Aller au contenu

Photo

THE Morrigan Discussion and Research Thread *Infested with Bugs Yet Again!*


16183 réponses à ce sujet

#10401
Barbarossa2010

Barbarossa2010
  • Members
  • 2 404 messages

Morrigans God son wrote...

The most likely thing we'll get with Morrigan and the godbaby, is nothing but references. That's my guess. Probably the same with Flemeth after DA2. BioWare will wipe the slate clean again, and start anew. ( Which I wouldn't mind since they have already took away the warden, so who cares about Hawke right? )

I'll stop now, before I give yall nightmares.


Well the developers have clearly stated, and are on record, that Morrigan will return, so no nightmare scenario there.  Whether the Warden returns, and certainly the status of the OGB...well, those are definitely big question marks, and perhaps might be relegated to reference and Codex.  You could be right, since the OGB is clearly not a common denominator among all players. 

I, for one, certainly agree with you about Hawke.  His presence bodes poorly for what I was hoping for out of the franchise.  A revolving door of PCs and companions is uninteresting.

#10402
Morrigans God son

Morrigans God son
  • Members
  • 483 messages
Can someone tell me, what the "gift" is at the end of Witch Hunt? Or are we not meant to see this "gift"

I don't know because I play on xbox 360, and so far I have not got the patch.



Oh yeah, I would be even more disapointed ( If that's even possible ) with DragonAge as a series if they didn't answer the questions conerning the godbaby/Morrigan. Tbh I'm only still interested in Dragon Age 2 because of Flemeth, and I have hopes that we might get some reference to the godbaby or Morrigan. I can't see myself spending £50/£60 on Dragon Age 2, too get small references to the questions I want answered. Oh! and I hate the voice wheel, so bad.

#10403
UFOash

UFOash
  • Members
  • 1 095 messages

MoSa09 wrote...

UFOash wrote...


My point was Flemeth's aren't necessarily wrong, just like you protect Morrigan (or at least MoSa09 does) you must realise those are also Flemeth's ideals.


I am not protective, and my opinion has nothing to do with her looks. I had those kind of arguments a hundreds times before, and in the end, it all comes down to this:

There is reason to trust Morrigan, and there is reason not to trust Morrigan. What you do is your choice and part of the game and its choices.

There is reason not to trust Flemeth. Maybe there is reason to trust Flemeth, and i am sure she could provide some, though i am certain she would just laugh when you ask her.But in game, i've found no reason to trust her.

You have to make a choice and pick one. I am fairly certain DA 2 and Flemeth will show us the flip side of the coin, and she will offer many explanations to trust her and not Morrigan, as this time around Morrigan cannot defend herself.  And in DA 3, its all about choosing.

But in Origins, i made mine because of reasons. You don't have to agree upon them, and of course i could be wrong, but not i am not protective or just caring about the looks.

Origins is about choices, and if you believe Morrigan or not is one of them. If you made a good or a bad decision will be revealed later, if at all.


Woah! Don't mince my words there!

I never said you were being overprotective, and you definately defended Morrigans views, I'm not saying there's anything wrong with that or that your wrong but you definately did.

I also said basically what you just said, that DA:O only really gave Morrigan's side of the story (Flemeth never really tried to tell hers so we may not have had much choice, but we still didn't hear it regardless) & that just because the Warden took her side (or didn't) doesn't prove who was right & we can't make a real decision on this until we've heard everything.

And I also never said you only cared about her looks, I actually gave 3 reasons (I'm sure theres others) why people might trust Morrigan over Flemeth, I doubt there are many on here who only like Morri for her looks but I'm sure the other two (Flemeth not getting her side told, as you said yourself, and Morrigan's as well as others stories about what Flemeth was really like) had/have an impact on why Flemeth is always/mostly seen as worse or more evil/sinister than Morrigan despite the fact that alot of what Morrigan says on many issues is what Flemeth brought her up with & undoubtedly thinks herself.

I was saying that just because we trust Morrigan (or not) doesn't change whether Morrigan or Flemeth (or either or both) is right & we don't get enough to think about in Origins to help us make a proper decision on that.

Modifié par UFOash, 03 octobre 2010 - 10:23 .


#10404
Brockololly

Brockololly
  • Members
  • 9 037 messages

UFOash wrote...
My point was Flemeth's aren't necessarily wrong, just like you protect Morrigan (or at least MoSa09 does) you must realise those are also Flemeth's ideals.

But we really don't know anything about Flemeth personally. With Morrigan we know that she is human, that while she may profess all of Flemeth's mantras on power and such, with Morrigan she is still more of an open book than Flemeth.

Flemeth is a centuries old abomination- thing that, as is evident in the Stolen Throne, kills men for no reason leaving their dead bodies to rot outside her hut. Flemeth has legends surrounding her highlighting how she once raised an army and how she steals men away to kill them. So, you could say that Morrigan only follows FLemeth's ideals, but its only because thats all she has known her whole life- she hasn't been able to see the world and form her own views on things outside of the purview of Flemeth. Morrigan is still a bit of a blank slate thats being formed as she goes out in the world- with Flemeth her views on things seem set in stone.

