Aller au contenu

Photo

THE Morrigan Discussion and Research Thread *Infested with Bugs Yet Again!*


16183 réponses à ce sujet

#9901
KnightofPhoenix

KnightofPhoenix
  • Members
  • 21 527 messages

MKDAWUSS wrote...
IDK, Morrigan's child (OGB or not - I think she has one regardless of DR or romance) could make for an interesting PC for DA3. From the sounds of it, the OGB is unaware of his status (making for another classic BioWare punchline [kinda like Revan and Maric's son] and this time around you get to possibly have one of several pending what choices you made!), and no doubt has a big role to play.


Problem is, OGB is male. Having a male only PC is the recipee for revolution.  

#9902
MKDAWUSS

MKDAWUSS
  • Members
  • 3 416 messages

KnightofPhoenix wrote...

MKDAWUSS wrote...
IDK, Morrigan's child (OGB or not - I think she has one regardless of DR or romance) could make for an interesting PC for DA3. From the sounds of it, the OGB is unaware of his status (making for another classic BioWare punchline [kinda like Revan and Maric's son] and this time around you get to possibly have one of several pending what choices you made!), and no doubt has a big role to play.


Problem is, OGB is male. Having a male only PC is the recipee for revolution.  


But think of the VA and storytelling opportunities! :o:P:lol::?<_<(See: Hawke)

#9903
Brockololly

Brockololly
  • Members
  • 9 037 messages

KnightofPhoenix wrote...

Brockololly wrote...
Yeah, I really hope we go to the Black City...based on the PAX chat with Gaider its seems in DA2 we'll only be briefly visiting the Fade. So like so much else with Morrigan, Flemeth, the Warden and the Old God Baby, at best it would seem we'll have to wait until DA3 to maybe get some more information...


Makes you wonder how Hawke is going to become "the most important person" in Thedas.
I think Hawke has something to do with the "beginning" of whatever it is Flemeth is planing / world change.

Yeah, I'm guessing DA2 starts out with Hawke sort of unknowingly setting Flemeth's plans or the Big Change into motion then for most of the game not hearing much about it. Then towards the end it becomes clear that Hawke was used by Flemeth or something and at the end Flemeth's role comes into the open and that (hopefully!) sets the stage for Morrigan, the Warden and the OGB's return in DA3.

Of course, maybe Hawke is the most important guy in Thedas, but with the Warden potentially in Mirror World, beyond the Fade, The Warden is the most important guy in the whole universe now.

KnightofPhoenix wrote...

MKDAWUSS wrote...
IDK,
Morrigan's child (OGB or not - I think she has one regardless of DR or
romance) could make for an interesting PC for DA3. From the sounds of
it, the OGB is unaware of his status (making for another classic BioWare
punchline [kinda like Revan and Maric's son] and this time around you
get to possibly have one of several pending what choices you made!), and
no doubt has a big role to play.


Problem is, OGB is male. Having a male only PC is the recipee for revolution.  

Well, the OGB isn't even the only child Morrigan could have- she might have a perfectly normal, non Old God son too. But its not a given that Morrigan gets pregnant at the end of Origins- its only if you did the DR (get OGB) or if you simply had sex with her (get normal son). SO the possibility is there that you may not even have a son of Morrigan in your playthrough.

The fact that they mentioned the OGB as being male makes me wonder if that hurts the possibility of playing as him as the PC down the road. Or maybe DA3 or whenever the OGB takes a major role, the possibility of playing as him is like an Origin story? 

#9904
Ash Wind

Ash Wind
  • Members
  • 674 messages

MKDAWUSS wrote...

Ash Wind wrote...

Brockololly wrote...

And on the topic of destiny, fate and prophecy and all that- regarding the Warden remember the encounter with Gaxkang where he says: "Eyes are on you from a very high vantage, Grey Warden."

Makes it seem like the Warden has caught the attention of high ups in the Fade and such. Now maybe thats just the Warden's role in ending the Blight or maybe its something more for the future and DA3, maybe?

Hit that scene on a recent playthrough for WH and was thinking the exact same thing. I always thought it meant probably Loghain/Howe types, but this time Gaxkang seemed to be beyond just the petty politics of the moment and to infer something bigger.

