has feelings for Shepard.

- Kelly flat-out tells you Tali wants to be more than friends.

- Her loyalty mission is by far the longest and contains some of the most emotionally charged gameplay I've ever seen. It also proves Shepard's devotion to her (assuming you get her cleared)

- Her actual romance dialogue feels very natural and holds more impact due to the history between them.



I don't think any other LI in either of the two games had so much emphasis placed upon them.

[GuardianAngel470]

JeanLuc761 wrote...

Tali was the obvious choice for me. I liked her character a lot in the first game and I was thrilled when I found out she was an option in ME2. What I like so much about the relationship is that both characters like/love each other because of who they are, rather than what they look like (glances at the rather shallow Miranda relationship). They've had a lot of history together, and Tali's loyalty quest made it clear (assuming you got her cleared) that Shepard is devoted to her.

Also, little side note; is it just me or did ME2 seem heavily biased towards a Tali romance?

- She was the first friend you met after being resurrected
- She was the only person to really express genuine shock that you're alive
- Her recruit mission has several "hints" that she has feelings for Shepard.
- Kelly flat-out tells you Tali wants to be more than friends.
- Her loyalty mission is by far the longest and contains some of the most emotionally charged gameplay I've ever seen. It also proves Shepard's devotion to her (assuming you get her cleared)
- Her actual romance dialogue feels very natural and holds more impact due to the history between them.

I don't think any other LI in either of the two games had so much emphasis placed upon them.

I think the Garrus romance has at least the last point you made.  Both of them have a history with you so romance seems more natural.  But I agree that the tali romance was the Dev's baby, they gave you so many hints.  And because of that, it is strange that I didn't catch on until after the Suit environment discussion.  Unfortunately I was romancing Mirranda at the time, but the Tali romance was probably the biggest reason I started a new playthrough.

I kept smiling and shaking my head wondering how in the heck that works, but the dev's pulled it off, in my opinion.  Sex would have been stupid and shallow, and would have made no sense at all.

Modifié par GuardianAngel470, 07 mars 2010 - 09:51 .

[Knoll Argonar]

GuardianAngel470 wrote...

JeanLuc761 wrote...

Tali was the obvious choice for me. I liked her character a lot in the first game and I was thrilled when I found out she was an option in ME2. What I like so much about the relationship is that both characters like/love each other because of who they are, rather than what they look like (glances at the rather shallow Miranda relationship). They've had a lot of history together, and Tali's loyalty quest made it clear (assuming you got her cleared) that Shepard is devoted to her.

Also, little side note; is it just me or did ME2 seem heavily biased towards a Tali romance?

- She was the first friend you met after being resurrected
- She was the only person to really express genuine shock that you're alive
- Her recruit mission has several "hints" that she has feelings for Shepard.
- Kelly flat-out tells you Tali wants to be more than friends.
- Her loyalty mission is by far the longest and contains some of the most emotionally charged gameplay I've ever seen. It also proves Shepard's devotion to her (assuming you get her cleared)
- Her actual romance dialogue feels very natural and holds more impact due to the history between them.

I don't think any other LI in either of the two games had so much emphasis placed upon them.

I think the Garrus romance has at least the last point you made.  Both of them have a history with you so romance seems more natural.  But I agree that the tali romance was the Dev's baby, they gave you so many hints.  And because of that, it is strange that I didn't catch on until after the Suit environment discussion.  Unfortunately I was romancing Mirranda at the time, but the Tali romance was probably the biggest reason I started a new playthrough.

I kept smiling and shaking my head wondering how in the heck that works, but the dev's pulled it off, in my opinion.  Sex would have been stupid and shallow, and would have made no sense at all.

Yup, for me Tali  Romance was Bioware's baby.

As I said, I think that because of that Tali's the best developed character of the ME series if you look at both ME1 and 2 at the same time. And her relation (and quarian relation) to the Geth, the other Bioware's baby, keeps growing.

I just want to see how my relation (as Shepard) with her grows up and how it develops in ME3.

[GuardianAngel470]

Knoll Argonar wrote...

GuardianAngel470 wrote...

JeanLuc761 wrote...

Tali was the obvious choice for me. I liked her character a lot in the first game and I was thrilled when I found out she was an option in ME2. What I like so much about the relationship is that both characters like/love each other because of who they are, rather than what they look like (glances at the rather shallow Miranda relationship). They've had a lot of history together, and Tali's loyalty quest made it clear (assuming you got her cleared) that Shepard is devoted to her.

Also, little side note; is it just me or did ME2 seem heavily biased towards a Tali romance?

- She was the first friend you met after being resurrected
- She was the only person to really express genuine shock that you're alive
- Her recruit mission has several "hints" that she has feelings for Shepard.
- Kelly flat-out tells you Tali wants to be more than friends.
- Her loyalty mission is by far the longest and contains some of the most emotionally charged gameplay I've ever seen. It also proves Shepard's devotion to her (assuming you get her cleared)
- Her actual romance dialogue feels very natural and holds more impact due to the history between them.

I don't think any other LI in either of the two games had so much emphasis placed upon them.

I think the Garrus romance has at least the last point you made.  Both of them have a history with you so romance seems more natural.  But I agree that the tali romance was the Dev's baby, they gave you so many hints.  And because of that, it is strange that I didn't catch on until after the Suit environment discussion.  Unfortunately I was romancing Mirranda at the time, but the Tali romance was probably the biggest reason I started a new playthrough.

I kept smiling and shaking my head wondering how in the heck that works, but the dev's pulled it off, in my opinion.  Sex would have been stupid and shallow, and would have made no sense at all.

Yup, for me Tali  Romance was Bioware's baby.

As I said, I think that because of that Tali's the best developed character of the ME series if you look at both ME1 and 2 at the same time. And her relation (and quarian relation) to the Geth, the other Bioware's baby, keeps growing.

I just want to see how my relation (as Shepard) with her grows up and how it develops in ME3.

Yeah, I think she is their baby because she was originally supposed to be a love interest, but they feared she wouldn't be liked enough for that in ME1.  Fast forward to ME2 and they get to go hogwild on character development for her because of the near Unanimous support for her (possibly an exageration). She always had the most interesting backstory in ME1, but some people found it boring (my brother being one of those people, hopefully he'll come around).  As compared to liara's and ashley's backstories though it definitely is the most interesting of the possible love interests.

[squirl100]

Liara = .....?