Ovidi wrote...
Cyjack wrote...
David Gaider wrote...
Hate to break it to you, but right after DA:O came out if you came anywhere near the forums you would have thought it must be the worst game in existence. This is pretty typical after any game gets released (or it is for us, perhaps, I don't hang around on other companies' forums very much) -- RPG fans are pretty passionate about what they like and don't like, and the ones that don't like tend to post again and again and again and again. Why? That's for a Psychology major to explore, I suppose.
It would be easy to assume that those posting on this forum represent the majority. That, however, simply isn't true. If you spend enough time on the forums, however, it's easy to believe that it must be. It's all the evidence you're exposed to, after all. But if you honestly believe that, you're only fooling yourself.
.
Kind of silly to assume the opposite as well...that when the more casual forum participants or dissenters leave a week or so after a new release, that the voices that remain are a more *accurate* sample. These boards are populated by diehard Bioware fans. Nobody else would hang out here after their initial playtime with the game had expired, and the *majority* of the entire base of people who buy the game wouldnt ever bother coming here at all.
Either way, positive or negative, these boards are not indicative of the audience at large. They are not an accurate sample. If anything, the sort of feedback you get right after release is more indicative of the audience at large, because you're getting a wider sample, beyond the self gratifying echo chamber of the diehard Bioware fanbase.
Not always though. Immediately following the release of Fallout 3 every forum was filled with topics derogatively referring to it as "Oblivion with guns". In spite of that, its pretty obvious by now that it's been very well recieved by most.
I'm pretty certain you can go to any oyther game board other than Bethesda's, and get that same opinion drummed up at you pretty quickly. The only people that hang out on official boards after their game experience is done, are diehard fans. People with strong negative opinions hang out long enough to rake their muck on the boards, then depart for more unbiased waters, leaving them mostly populated by the fans. But theyre still out there.
I'm not sure how you define "well received", either. Oblivion sold a boatload of units, and got good reviews, but if you bring it up on any game boards other than Bethesda's, the majority of the feedback you get about it will be negative.
American Idol is *popular*. It is not, however, indicative of *good music* to very many people who know much about music. If you were to bring up the show on a board populated by people who knew quite a bit about music, and were passionate enough to constantly discuss it on a message board, the response would not reflect the popularity of the show. Does that mean "American Idol" is still "well received"? I don't know.
But I do know dismissing the negative feedback you get around a release, in favor of the usual support you get from the people who are big enough fans to stick around here all the time is a rather dubious proposition. The people who dont like something try to make their voice heard, but eventually leave. The fans stick around. Neither is an accurate sample, but you get a broader range of reactions around a release that is probably more honest overall, than what you generally see on Fan boards during business as usual.
Modifié par Cyjack, 17 mars 2010 - 06:19 .