But the Warden for DA:3 is too much to hope for. We have the uninteresting Timmy Hawke... DA:3 will probably be the new adventures of Keith Stone... the most important person in the DA world... Seriously... We mean it this time. 


IDK, Morrigan's child (OGB or not - I think she has one regardless of DR or romance) could make for an interesting PC for DA3. From the sounds of it, the OGB is unaware of his status (making for another classic BioWare punchline [kinda like Revan and Maric's son] and this time around you get to possibly have one of several pending what choices you made!), and no doubt has a big role to play.

Well, of course people tastes are going to be different. It seems pretty clear that if there is a child, OBG or Normal, its a boy... that kind of FUBAR's female players from playing a female character.

Just my opinion, but I have less interest in playing OBG than I do Hawke. As a companion, I think Male OBG would be awesome... ten times more if the PC is the Warden. Finding out his destiny, guiding him along... protecting and trying to influence him. The possibilities are amazing.

As far as DA:2 goes, I forget who said it earlier in this forum, but it mirrored my thoughts: I have little interest in playing Hawke, and yet I have a strong interest in the storyline and the Geo-Political, Religous and Social Implications... What's Flemeth's plan... is she a tevinter mage, one of the original cast out of the black city; what's Morrigan's plan, what happens to the political landscape... the crumbling of the chantry and possible ramifications for mages.

I thought it was a weak statement earlier, but maybe Thedas is the main character of DA. I'm certainly more interested in it than the PC of DA2

#9905
phaonica

phaonica
  • Members
  • 3 435 messages

Brockololly wrote...

phaonica wrote...
That could be very cool, indeed. Something like, maybe it is not immortality that Flemeth (and/or Morrigan) seeks but divinity? When I was thinking about the 'change' Morrigan spoke of (and how I had compared it to the Architect's plan earlier), I had a vague idea that, in the same way that mankind was corrupted and changed into darkspawn, I wonder if people could be changed and ascended into something "divine", perhaps something more like the Tevinter mages sought when they first tried to reach the Golden City.


Now thats an interesting theory I hadn't heard of as yet! Very interesting....I'll probably type up some massive post sometime this week, but the thing with Morrigan's "change" speech is that in some ways it reminds me of Uldred's talk about how Mages were but a larval form of something greater and he was intent on giving them the "gift" of becoming an abomination whether they wanted it or not.

Now I don't think Morrigan wants to turn everyone into abominations, but maybe there is some reverse Taint- instead of being corrupted it endows the person with "divine" Old God like magical powers and abilities?


I hadn't thought of Uldred, but yeah that's another "change" that my character wouldn't advocate. However, at the same time, Wynne is technically an abomination. Rather than turning everyone into demon-abominations, Morrigan could maybe try to turn everyone into spirit-abominations.

Morrigan seems to think that power significantly contributes to her survival and self determination. Does she ever express that power in weak hands is dangerous? Or might she think that empowering people would give them freedom, and not be concerned that much about the dangers? Or that the strong would survive and balance everything out?

I also was considering if it meant anything that when you first talk to Morrigan about the child, she says it will not be hurt when it absorbs the soul of the old god, it will be "changed", and if that had anything to do with the "change" she proposes in WH.

#9906
Guest_PureMethodActor_*

Guest_PureMethodActor_*
  • Guests

phaonica wrote...

That could be very cool, indeed. Something like, maybe it is not immortality that Flemeth (and/or Morrigan) seeks but divinity? When I was thinking about the 'change' Morrigan spoke of (and how I had compared it to the Architect's plan earlier), I had a vague idea that, in the same way that mankind was corrupted and changed into darkspawn, I wonder if people could be changed and ascended into something "divine", perhaps something more like the Tevinter mages sought when they first tried to reach the Golden City.


I had this in mind with my FIRST, theory, with Morrigan and Flemeth working together to try to ascend to the Golden City and be more successful then the Tevinter Mages.

Despite the fact that my first theory is gone, I could still imagine your theory being quite plausible. My one question, then, would be "If Flemeth is attemting to become a Divine, of sorts, then where does Morrigan fit in to this whole thing?"

#9907
Axekix

Axekix
  • Members
  • 2 605 messages

Ash Wind wrote...

