249 réponses à ce sujet

[crimsontotem]

Many fans have debated about this topic for such a long time and it is still a one of hot issues. But juding by the flow of the storyline of the game... Let's face it... It's Tali.

Why? Here's evidence...

1. Tali has been with Shepard in every series (and most likely in the third one)

2. She was in 'love' with him ever since they met in the Citadel (thanks for the typo)

3. Unlike other heroines in any Mas Effect series... she is the only one who has a love scene theme song coming in when She and Shepard is sharing their feeling (not a sex scene)

4. Dat Ass...

Modifié par crimsontotem, 10 mars 2010 - 09:45 .

[madisk]

I agree with you and have recognized her importance way before I actually liked her in ME1 (I hated her at first, all the way until the very last few hours of my first playthrough). Even more so in ME2, but for absolutely different reasons.



Tali's importance in the overarching story will lie with the final solution between the Geth and the Quarians, who are definitely one of the main focuses in the ME universe.

[keegdarv1]

its a matter of point of view, you see it as that, i see nothing expect Tali as my Shepards "little sister" that i have to protect from the moment i meet her and make sure nothing hurts her. So in my Shepards mind the through of the romance makes no sense since it puts her in danger for one and like i said shes his "little sister"

Modifié par keegdarv1, 10 mars 2010 - 09:34 .

[ObserverStatus]

We can't know for certain who will be most important in ME3. Ashley now outranks Shepard, and if he returns to the alliance, Ashley probably won't let aliens on her ship.

[keegdarv1]

bobobo878 wrote...

We can't know for certain who will be most important in ME3. Ashley now outranks Shepard, and if he returns to the alliance, Ashley probably won't let aliens on her ship.

ummm nope Ashley and Kadien dont out rank Shepard, Kadien is the rank right below Shepard and Ashley is a few down the line

[IoCaster]

bobobo878 wrote...

We can't know for certain who will be most important in ME3. Ashley now outranks Shepard, and if he returns to the alliance, Ashley probably won't let aliens on her ship.

In what military organization in the galaxy does an NCO outrank an officer?

[klossen4]

2. He was in 'love' with him ever since they met in the Citadel

shep loved himself?

[Zafezase]

bobobo878 wrote...

We can't know for certain who will be most important in ME3. Ashley now outranks Shepard, and if he returns to the alliance, Ashley probably won't let aliens on her ship.

Shepard is a Spectre. He outranks all military/alliance. lol

[SLPr0]

crimsontotem wrote...

Many fans have debated about this topic for such a long time and it is still a one of hot issues. But juding by the flow of the storyline of the game... Let's face it... It's Tali.

Why? Here's evidence...

1. Tali has been with Shepard in every series (and most likely in the third one)

2. He was in 'love' with him ever since they met in the Citadel

3. Unlike other heroines in any Mas Effect series... she is the only one who has a love scene theme song coming in when She and Shepard is sharing their feeling (not a sex scene)

4. Dat Ass...

Err.....yeah.

I aint never seen no plant grow out of a toilet.

[Rodriguer2000]

its all opinon based you can say that about liara too

[Collider]

Liara could also be considered the main heroine like Rodriguer said. She was what allowed Shepard to find the conduit (or something) and also saved Shepard from being the Shadow Broker's bargaining piece. I would consider Liara to be more important than Tali (Tali was important in ME1 for the evidence against Saren but other than that she was not needed) and the only heroine of the trilogy.

Modifié par Collider, 10 mars 2010 - 10:03 .

[ObserverStatus]

Just found the site shes Operations Chief now, forgot where I read otherwise.

[LakeshowAD1986]

What if Tali dies in a playthrough? Then she won't be in the third game, so her role can't be that important.

[Beechwell]

I would even say Liara is the most obvious "main heroine" (apart from femShep of course).