Perhaps its because Flemeth isn't an attractive female, perhaps its because she isn't a party member like Morrigan and you can't reach beneath her facade or discover her in depth, or perhaps its the stories Morrigan & others tell of "The Witch of the Wilds" but Flemeth is treated as an Archdemon while Morrigan is treated as the misunderstood princess despite the huge amount they have in common.

Morrigan has things in common with Flemeth sure. But with Morrigan you can get a feeling for the fact that she is a human being underneath it all. With Flemeth, she isn't even human, and certainly has a track record for scheming with the big important people of Thedas history like Maric, the Warden and soon, Hawke. And while Morrigan also has her secretive plan, you're able to learn much more about Morrigan as a human being than you are with Flemeth. All Flemeth does is play you like a puppet and dispense cryptic answers.

Also something I thought of after reading poster/comic Brock posted where Flemeth is teaching Morrigan, why would Flemeth go to all the trouble of teaching Morrigan all this if she intended to take Morri's body, good ammunition for the argument that Flemeth never intended to steal Morrigan's body.

She is teaching Morrigan to be powerful precisely because she intends/intended to steal her body. The whole point is that as Morrigan becomes more powerful, that makes it easier for Flemeth to settle in to Morrigan's body.

The trust thing is invalid to the conversation, if (sounds strange but bear with me) Flemeth had been the party member, the Warden had fell for her & she had said Morrigan was evil & had to be killed, The Warden (not having heard Morri's side of the story) would have done the same as he did with Flemeth for Morrigan in reality, neither prove who was right because the Warden knows so little & is mearly trusting, as Chantry followers trust there is a maker, that they are doing the right thing but whether they are or not is purely a guess as they only hear Morrigans side in Origins.

I understand where you're coming from and agree to an extent. But the thing is, Flemeth has a long rap sheet in legend at least, of being up to bad stuff. Morrigan doesn't, despite being raised by Flemeth. Flemeth is a centuries old abomination that is certainly set in her ways- you wouldn't be convincing Flemeth not to spare the Cirlcle mages or anything like that.  The other issue is that Flemeth doesn't even care if you kill her- she isn't even human so you kill her, she'll just come back again. Thats not the case with Morrigan- so perhaps if you confronted Morrigan like you did Flemeth, maybe she would have been more forthcoming than Flemeth.

FYI about Andraste I think from what you hear in the temple Andraste seems a bit intolerant too, the Tevinter Imperium had done no more bad than Orlais & Fereldan had in their pasts, its utter destruction seems a bit of a harsh punishment not to mention the guy who is supposed to do the "good thing" by accepting being cuckolded.

Well, the whole "possibly using gobs of blood magic to destroy an entire race of people and sink their city in to the ground, then sell their whole culture into slavery while invading heaven, creating a race of monsters that periodically swarm to the surface destroying all civilization" seems like a bit of a black mark on Tevinter's reputation. I can see why maybe people wouldn't be too happy with them over that stuff.

As far as Flemeth goes I'd just point to this quote by Mary Kirby on Flemeth:

Mary Kirby wrote...

She's a thousand-year-old abomination, a shapeshifter who, according to legend (and according to the grimoire you give Morrigan) seduces mortal men in order to get herself more daughters. Her daughters are reputed  to be able to kill men with fear. She's both a seductress and a hag.  She played up the hag aspect for the Warden, "Oh, never mind me, I'm  just a crazy old bat who saved your life! Go on your quest and take my  daughter with you! I'm sure nothing terrible could come from that..."  But just because the Warden only saw her as the hag, doesn't mean that's all she was...

I would advise you that in any dealings with Flemeth, be confident of nothing.


Modifié par Brockololly, 03 octobre 2010 - 10:28 .


#10405
Morrigans God son

Morrigans God son
  • Members
  • 483 messages

Barbarossa2010 wrote...

Morrigans God son wrote...

The most likely thing we'll get with Morrigan and the godbaby, is nothing but references. That's my guess. Probably the same with Flemeth after DA2. BioWare will wipe the slate clean again, and start anew. ( Which I wouldn't mind since they have already took away the warden, so who cares about Hawke right? )

I'll stop now, before I give yall nightmares.


Well the developers have clearly stated, and are on record, that Morrigan will return, so no nightmare scenario there.  Whether the Warden returns, and certainly the status of the OGB...well, those are definitely big question marks, and perhaps might be relegated to reference and Codex.  You could be right, since the OGB is clearly not a common denominator among all players. 

I, for one, certainly agree with you about Hawke.  His presence bodes poorly for what I was hoping for out of the franchise.  A revolving door of PCs and companions is uninteresting.

We don't even know if there will be a Dragon age 3 yet. So we can't be sure if Morrigan will return or not. Besides how much longer will we have to wait? 3,4 more years? Posted Image

#10406
Brockololly

Brockololly
  • Members
  • 9 037 messages

Morrigans God son wrote...

