142 réponses à ce sujet

[Zeleen]

OK,

So the big choice at the end of the game.
Do you choose to defend the keep or the city?
How did it end for you?

Modifié par Zeleen, 17 mars 2010 - 10:42 .

[Fishy]

I saved the keep.Obviously because it's a stronghold with fortified defense and the city 's already besieged and 90 % of the civilians are either dead or tainted by the darkspawn.

i made a pragmatic choice

Modifié par Suprez30, 17 mars 2010 - 08:14 .

[Blindside002]

Actually if you save the city a great deal of the Civilians are still alive, very few got tainted.

[JigPig]

Left Anders, Oghren,and Nathaniel in the Keep.

Saved the city, epilogue said they found Ander's Body with an arrow through his neck surrounded by 100 darkspawn corpses killed by magic.

Oghren died, Felsi cried.

Nathaniel died, avenging his family's name.

[Raiil]

I chose to defend Amarathine, with Nathaniel, Justice, and Sigrun. Velenna disappeared, Anders lives but takes off eventually. Justice just sort of... lol ~poofs~ away, and Nathaniel takes off after a while, along with Sigrun.





Apparently I'm not going at keeping Wardens, just recruiting them. At least the townfolk like me.

[Blindside002]

Everyone lived in mine. Anders single-handedly defeated a wave of darkspawn, Oghren killed 2 armored ogres before he passed out, Justice I believe fulfilled his promise and left the body for Aura to bury. Took Velanna, Sigrun, and Nathaniel. Both Velanna and Nathaniel had good endings, Sigrun didn't for some reason, maybe it had to do with her contesting my siding with the Architect and how hard it was to get Approval with her.

[Lady Jess]

Oh finally someone's discussing it, I'm stuck at the beginning too chicken to start, for fear of choosing wrong early and screwing something up badly...lol

[Corti78]

I chose the city. Quite a number of citizens lived and of course the city survived. The Vigil took a week or so to fall but all my defenders lived. Anders wiped out hundreds of darkspawn, Ohgren took out 2 armored Ogres while defending the gate, Sigrun led the charge when the walls broke and Nathaniel put up a great defense or something (yes I left 4 people).

The city was repaired in 1 year and the Vigil was completely rebuilt in 5. So in the end I was pleased with my decision.

Modifié par Corti78, 17 mars 2010 - 10:10 .

[Tankenminnet]

I upgraded it to the max, but sent off soldiers to guard the farms and ****, so I felt it was my responsibility to save the city! I really thought that by having the keep fully upgraded, I would be able to do both. It seems not. Justice got his head chopped off, the keeper was buried (but disappeared), Sigrun led a suicidal but brace charge. Vigil was overrun but not before slaying a billion trillion darkspawn.



I wish I knew all the deciding factors for this. Does the party setup you leave matter? Perhaps their standing with you matters? Seeing as how I had barely bothered to bring or raise any of the ones I left behind (god they were boring), that might've been the case.

[Walina]

That's an interesting sunject :3

[Deuterium_Dawn]

Went with the city. Keep held out, Justice got his head cut off right before the victory horn(not sure if he's actually dead but Kristoff's wife got his body), Velanna got crushed by a wall but disappeared, everyone else lived. Sigrun eventually ran off for her Calling, Anders left for a couple months but came back, I ran off and got my sword stolen.

Modifié par Deuterium_Dawn, 17 mars 2010 - 10:20 .

[Walina]

Is there no way to get an "happy" ending or what ? O.o

Seems it's a waste of time ti strenght up the Vigil keep if all your companions still die...

[xzxzxz701]

I don't think there is a "happy" ending, to get all of your compaions to live you have to save Vigil's keep, but if you leave the city the towns people hate the Grey Wardens so I don't know.

[Corti78]

As I mentioned I did not save the Vigil, I didn't even fully upgrade it but all my companions survived while I saved the city. Seeing so many other people say their companions died makes me wonder what I did to trigger all my companions survival.

[Tankenminnet]

From what I've read, there seems to be a "happy" ending. The companions survives while defending the keep and you save the city. I think that the companion reputation plays in a lot here, affecting their performance- the higher the better. The ones I left behind were so-so and therefore, ended rather poorly.

Edit: Corty, did you send soldiers to the farms? Or to guard miners? Did you have high companion standing with the ones you left?

Modifié par Tankenminnet, 17 mars 2010 - 10:29 .

[Walina]

Corti78 wrote...

As I mentioned I did not save the Vigil, I didn't even fully upgrade it but all my companions survived while I saved the city. Seeing so many other people say their companions died makes me wonder what I did to trigger all my companions survival.