Just my opinion, but I have less interest in playing OBG than I do Hawke. As a companion, I think Male OBG would be awesome... ten times more if the PC is the Warden. Finding out his destiny, guiding him along... protecting and trying to influence him. The possibilities are amazing.

I agree.  Having the OGB as a companion instead of the PC (which I doubt they ever planned to do anyway) would be a lot more interesting imo.  I don't think I would want to play Morrigan's romance and her son.  That could just get awkward....

#9908
Nerevar-as

Nerevar-as
  • Members
  • 5 375 messages

Axekix wrote...

Ash Wind wrote...

Just my opinion, but I have less interest in playing OBG than I do Hawke. As a companion, I think Male OBG would be awesome... ten times more if the PC is the Warden. Finding out his destiny, guiding him along... protecting and trying to influence him. The possibilities are amazing.

I agree.  Having the OGB as a companion instead of the PC (which I doubt they ever planned to do anyway) would be a lot more interesting imo.  I don't think I would want to play Morrigan's romance and her son.  That could just get awkward....


It is a possibility. Most of the party in DA itself were optional companions. But it is the problem with the so called big choices. They aren´t or the sequel plot would have to be too different depending on them. In ME2 they didn´t even show the consequences of the Council choice outside the Citadel. It all felt a cop out to me, even if they lived outside Citadel space I´d have expected many from other races to be angry at Shepard and humanity. I don´t want that with OGB. Something like reencarnating a god power level entity should ahve big consequences that should be seen in game.

#9909
Shade of Wolf

Shade of Wolf
  • Members
  • 426 messages

Ash Wind wrote...

MKDAWUSS wrote...

Is it possible that Flemeth had a role in creating the Blight so the Old Gods to be released to basically uproot the Chantry? That could create an interesting dynamic, and totally gray things up by making it a fight between (what we'll call) the Second Tevinter Empire and the Chantry.

But then again, IDK if BW wants to get into religion all that much...


Possibly... or saw it coming and decided to take advantage




****Possible The Stolen Throne and The Calling Spoilers******









In the Calling, Maric reveals that (in The Stolen Throne) the Witch of the Wilds told him he would not live to see the next Blight. Whether its occurs by her design or she simply knows its coming are the unknown... But she clearly has an insight into when the next one was to occur.

I'd love to destroy the Chantry. Would Morrigan be interseted in that or would she be bothered?

#9910
Shade of Wolf

Shade of Wolf
  • Members
  • 426 messages

Brockololly wrote...

phaonica wrote...
That could be very cool, indeed. Something like, maybe it is not immortality that Flemeth (and/or Morrigan) seeks but divinity? When I was thinking about the 'change' Morrigan spoke of (and how I had compared it to the Architect's plan earlier), I had a vague idea that, in the same way that mankind was corrupted and changed into darkspawn, I wonder if people could be changed and ascended into something "divine", perhaps something more like the Tevinter mages sought when they first tried to reach the Golden City.


Now thats an interesting theory I hadn't heard of as yet! Very interesting....I'll probably type up some massive post sometime this week, but the thing with Morrigan's "change" speech is that in some ways it reminds me of Uldred's talk about how Mages were but a larval form of something greater and he was intent on giving them the "gift" of becoming an abomination whether they wanted it or not.

Now I don't think Morrigan wants to turn everyone into abominations, but maybe there is some reverse Taint- instead of being corrupted it endows the person with "divine" Old God like magical powers and abilities? But as far as Morrigan's plan goes, II'm wondering if maybe she wants the power of an Old God herself? In the toolset, despite being outdated in Morrigan's character description, it says this:

Morrigan lacks the will to care about most things enough to excite herself over them. Her primary concern is her survival. She has a difficult time relating to other people, and feels extremely vulnerable outside of the marsh. Her sense of humor is dark and twisted, and she finds the most morbid things amusing.

Her primary goal is to gain skills and knowledge and become a powerful sorceress in her own right. She believes that having a child with the PC's blood will give her access to this power.


So obviously, DR or not, Morrigan thinks she can get more power via the Eluvians and Mirror World. But power to what end? Power for herself? Power for the OGB? Power to stop Flemeth? Or power to herald in the change into the world? WHAT IS HER PLAN? Ugh.....

