158 réponses à ce sujet

[NightOak]

Does anyone know if there is a way to keep Mhairi alive during the joining or is she destined to die?

[Shotpicks4me]

If the post in Awakening Forum is correct, she does not survive & there is no way to keep her alive.

[RobbertDewulf]

I guess the game will lack female partners now (dwarf doesn't count).

[HoonDing]

Wait... does she refuse to take part and the PC is forced to stab her in the gut?



I want drama.

[NightOak]

lol it's pretty much her saying "I've been waiting for this" taking a drink and dropping dead.

[Kyero]

Im dissapointed, but hopefuly the elf mage chick doesnt die. if she does, I declare Dragon age Awakening a Sausage fest ._.

[Mystranna Kelteel]

I finally get a female warrior to complete my party and she dies just like that?!



BS, BioWare, Oghren doesn't cut it. Not at all.

[Lady Rivinn]

I can't believe they'd introduce a character just to remove them like that... I was just looking forward to having a female tank. Who's suppose to be my tank now? I don't want Oghren bleh!

[redleafchewer]

Oghren is only good for comedy relief, surprised me they killed her so fast

[KendallX23]

if u have oghren as a main tank prepare to fight everything that moves...no diplomacy or anything else or have him with below 0 approval...

[mjustini99]

Yeah, who knows when I'll meet Justice, but until then I have no tank ... and no, Ohgren isn't really a good option.

[MoeIII]

Well, that just sucked.

[Le_Mieux]

It's what is known in the industry as, 'Bad Writing'.



Lazy writers will often use this as what they think as a clever way to convince the player/reader that, 'sh** just got real'. When in fact it's just a dick move.



Basically they create and kill a character to give the illusion of the trope, 'Everybody Dies', without actually affecting the story or the world at all.

[Leon Elsa]

Le_Mieux wrote...

It's what is known in the industry as, 'Bad Writing'.

Lazy writers will often use this as what they think as a clever way to convince the player/reader that, 'sh** just got real'. When in fact it's just a dick move.

Basically they create and kill a character to give the illusion of the trope, 'Everybody Dies', without actually affecting the story or the world at all.

You make too much sense. 

[Kaeluwen]

This was a complete joke to kill the her off that quickly. At least she could have been joined and kill her off later in the story ala ME1. A real letdown for people not playing a tank as their main.

[JasonPogo]

This is just one more resone this expanshion was major ****. Bioware droped the ball so hard it makes me sad...

[steelfire_dragon]

anyone planning on modifying this?



she wont have any dialogue .... or VA

[Noir201]

Reading the threads about this still annoy and upset me

Had to play good old jade empire, to remember what great female party members are like again, can't bring myself to play on da:o and finish my HNF just yet.

Modifié par Noir201, 17 mars 2010 - 11:53 .

[tzs.nicholas]

Le_Mieux wrote...

It's what is known in the industry as, 'Bad Writing'.

Lazy writers will often use this as what they think as a clever way to convince the player/reader that, 'sh** just got real'. When in fact it's just a dick move.

Basically they create and kill a character to give the illusion of the trope, 'Everybody Dies', without actually affecting the story or the world at all.

Quote for Truth...

IMO DA:O has always come up short in terms of potential...the game has great potential, but Bioware never quite realizes it....you're given some choices, but they don't have much impact (take Jowan from DA:O for instance). There's way too much linearity. Mhairi is a poor attempt at a plot twist. 

The DAO:A would be more amusing/interesting if they randomly killed off one of the three in the joining....shake things up a little....or make you choose like in ME1 when the characters have made some sort of contribution (although I never really used Ash or Kaiden much)....

I wonder how much of an effect this expansion will have on Dragon Age II....if there is one...or maybe it'll be based on a totally different character (i.e. Morrigan's child -if this were the case, adds insult to injury about choices having impact - a child that's somewhat a god...sounds familiar....where have I heard that before??)

I had a blast with ME2...finished it before DA:O, which I started first....it started to get a little tiring fight after fight after fight...I wonder how long it will take me to complete this half-baked expansion...

apologies for rambling

[Maria Caliban]

NightOak wrote...

Does anyone know if there is a way to keep Mhairi alive during the joining or is she destined to die?

She dies. Always.

Le_Mieux wrote...

It's what is known in the industry as, 'Bad Writing'.

Daveth and Jory both died in Dragon Age: Origins. It's the Joining; someone has to die. That you don't like the fact that someone dies doesn't make it bad writing.

Modifié par Maria Caliban, 17 mars 2010 - 01:33 .

[Misophor]

Yeah, I was pretty confused considering when you enter the keep one of the dialog branches you go through adds 10 approval.

[Drwhy]

Just let her go at the end of the quest and don't recruit her, it's only way she lives in the epilogue as far as I know.

The way I see it, you helped her do what she was there for, she is a member of the Legion of the Dead and one of the only survivors left, I prefer to let her stay in her order and see what she does with it.

Modifié par Drwhy, 17 mars 2010 - 02:13 .