271 réponses à ce sujet

[TOBY FLENDERSON]

Let him live, kinda reminds me of Gisbourne from the BBC Robin Hood series.

[Daralii]

Landline wrote...

I trust Garrus to be able to make his own choices in life.

Its his choice, I'll go along with him, and he wants him dead.

This is actually why I let him live; after the mission, Garrus comments that, one he had Sidonis in sight, he couldn't pull the trigger. Had Shepard not been there, I doubt he would've killed him.

[Krasnoludek666555]

Die. I am a big dwarf fan, and i also agree with a lot of their philosophy. If you break the law/are honorless, you must face consequences.



PS. And yes, I support death punishment in real world (of course only for very serious crimes).

[Maginipowfire]

Ray Joel Oh wrote...

Landline wrote...

I trust Garrus to be able to make his own choices in life.

Its his choice, I'll go along with him, and he wants him dead.

It's self destructive.  Come on, people!  Read your Batman!

What are you talking about. Look how Jack turned out, I mean... Oh... 

I kill Sidonis anyway, he deserved it.

[Markinator_123]

kill him

[Bigdoser]

I let him live.

[Ray Joel Oh]

Maginipowfire wrote...
What are you talking about. Look how Jack turned out, I mean... Oh... 

I kill Sidonis anyway, he deserved it.

Shooting him isn't even sadistic, though.  He doesn't learn anything, doesn't have time to realize what's happened, in fact it's relief from his life of guilt.  I'm happy letting him live knowing he feels in debt to Garrus.

[Axterix]

Daskworx wrote...

It says in a news report he turns himself in. I just thought "Fat lot of good hes going to do in a cell..."

It says he's trying to, yes.  The problem though is that the Citadel has no jurisdiction on Omega and no extradition treaty since Omega has no official government.  So what to do with him is up in the air.

[Bigdoser]

Axterix wrote...

Daskworx wrote...

It says in a news report he turns himself in. I just thought "Fat lot of good hes going to do in a cell..."

It says he's trying to, yes.  The problem though is that the Citadel has no jurisdiction on Omega and no extradition treaty since Omega has no official government.  So what to do with him is up in the air.

Maybe in me3 we might see him in c-sec that would be good.

[trigger2kill1]

I'm cheep. Kill the bastard. A bullet is cheeper than room and board for xx years.



Capital punishment.

[Ray Joel Oh]

trigger2kill1 wrote...

I'm cheep. Kill the bastard. A bullet is cheeper than room and board for xx years.

Capital punishment.

Incidentally, capital punishment is more expensive than room and board for xx years.

But that's not really the issue here.

[Maginipowfire]

Ray Joel Oh wrote...

Maginipowfire wrote...
What are you talking about. Look how Jack turned out, I mean... Oh... 

I kill Sidonis anyway, he deserved it.

Shooting him isn't even sadistic, though.  He doesn't learn anything, doesn't have time to realize what's happened, in fact it's relief from his life of guilt.  I'm happy letting him live knowing he feels in debt to Garrus.

Yeah, and we are the bad ones for killing him... xD

[Ray Joel Oh]

Maginipowfire wrote...

Shooting him isn't even sadistic, though.  He doesn't learn anything, doesn't have time to realize what's happened, in fact it's relief from his life of guilt.  I'm happy letting him live knowing he feels in debt to Garrus.
Yeah, and we are the bad ones for killing him... xD

It's not about being good or bad, it's about what's the best thing for Garrus.  It's a bad situation and letting Garrus assassinate a guy just drags him down further.  Sidonis is already miserable as he should be.  With him living and knowing he's been given another chance, there's an opportunity for him to do something positive.  He was never dangerous, just cowardly.

Modifié par Ray Joel Oh, 13 mars 2010 - 09:36 .

[Axterix]

Ray Joel Oh wrote...

Incidentally, capital punishment is more expensive than room and board for xx years.

But that's not really the issue here.

Only if you allow appeals and let it drag on.  Don't mix up the concept and certain countries' implementation of it.  But yeah, not the topic here.

Anyway, forgot to answer the first reply.

I let him live, because that was the Paragony thing to do.  But really, I was that close to letting Garrus take the shot.  And think I probably should have let him.

In my current renegade playthrough, well, he's toast.

Modifié par Axterix, 13 mars 2010 - 09:43 .

[StefanBW]

How can people call themselves true paragon when they let Garrus shoot Sidonis?!



Freedom is the right of all sentient beings!

[epoch_]

binaryemperor wrote...

epoch_ wrote...

[anal\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\]
Actually thumbs down means "let live". Thumbs up means "kill him".

Somebody in history got it backwards.

[\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\anal]

also I let him live. I kinda liked his whole guilt spiel if you talk with him. Also the dialog with Garrus was interesting. Mostly because I could actually initiate a conversation with him, away from his precious calibrations.

How do you know I didn't post that and let him live?

[eternalnightmare13]

Daskworx wrote...

Driving Ghost wrote...

Garrus wants him to suffer. If he wants that, he should let Sidonis live.

Also, I can see Sidonis making it up to Garrus. Just like he says he will.

It says in a news report he turns himself in. I just thought "Fat lot of good hes going to do in a cell..."

Considering his crimes happened on Omega not Citadel space I doubt much'll happen to him.  Maybe someone from Blue Suns or something will off him in order to shut 'em up.

[ChaosBahamut]

I let Garrus do his thing.



Doesn't matter why Sidonis betrayed this crew, the fact is he did and it cost said crew dearly. Yes I had Sheppard try to talk him out of it but in the end I made it so Sheppard understood that this had to be done.



Damn I feel like a god.

[RyrineaNara]

For me letting Sindios live is what was best for Garrus, and I thought him killing the guy was not in his best interest. He would have gone further in too darkness, if he had taken that shot. The thing is, I have seen what revenge will do to people. It eats away at them until it is all they can think about. Some good anti heroes, are these type of people.

[Driving Ghost]

Daskworx wrote...

Driving Ghost wrote...

Garrus wants him to suffer. If he wants that, he should let Sidonis live.

Also, I can see Sidonis making it up to Garrus. Just like he says he will.

It says in a news report he turns himself in. I just thought "Fat lot of good hes going to do in a cell..."

Indeed, but they were unable to take any action against him because Omega isn't in Citadel Space.

[Onyx Jaguar]

I let him live because I don't like to execute people and I certainly don't want to start assassinating people. And because Garrus is the character that is the easiest to influence I don't want him to start acting that way either.

[trigger2kill1]

Ray Joel Oh wrote...

trigger2kill1 wrote...

I'm cheep. Kill the bastard. A bullet is cheeper than room and board for xx years.

Capital punishment.

Incidentally, capital punishment is more expensive than room and board for xx years.

But that's not really the issue here.

Discounting the f*cking lawyers a bullet vs. xx years is far, far cheeper. F*ck the lawyers. Billy said it best Kill all lawyers.

[trigger2kill1]

dp

Modifié par trigger2kill1, 13 mars 2010 - 10:03 .

[Pauravi]

Either way is defensible, but I usually get Garrus to spare him for Garrus' own sake. Killing him doesn't really do any good for anyone and, frankly, I think Garrus will feel worse about it in the long run. All he really needed to do was close that chapter in his life, and killing someone who used to be his friend is not the best way to do it, IMO.

[Ray Joel Oh]

trigger2kill1 wrote...

Discounting the f*cking lawyers a bullet vs. xx years is far, far cheeper. F*ck the lawyers. Billy said it best Kill all lawyers.

I can see this would be a very mature discussion we would have.