Maybe Morrigan will appoint herself Queen of the World, with the Warden by her side?

#9911
Shade of Wolf

Shade of Wolf
  • Members
  • 426 messages

MKDAWUSS wrote...

phaonica wrote...

Brockololly wrote...

I hope BioWare gets more into the religion though- they don't need to have the Maker come down or anything crazy like that, but if they explored more of the religion from the "What qualifies as divine?" sort of angle that might be neat. Maybe have the Old God Baby once he's a bit older go around all Jesus like performing miracles with some people worshipping him like Andraste while he may not be divine necessarily but simply have the soul of an Old God, which for all we know is just the soul of a dragon. Is that truly divine? Is that truly worth worshipping?


That could be very cool, indeed. Something like, maybe it is not immortality that Flemeth (and/or Morrigan) seeks but divinity? When I was thinking about the 'change' Morrigan spoke of (and how I had compared it to the Architect's plan earlier), I had a vague idea that, in the same way that mankind was corrupted and changed into darkspawn, I wonder if people could be changed and ascended into something "divine", perhaps something more like the Tevinter mages sought when they first tried to reach the Golden City.



It's going to have to be something that's done right - if not, it could be a big disappointment if not something that's either borderline or outright offensive, considering we are dealing with religions here. We have the Chantry which more or less comes off as the Catholic Church; Andraste as this combination of Jesus and Joan of Arc; the Revered Mothers as priests, Grand Clerics as bishops, and Divines as the Pope...

IDK if EAWare really wants a horde of outraged Catholics and possibly The Vatican to come down against them...

Bioware definitely wo't be the first to do so, and I agree completely with your metaphors. The Vatican can't do nothing to them if it stays witin creative bounds, like singing a song about religion or something. The only thing that makes me doubt this is the fact that there's magic in DA.

#9912
Shade of Wolf

Shade of Wolf
  • Members
  • 426 messages

KnightofPhoenix wrote...

Brockololly wrote...
Yeah, I really hope we go to the Black City...based on the PAX chat with Gaider its seems in DA2 we'll only be briefly visiting the Fade. So like so much else with Morrigan, Flemeth, the Warden and the Old God Baby, at best it would seem we'll have to wait until DA3 to maybe get some more information...


Makes you wonder how Hawke is going to become "the most important person" in Thedas.
I think Hawke has something to do with the "beginning" of whatever it is Flemeth is planing / world change.

How will people take that all in all? Hawke being the most important person? I know a lot of people who will hate the idea. I'm already beginnng to hate the character of Hawke. But I won't judge too harshly until I play the game.

#9913
Shade of Wolf

Shade of Wolf
  • Members
  • 426 messages

Brockololly wrote...

KnightofPhoenix wrote...

Brockololly wrote...
Yeah, I really hope we go to the Black City...based on the PAX chat with Gaider its seems in DA2 we'll only be briefly visiting the Fade. So like so much else with Morrigan, Flemeth, the Warden and the Old God Baby, at best it would seem we'll have to wait until DA3 to maybe get some more information...


Makes you wonder how Hawke is going to become "the most important person" in Thedas.
I think Hawke has something to do with the "beginning" of whatever it is Flemeth is planing / world change.

Yeah, I'm guessing DA2 starts out with Hawke sort of unknowingly setting Flemeth's plans or the Big Change into motion then for most of the game not hearing much about it. Then towards the end it becomes clear that Hawke was used by Flemeth or something and at the end Flemeth's role comes into the open and that (hopefully!) sets the stage for Morrigan, the Warden and the OGB's return in DA3.

Of course, maybe Hawke is the most important guy in Thedas, but with the Warden potentially in Mirror World, beyond the Fade, The Warden is the most important guy in the whole universe now.

KnightofPhoenix wrote...

MKDAWUSS wrote...
IDK,
Morrigan's child (OGB or not - I think she has one regardless of DR or
romance) could make for an interesting PC for DA3. From the sounds of
it, the OGB is unaware of his status (making for another classic BioWare
punchline [kinda like Revan and Maric's son] and this time around you
get to possibly have one of several pending what choices you made!), and
no doubt has a big role to play.


