Aller au contenu

Photo

If you could only play one origin...


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
62 réponses à ce sujet

#26
SurelyForth

SurelyForth
  • Members
  • 6 817 messages
Human noble barely edges out mage for me. If the mage was connected to any kind of family, it would probably win out. Unfortunately, Jowan gets more of a back story than the PC mage. It's ridiculous.

I think HN is tops because I can relate so strongly to the type of family the Couslands are and the loss at the end is genuinely heart-breaking because of that. My HN's aren't driven by a need for vengeance (most try as hard as they can to forget about what Howe did until the Landsmeet forces a confrontation) as much as they are driven to live up to the expectations that Bryce and Eleanor laid on them.

I also use my HN's longing for a strong support system as an excuse to coddle my companions. Other PC's usually have one or two that they don't get along with, but my (female) nobles are compelled to make everyone happy.

Modifié par SurelyForth, 14 mars 2010 - 03:50 .


#27
Skadi_the_Evil_Elf

Skadi_the_Evil_Elf
  • Members
  • 6 382 messages
It's a toss up between human mage and human noble for me. Casteless dwarf is a close second. Mage I must supply my own backstory, but it gives enough leeway that i can do this pretty good, and I enjoy the conflict between mage and Chantry. Human noble gives a complex, bittersweet entrance into the Grey Wardens and has plenty of room for inner conflict, regret, and loss.

#28
DalishRanger

DalishRanger
  • Members
  • 2 484 messages
I've played the mage one more than any of the others, which surprises me; I normally prefer stabbing type characters to straight spellcasters. And it's not like I even find the mage origin the most interesting out of them (though I do enjoy it); I think has more to do with my mage character himself that makes me want to replay him/the origin over and over again.

#29
Addai

Addai
  • Members
  • 25 850 messages
I would say elven mage if it had more of a back story, like maybe if you were an Aneirin type (apostate). As it is, my quintessential character is probably my HNF rogue princess-consort.

#30
Cypher0020

Cypher0020
  • Members
  • 5 128 messages
Geeez all the origins are great. Much as I'd love to say mage is me, it'd have to be human noble. I'd be pretty fair with my people, but still want Howe dead.



Oh and having Alistair share the burdens of being a Warden and an illegtimate prince and ruling together is the perfect fairytale ending :)



Now if I was a man, I'd have to say dwarf noble. The political intrigue, betrayal, etc is just perfect




#31
sylvanaerie

sylvanaerie
  • Members
  • 9 436 messages
I like them all but Human Noble pulls at my heart like none of the others. That little boy and his dad's foreshadowing line about swords, seeing Bryce dying and unable to do anything, Mom's bad ass courage with only a bow to defend them as you are dragged away (yea Duncan doesn't ever get a willing recruit in my PC) Ser Gilmore (not only nice eye candy but rare courage and nobility). This was a wonderful story of love, warmth and ultimately betrayal and courage in the face of inescapable circumstances. Makes me tear up just thinking about it.

#32
CalJones

CalJones
  • Members
  • 3 205 messages
I've played mage the most. I like the human noble origin a bit better but the mage origin is the closest you'll get to playing a human commoner, and is also the most versatile in creating character builds. HN runs a close second though.

#33
ImNotTrent

ImNotTrent
  • Members
  • 79 messages
city elf origin, but i love playing mages. i dislike the mage origin honestly, but i've probably played through that origin the most.

#34
RBCharger

RBCharger
  • Members
  • 179 messages

ImNotTrent wrote...

city elf origin, but i love playing mages. i dislike the mage origin honestly, but i've probably played through that origin the most.


Exactly.  City elf female origin is the best origin story but I like the mage class.  Best moment of mage origin is when Jowain, Lily and I come out of the basement naked and I say "This is not what it looks like".

#35
Tinnic

Tinnic
  • Members
  • 200 messages
Mage

I like elves. Which I realise on this board appears to be a minority but I don't care! Knife-ears rule! Although I realise that in Dragon Age, most elves are just pointy eared humans for all intent and purposes.