She plays a rather large part in the resolution of the plot in ME1 (Tali only has one moment of fame in the beginning); she is the one who recovers Shepard's body and sets the events of ME2 in motion; and her current hunt for the Shadow Broker may also be of some importance in ME3 (at least as likely as the Geth conflict becoming important - unless they put the whole Shadow Broker thing into the comic).

[Keltoris]

LakeshowAD1986 wrote...

What if Tali dies in a playthrough? Then she won't be in the third game, so her role can't be that important.

Bingo. Tali's character is more expendable to Bioware than Liara's.

Collider wrote...

Liara was what allowed Shepard to find the conduit and
also saved Shepard from being sold to the Collectors, and is subsequentially responsible for Cerberus being able to bring you back.

[Rodriguer2000]

LakeshowAD1986 wrote...

What if Tali dies in a playthrough? Then she won't be in the third game, so her role can't be that important.

i know people seem to forget that tali dies for some people its not like everyones gonna make her live hell she died for me on my first 2 playthoughs

Modifié par Rodriguer2000, 10 mars 2010 - 10:03 .

[Jebel Krong]

erm, miranda also has specific music in the conversations leading up to the romance scene...

[Collider]

I would rank the heroines like this.

1. Liara

2. Miranda

3. Tali

4. Ashley



Ashley could be switched with Tali if you consider how she was part of one team or the other on Virmire.

[Rodriguer2000]

Rodriguer2000 wrote...

LakeshowAD1986 wrote...

What if Tali dies in a playthrough? Then she won't be in the third game, so her role can't be that important.

i know people seem to forget that tali dies for some people its not like everyones gonna make her live hell she died for me on my first 2 playthoughs also its the players choice on what love interest is more important personally i dont see how my sheperd could have a relationship with a exosuit wearing alien that has a chance of dieing if they have sex

[Rodriguer2000]

Collider wrote...

I would rank the heroines like this.
1. Liara
2. Miranda
3. Tali
4. Ashley

Ashley could be switched with Tali if you consider how she was part of one team or the other on Virmire.

yeah thats how i would rank it except ashley is in front of tali in my opinion

[IoCaster]

bobobo878 wrote...

Just found the site shes Operations Chief now, forgot where I read otherwise.

She was a gunnery chief petty officer in ME1. She is an operations chief petty officer in ME2. She is still a non-commissioned officer. 

Kaiden was promoted from Lieutenant to Lt.Commander which is one level up from ME1. I'm making an assumption about this because otherwise it would be two levels up to a full Commander in two years. It's a video game so anything is possible but that would be unusual.

[gutty47]

Collider wrote...

I would rank the heroines like this.
1. Liara
2. Miranda
3. Tali
4. Ashley

I was just about to post this same list. Liara helps piece together the prothean stuff in ME1 and eventually recovers Shepards body. Miranda had opportunities to recover Shepard's body but was told no by TIM (read Redemption #3), and then was in charge of bringing Shep back to life. Tali's only moment is the audio snippet to oust Saren as a traitor. The rest of the women in Shepard's crew don't do anything of importance otherwise.

[DMC12]

Well in my play through, Tali tried to catch a bullet with her faceplate and failed... Like grey matter everywhere failed. So I'm gonna have to disagree with you here. Shepard's main squeeze is whoever you want it to be or survived.

[DMC12]

Well in my play through, Tali tried to catch a bullet with her faceplate and failed... Like grey matter everywhere failed. So I'm gonna have to disagree with you here. Shepard's main squeeze is whoever you want it to be or survived.

[IoCaster]

Collider wrote...

I would rank the heroines like this.
1. Liara
2. Miranda
3. Tali
4. Ashley

Ashley could be switched with Tali if you consider how she was part of one team or the other on Virmire.

Liara will still be alive in ME3. Tali is likely to be as well in most peoples game since she's way more popular than Miranda. Plenty of people can't stand Miranda and will kill her off in ME2. She isn't important to anyone other than TIM and fanboys. 

EDIT: Had to correct myself because obviously Ashley is dead for a lot of people that played ME1. 

Modifié par IoCaster, 10 mars 2010 - 10:22 .