Problem is, OGB is male. Having a male only PC is the recipee for revolution.  

Well, the OGB isn't even the only child Morrigan could have- she might have a perfectly normal, non Old God son too. But its not a given that Morrigan gets pregnant at the end of Origins- its only if you did the DR (get OGB) or if you simply had sex with her (get normal son). SO the possibility is there that you may not even have a son of Morrigan in your playthrough.

The fact that they mentioned the OGB as being male makes me wonder if that hurts the possibility of playing as him as the PC down the road. Or maybe DA3 or whenever the OGB takes a major role, the possibility of playing as him is like an Origin story? 

Maybe he'll be a powerful endgame recruit in another game, or be like an npc who you see a lot and do lots of quests for and then OMG he could have done it all himself.

#9914
Shade of Wolf

Shade of Wolf
  • Members
  • 426 messages
What if the OGB could be romanceable by the PC in future games? I played as a male Warden and romanced Morrigan (as a guy obviously) but maybe if you had to romance the OGB to continue the Morrigan plot it would open up many possibilities, such as having a baby with him. This would make it so that you play as a female. Maybe the cover character for the DA3 (or later release) will be female.

Sorry for the 6 ina row post!Posted Image

Modifié par Shade of Wolf, 15 septembre 2010 - 04:16 .


#9915
Jacks Smirking Revenge

Jacks Smirking Revenge
  • Members
  • 561 messages
I think BioWare has backed themselves into a corner with the OGB. They can either canonize him or make him a subtle part of the game.



I'm thinking the latter, so I'm not expecting any tangible things about the OGB. I'm thinking at best mentions from NPCs or epilogue slides. I don't think BioWare would direct enough budget for one optional component to do be "apart" of the world. I mean apart as in a tangible form, design, voice, character depth, etc.



I could see @ the end of the saga maybe an epilogue slide saying in ______ son of the fabled Grey Warden _____ did _________ and became ________ . Maybe I'm being pessimistic (it has rained for like a week here), so my mood is a little off, but I just don't see BioWare adding depth to the OGB since he is optional and has so many variables to what makes him a character.

#9916
GardenSnake

GardenSnake
  • Members
  • 425 messages
Back from my Reach overdose! Crap I've missed a lot. Talking about the OGB I see? Well, the possibility of him being a pc in future games is out of the question (unless Bioware makes us play as only a guy, and then the fire started on the forums will be ireversable). Him being a companion isn't a stretch is it? Unless of course they make him a party member as a kid (doubt it, but it has been done with that little girl in Jade Empire, and Urthemiel's soul could potentially be a spirit or something. That would allow him to be a combatant.), he'd probably be in his twenties to thirties or even older. That would require the Warden to be dead and Morrigan to be old. Not a big fan of that route. DA3 can involve Morri and Flemeth's power struggle, and the baby can be an extention of that? I mean for example, Flemeth wants to get her hands on the baby for x reason that Gaider will hopefully explain and so on and so forth. It could work, well at least it all works out perfectly in my head.

#9917
Morrigans God son

Morrigans God son
  • Members
  • 483 messages
Does anybody have a general idea when the patches will be out for Witch Hunt?

#9918
Aphetto_LC

Aphetto_LC
  • Members
  • 190 messages

Morrigans God son wrote...

Does anybody have a general idea when the patches will be out for Witch Hunt?

Probably not until at least Microsoft certifies the patch. 

#9919
Bruddajakka

Bruddajakka
  • Members
  • 1 508 messages
I'm guessing they have a set path in mind for the child so you'll end up playing as some body who interacts with him. Hell it might very well be possible that it starts in completely different places depending on your character.

#9920
Brockololly

Brockololly
  • Members
  • 9 037 messages

Jacks Smirking Revenge wrote...

I think BioWare has backed themselves into a corner with the OGB. They can either canonize him or make him a subtle part of the game.

I'm thinking the latter, so I'm not expecting any tangible things about the OGB. I'm thinking at best mentions from NPCs or epilogue slides. I don't think BioWare would direct enough budget for one optional component to do be "apart" of the world. I mean apart as in a tangible form, design, voice, character depth, etc.