Modifié par Tinnic, 14 mars 2010 - 04:15 .


#36
DianeLyn56

DianeLyn56
  • Members
  • 74 messages
I love being a Dalish Elf Rogue.

#37
Raiil

Raiil
  • Members
  • 4 011 messages
Human mage. I prefer playing as one to begin with and the idea of being locked away and then getting to break free in a way that none of the other origins can is satisfying.

#38
Ildaron

Ildaron
  • Members
  • 121 messages
The Dalish Mage Origin. I wept when my tribe was taken out. The early Darkspawn battles were very scary. Thank goodness Duncan came when he did. I will always be grateful.



For one that exists outside of my own mind I would say the elf mage. I loved that one. It beat the Dalish one only slightly.

#39
Sarah1281

Sarah1281
  • Members
  • 15 280 messages
I'd have to say Dwarf Noble. I get the impression (from King Endrin not wanting you to have to deal with persistent merchants so you need an escort to the Provings) that as the favorite, you're a bit on the sheltered side. Everyone loves you so how could you not love Orzammar? Then all of  a sudden everything changes and you're sentenced to die fighting darkspawn. That's awful but even with no trial, the Assembly did decree it and going against it isn't the easiest thing in the world...why not join the Grey Wardens? There's a Blight coming and you're sure to fulfill your sentence eventually, not to mention you get the chance to protect your home even if they want nothing more to do with you. You've fought darkspawn before and understand just what a real threat they are.

Playing a dwarf is really the only way I can stand Orzammar due to sheer length (and playing as a commoner makes me hate it almost more than not playing as a dwarf). Unlike in the other origins where you can't really tell what Bhelen or Harrowmont stand for, you already know them and have seen the dwarven traditions Harrowmont wants to preserveand Bhelen wants to destroy.

It also makes it harder to choose a King. In the Commoner origin Harrowmont thinks your entire caste should never have been born and Bhelen makes Rica happy. As a non-dwarf it really doesn't matter. Harrowmont is the only reason a DN even knows to go looking for Duncan and Bhelen betrayed you. The note from your father makes it clear Harrowmont's right about him not wanting Bhelen to succeed him. On the other hand, the betrayal wasn't personal just political and you have to go to Dust Town for possibly the first time in your life and see what it's like. Zerlinda, especially, both horrified and impressed me because her family wanting her to throw away a living breathing child when population was such a problem was unthinkable and she was clearly willing to go much farther than your own father was willing to go for you when he basically wrote you off because he wanted to keep the throne in the family.

I definitely didn't want to be responsible for removing my family from power but Bhelen really didn't show much consideration for ANY tradition except the one that would give the throne to him. In addition really seeing what being casteless was like, my PC was already questioning the caste system after getting to the surface and seeing the way elves were treated. They were both surfacers to her so what was the reason they were relegated to second-class citizens? That, of coure, made her start wondering what the basis was for the caste system, which she had more or less accepted as just part of the society before.

Another thing I liked about DNs is that the minute Alistair confesses about being royalty, she knew that there was a very real possibility that he could end up on the throne and so - when dating him - immediately broke it off before she got too involved. Hardening him was a no-brainer too because everyone around her her whole life had been out for themselves and that was just a basic truth to her that Alistair was a little slow to grasp. Marrying Alistair to Anora was a sound political move and on some occasions recruiting Loghain seemed sensible, too. That Alistair was putting his personal feelings above the good of Ferelden and not helping right when they needed him most just made her lose respect for him and made him come off as more of a child, especially as she usually ended up putting Orzammar before her own feelings and giving Bhelen the throne. If she could put her feelings aside, she had no patience for his refusal to.

Doing the ritual was a must because she wasn't a saint, had no intention of dying, and also refused to spend the rest of her life rebuilding the Grey Wardens. On the other hand, it needed to be done and Loghain was pretty much forced to spend the rest of his life with the Wardens while no one was going to be forcing their hero to do anything. Maybe Morrigan could be trusted, maybe she couldn't. Maybe she knew what she was doing with the kid, maybe she didn't. That was definitely a problem they would't be facing for two decades or so and if the Wardens were properly rebuilt, they could probably handle it. And the minute Gorim mentione she was being considered as a Paragon and confirmed that she was, indeed, no longer an exile she wondered why in the world she was still in Denerim.