I wonder and make me worry if there is any logic behind it or is it just bugged

[Corti78]

Tankenminnet wrote...

From what I've read, there seems to be a "happy" ending. The companions survives while defending the keep and you save the city. I think that the companion reputation plays in a lot here, affecting their performance- the higher the better. The ones I left behind were so-so and therefore, ended rather poorly.

Edit: Corty, did you send soldiers to the farms? Or to guard miners? Did you have high companion standing with the ones you left?

I said "Protect everything as best as possible." in the meeting, I also sent some to protect the miners. Most of my companions ratings were still low, some I did not even get or do the companion quest for (more so because a couple of them bugged on me).

So I really have no idea what factors into the companion survival. My complete ending was pretty much a happy end, everyone survived, my PC was considered a hero by the people and the Vigil was rebuilt.

Modifié par Corti78, 17 mars 2010 - 10:40 .

[Walina]

So it's really buged >.>

[Andraste_Reborn]

My ending was happy ... and bugged.



I fully upgraded Vigil's Keep and chose to defend the city. When I went to the Dragonbone Wastes, the codex claimed that the Keep had been overrun by darkspawn and the companions I'd left there were dead - but when I got to the epilogue, everyone was alive and well again!



I think this was the intended outcome of my actions and the codex was just bugged, but who knows?

[Vizkos]

Took Anders, Nathaniel, and Velanna to defend the city. Left everyone else at the keep.



Saved the city, the keep with the dwarven walls and silverite troops withstood the assault. Justice got his head chopped off. Olgren actually made himself worthy of his arrogance by defending the gate to the courtyard.



The epilogue kind of made a big deal about how Sigrun went into battle against the darkspawn and didn't flee.

[pudi0072000]

Tankenminnet wrote...

I upgraded it to the max, but sent off soldiers to guard the farms and ****, so I felt it was my responsibility to save the city! I really thought that by having the keep fully upgraded, I would be able to do both. It seems not. Justice got his head chopped off, the keeper was buried (but disappeared), Sigrun led a suicidal but brace charge. Vigil was overrun but not before slaying a billion trillion darkspawn.

I wish I knew all the deciding factors for this. Does the party setup you leave matter? Perhaps their standing with you matters? Seeing as how I had barely bothered to bring or raise any of the ones I left behind (god they were boring), that might've been the case.

This was my outcome as well, although it said that the city was restored within a year and the Keep within 5. I did all of Herren's ore quests, the lyrium bomb quests, and the other dwarf's wall quests. I'm not sure how your Keep died, while mine survived... Odd. (Also had all but Sigrun at 100 approval - she went emo and didn't talk to anyone after killing the Mother.) 

[Tankenminnet]

Well I mean it... sort of survived, the 1 year - 5 thing, but everyone died in it more or less. That grey-haired dude for example died, Justice "died", Sigrun died, the keeper "died". Some shepherd became legendary, I got the silver order thing, but... yeah. Hm.



Perhaps it just depeds on who you leave behind. Now that I recall it, my Justice rep was actually really high, yet he faced a rather unepic demise.

[Sotaklas]

i went to save the city with my companion and stayed there i was confident that the keep will hold and as it turned out it did hold and only the keeper vanished or something it was cool, but the thing that drew my curiosity more was at the epilogue at the end it said the warden left for no reason and no one seen him and that his tales are not over tease for next expansion ? who know's

[Raltar]

I stayed at the City(I had all of the upgrades at the keep, so I felt that Oghren, Valanna and Nathaniel could handle themselves, which they did). During the epilogue, it said that very few citizens were tainted and even fewer died. A lot of the troops at the keep did die, however...but Oghren passed out fighting(but woke later), Nathaniel decided being a warden wasn't for him sometime after and left one day, but his nephew became a warden just like his uncle and eventually became the Warden Commander at Vigil's keep, Valanna left for reasons unknown, as did Sigrun(but she never went through the joining in my game because I didn't have enough time due to recruiting her last). Justice stayed on as a warden, keeping close contact with Aura until his deteriorating body became too much for Aura...then he left the body(no one knows if he died as well or if he's still out there somewhere). Anders stayed with the wardens for a while, then left. Only to come back to the wardens again.

[Blindside002]

I think whoever you recruit last doesn't get to become a Grey Warden, which may have a significant pull on how the epilogue goes for them. I got Justice last and he died at the Keep I believe, Sigrun I think had an issue with me siding with Architect and got a bad ending, everyone else got good endings. Most of them "Disappeared" after a time, but then again they said the same thing about my character, which may be hinting to something.