To me, if the OGB isn't a major part in the world of DA where you did the DR that really shows that BioWare doesn't give a hoot for actually following through with choice and consequence in their games. Gaider has said the DR is the one biggest choice in Origins. From theeir telemetry, they likely know how many people have done the DR. To just relegate the OGB to an epilogue slide or rumor would be a terrible decision- why bother with the DR choice in the first place if nothing ever comes of it?

As for the role of the OGB, it should be said that in Witch Hunt, with respect to the OGB and how it fits in with "Change," if you do the DR, Morrigan says:

The ritual was but a means to an end, a herald of what is to come.


And if you didn't do the DR Morrigan says this:

You denied me the Ritual, but that does not change what is to come.


So however the OGB fits in to the Big Change Morrigan is talking about, it seems the Change is coming regardless of the RItual or not, so if the OGB is primarily involved in the Change, then who knows what sort of role he'd have to play in that....

GardenSnake wrote...
Him being a companion isn't a stretch is it?  Unless of course they make him a party member as a kid (doubt it, but it has been done with that little girl in Jade Empire, and Urthemiel's  soul could potentially be a spirit or something.

They could do something like JE I suppose while still being a kid- that is if DA3 or whenever Morri and the OGB turn back up isn't far in ahead in the timeline.

GardenSnake wrote...
That would require the Warden to be dead and Morrigan to be old. Not a big fan of that route.

I'm not a fan of zooming ahead to a 20-30 year old Old God Kid with the Warden all tainted and Morrigan an old lady. That would just suck.

If they stick with the whole framed narrative angle, they could even have DA3 start out right at the end of Witch Hunt and maybe even have different Origin stories depending on how you ended Witch Hunt and the DR choice. Then with the framed narrative they could cover a larger time period and have the OGB grow up over that time and instead of relegating choices to epilogue slides, they could show the consequences within the game.

And as far as having the OGB as the PC in the future, I just think back to this quote a couple years ago from Gaider from the old forums:

David Gaider wrote...

Quote: Posted 02/05/07 18:52 (GMT) by Lightzy
Bah, I dislike the idea of continuing a sequel with your original character and its choices.

There's no guarantee that this would be the case. What I'm talking about is,  even if you start off with a new character, that what you've done in the original game affects the world and/or your choices in the new game.

What if, for instance, you had a romance with an NPC(just as a hypothetical  example) and this was the only way you could get a "child of the great  hero" origin story in the sequel? Might be kind of cool. Or perhaps you  meet up with characters in the game who are different based on what  happened to them in the first Dragon Age. Or the main villain in the sequel is different based on the first one's events? So long as there is some kind of connection between the first and second game, that would be fine... it doesn't have to be a continuation of a set character.


Modifié par Brockololly, 15 septembre 2010 - 11:11 .


#9921
soundchaser721

soundchaser721
  • Members
  • 238 messages
Anyone else getting a Goku/Gohan vibe from the Warden and the OGB? In all seriousness though, I agree with Brock on the whole idea of a huge jump in time to when the OGB is fully grown up it would just be completely ridiculous. I'm just concerned the the OGB will sort of get swept to the wayside among other things because the DR is optional. At some point bioware has to start figuring out what they're going to do with these major decisions.

#9922
Brockololly

Brockololly
  • Members
  • 9 037 messages
Certainly BioWare can't take every choice and make a big deal out of them. But if there ever was one choice in a game thats begging to be dealt with in a major diverging storyline sort of way, its the DR and the OGB. Witch Hunt sort of side stepped the issue but whatever Change thats coming, if you did the DR then the OGB has a role to play in it, although its not clear how large of a role.

BioWare has a very exceptional opportunity with the DR choice to really do some neat things with player choice and consequences if they want to put the time and resources into that sort of thing. The type of stuff Gaider mentioned in that old post I quoted from 2007 sounds neat- playing as the child of the hero in a future game, having the villain be different depending on how you acted in the first game- its just that at least in ME1 to ME2, the choices were not handled with any real care.

So I just worry that with the OGB we'll get a Wrex or Ash/Kaiden scenario: if you did the DR you get the OGB in role X but if you didn't then that role is simply filled by new character Y who while not being the OGB essentially serves the same story role- hell, they could give that role to Morrigan or something. Bottom line is that doing that sort of thing feels cheap and cheapens the choice, even though its done for obvious cost reasons.