#40
brain_damage

brain_damage
  • Members
  • 902 messages
Human Noble. Or city elf, but I still prefer the human noble.

#41
HarlequinDream

HarlequinDream
  • Members
  • 384 messages
I'm torn between Dalish and Mage. They're the ones that struck me most.

#42
Gilsa

Gilsa
  • Members
  • 5 828 messages
@Sarah1281 -- I really enjoyed reading your perspective on the dwarf noble. Thanks for sharing.

#43
R-F

R-F
  • Members
  • 506 messages
i liked the human noble origin and the city elf ones the most, they were both quite emotional. i wish i continued on with my city elf, but i was all played out after 2 times through. i really loved the human noble story though, by the end i was so ready to slit Howe's throat.

#44
Ameraudur_

Ameraudur_
  • Members
  • 37 messages
Human noble followed by female city elf...

#45
Caozen

Caozen
  • Members
  • 570 messages
Dwarven Commoner all the way. Being the living equivalent of nug poop has never been so sweet.



...Wait a tick.

#46
Vengeful Nature

Vengeful Nature
  • Members
  • 868 messages
Human Noble, definately. Getting thrust out into the real world from a sheltered life after a personal tragedy, only to rise above it.



Second would be Dwarf Noble. I haven't played a full game with one yet, mostly because I can't get over the height difference, so romances seems silly. If only there was a female dwarven LI.



I find the DN origin more compelling if I quit it before meeting Duncan, pretending that he died in the Deep Roads. It's interesting to think that one wrong turn would have spelt that character's death, and I find it really compelling to think of this embittered ex-noble, shivering round a small fire in some dead thaig, jumping at every sound. It's also fun to think that, whilst he dies in the Deep Roads, his work is carried on by a kindred spirit in the HN. The two would have been great friends. It's quite haunting to think of what could have been...

#47
highcastle

highcastle
  • Members
  • 1 963 messages
Human Noble for me. It's a good thing I played this one last, because I just can't go back to the others now that I know all the goodness the HN origin has. There's so much flexibility in the origin, it ties the most into the main story, and the arc regarding Howe is brilliant. Love it, love it, love it.

#48
draxynnus

draxynnus
  • Members
  • 338 messages
Mage, for the same reason as Gill Kaiser.



That said, I also have two Human Noble characters, and I do feel a certain kinship towards the Dalish in their desire to recover long-lost knowledge as well. The Dwarf Noble origin is also one I'm looking forward to, even if that character is likely to end up very similar to my HN warrior in all but specialisations.

#49
Xandurpein

Xandurpein
  • Members
  • 3 045 messages
Human Noble Warrior with sword and shield spec. Knights in shining armor simply rules when it comes to looks and going eye to eye with mobs as tank just feels three times more heroic than anything else. I really enjoy the whole human noble orgin story, and I also feel so much closer to dog in the Human noble orgin than with any other orgin.



The only sad thing about always being HN Tank myself is that there I have no practical use for Alistair in my group. I like Alistair and his banter a lot, even if he got angry and ran away when I married Anora myself in my canon ending.

#50
SurelyForth

SurelyForth
  • Members
  • 6 817 messages

Xandurpein wrote...

Human Noble Warrior with sword and shield spec. Knights in shining armor simply rules when it comes to looks and going eye to eye with mobs as tank just feels three times more heroic than anything else. I really enjoy the whole human noble orgin story, and I also feel so much closer to dog in the Human noble orgin than with any other orgin.

The only sad thing about always being HN Tank myself is that there I have no practical use for Alistair in my group. I like Alistair and his banter a lot, even if he got angry and ran away when I married Anora myself in my canon ending.


Spec Alistair as DW/2H. You get him early enough that it won't be a total waste of his couple of SS skills (or, if you play on the PC you can use the respec mod). He's never SS in my game anymore and he's a beast.