#9923
MKDAWUSS

MKDAWUSS
  • Members
  • 3 416 messages

Brockololly wrote...

Certainly BioWare can't take every choice and make a big deal out of them. But if there ever was one choice in a game thats begging to be dealt with in a major diverging storyline sort of way, its the DR and the OGB. Witch Hunt sort of side stepped the issue but whatever Change thats coming, if you did the DR then the OGB has a role to play in it, although its not clear how large of a role.
BioWare has a very exceptional opportunity with the DR choice to really do some neat things with player choice and consequences if they want to put the time and resources into that sort of thing. The type of stuff Gaider mentioned in that old post I quoted from 2007 sounds neat- playing as the child of the hero in a future game, having the villain be different depending on how you acted in the first game- its just that at least in ME1 to ME2, the choices were not handled with any real care.
So I just worry that with the OGB we'll get a Wrex or Ash/Kaiden scenario: if you did the DR you get the OGB in role X but if you didn't then that role is simply filled by new character Y who while not being the OGB essentially serves the same story role- hell, they could give that role to Morrigan or something. Bottom line is that doing that sort of thing feels cheap and cheapens the choice, even though its done for obvious cost reasons.


And TBH the DR is really the only "choice" the player gets to make, along with the monarchs - all the other choices eventually work their way to a common ground. The Circle Tower is eventually filled with mages and templars, regardless of what you did, the Brecilian Forest is empty of Dales and Wolves, Lothering and Redcliffe are rebuilt, Eamon has a mage child...

It's something that will probably be wasted or lessened because of all the variables (some may have child, some may not, and those who do have numerous variables, including OGB at the very top)... On one hand, I don't want the OGB to basically be what it was in Witch Hunt, something that develops backstage and you hear about it on the grapevine, but I don't want it to pack an equal alternative that basically gets you to the exact same point (though I suppose WH alluded to that that's what's going to happen)...

#9924
Brockololly

Brockololly
  • Members
  • 9 037 messages

MKDAWUSS wrote...

And TBH the DR is really the only "choice" the player gets to make, along with the monarchs - all the other choices eventually work their way to a common ground. The Circle Tower is eventually filled with mages and templars, regardless of what you did, the Brecilian Forest is empty of Dales and Wolves, Lothering and Redcliffe are rebuilt, Eamon has a mage child...

Yeah, although seeing as DA2 seems to focus at least in part on the collapse of the Chantry, I  think the fate of the Sacred Ashes could possibly play a more significant role- I seem to remember in one article or interview the devs mentioning the Ashes as one the choices that definitely has a role in DA2.

MKDAWUSS wrote...
 On one hand, I don't want the OGB to basically be what it was in Witch Hunt, something that develops backstage and you hear about it on the grapevine, but I don't want it to pack an equal alternative that basically gets you to the exact same point (though I suppose WH alluded to that that's what's going to happen)...

Agreed- it seems like the OGB has a role in heralding in the Big Change Morrigan mentions, but that Big Change is going to happen anyway. So why exactly is the OGB so important? It would be stupid if they downplay the OGB though- the ritual was obviously super important to Morrigan yet we still don't exactly know why, other than vague notions of power. How will this Big Change play out differently with the OGB versus no OGB or conversely with a normal child too?

#9925
MKDAWUSS

MKDAWUSS
  • Members
  • 3 416 messages

Brockololly wrote...

Agreed- it seems like the OGB has a role in heralding in the Big Change Morrigan mentions, but that Big Change is going to happen anyway. So why exactly is the OGB so important? It would be stupid if they downplay the OGB though- the ritual was obviously super important to Morrigan yet we still don't exactly know why, other than vague notions of power. How will this Big Change play out differently with the OGB versus no OGB or conversely with a normal child too?


It'd feel like a total cop-out (which we can probably blame more on EA than BW) if the only thing that made the OGB the OGB was a few dialog lines that harbored no impact at all on the development of the story and character. That sort of thing should be more about the father of Morrigan's child (especially if it's a product of Warden-Morrigan romance [I would HOPE that that factors in there somewhere]).

But then again, I'm not holding my breath...