Barbarossa2010 wrote..
Well the developers have clearly stated, and are on record, that Morrigan will return, so no nightmare scenario there.  Whether the Warden returns, and certainly the status of the OGB...well, those are definitely big question marks, and perhaps might be relegated to reference and Codex.  You could be right, since the OGB is clearly not a common denominator among all players. 

I, for one, certainly agree with you about Hawke.  His presence bodes poorly for what I was hoping for out of the franchise.  A revolving door of PCs and companions is uninteresting.



We don't even know if there will be a Dragon age 3 yet. So we can't be sure if Morrigan will return or not. Besides how much longer will we have to wait? 3,4 more years? Posted Image


Yeah, unless DA2 bombs and they never make another DA game again, Morrigan's story will get closure in some form, probably/hopefully DA3.

But for me, if they ignore or marginalize the events of Witch Hunt in it and try to reduce the Warden/OGB to a codex entry, thats incredibly stupid and for me, would pretty much ruin DA.

As for DA3, well, we'll probably be waiting another 2-3 years after DA2 comes out- so that means 2013 or 2014, unless  they cram Morrigan into an expack or something to DA2.

#10407
UFOash

UFOash
  • Members
  • 1 095 messages

Brockololly wrote...

But we really don't know anything about Flemeth personally. With Morrigan we know that she is human, that while she may profess all of Flemeth's mantras on power and such, with Morrigan she is still more of an open book than Flemeth.

Flemeth is a centuries old abomination- thing that, as is evident in the Stolen Throne, kills men for no reason leaving their dead bodies to rot outside her hut. Flemeth has legends surrounding her highlighting how she once raised an army and how she steals men away to kill them. So, you could say that Morrigan only follows FLemeth's ideals, but its only because thats all she has known her whole life- she hasn't been able to see the world and form her own views on things outside of the purview of Flemeth. Morrigan is still a bit of a blank slate thats being formed as she goes out in the world- with Flemeth her views on things seem set in stone.


In the comic you posted, is that or is that not Morrigan poking a Templars eyes out from the inside with Tree Roots?
I doubt Morrigan hasn't killed people in the same way Flemeth has while in the Korcari wilds.
Also Morrigan has seen the world she talks about visiting villages & towns and she also talks about men shes been with & such I doubt she met them in the Wilds.

Brockololly wrote...
Morrigan has things in common with Flemeth sure. But with Morrigan you can get a feeling for the fact that she is a human being underneath it all. With Flemeth, she isn't even human, and certainly has a track record for scheming with the big important people of Thedas history like Maric, the Warden and soon, Hawke. And while Morrigan also has her secretive plan, you're able to learn much more about Morrigan as a human being than you are with Flemeth. All Flemeth does is play you like a puppet and dispense cryptic answers.

Not sure when you referring to but Flemeth never really plays you she barely says anything to you & she did save you life thats something to remember

Brockololly wrote...
She is teaching Morrigan to be powerful precisely because she intends/intended to steal her body. The whole point is that as Morrigan becomes more powerful, that makes it easier for Flemeth to settle in to Morrigan's body.

Fair enough on that one I was referring to the morals & the ideas that would seem a bit of a waste of time if she was just going to erase it by possessing Morrigan

Brockololly wrote...
I understand where you're coming from and agree to an extent. But the thing is, Flemeth has a long rap sheet in legend at least, of being up to bad stuff. Morrigan doesn't, despite being raised by Flemeth. Flemeth is a centuries old abomination that is certainly set in her ways- you wouldn't be convincing Flemeth not to spare the Cirlcle mages or anything like that.  The other issue is that Flemeth doesn't even care if you kill her- she isn't even human so you kill her, she'll just come back again. Thats not the case with Morrigan- so perhaps if you confronted Morrigan like you did Flemeth, maybe she would have been more forthcoming than Flemeth.

Mary Kirby wrote...

She's a thousand-year-old abomination, a shapeshifter who, according to legend (and according to the grimoire you give Morrigan) seduces mortal men in order to get herself more daughters. Her daughters are reputed  to be able to kill men with fear. She's both a seductress and a hag.  She played up the hag aspect for the Warden, "Oh, never mind me, I'm  just a crazy old bat who saved your life! Go on your quest and take my  daughter with you! I'm sure nothing terrible could come from that..."  But just because the Warden only saw her as the hag, doesn't mean that's all she was...

I would advise you that in any dealings with Flemeth, be confident of nothing.


Yeah I can't really argue with a guy from Bioware (although having them reveal things outside the game kinda ruins speculation spawned from whats in the gamePosted Image) but as I said above Flemeth hasn't really said much in-game to give you reason to hate her (perhaps thats on purpose, but still) so all you have to rely on is legends & Morrigan who is at least quite biased.

On this...

Brockololly wrote...
Well, the whole "possibly using gobs of blood magic to destroy an entire race of people and sink their city in to the ground, then sell their whole culture into slavery while invading heaven, creating a race of monsters that periodically swarm to the surface destroying all civilization" seems like a bit of a black mark on Tevinter's reputation. I can see why maybe people wouldn't be too happy with them over that stuff.

What race was this? If its the Elves they are not destroyed.

Now also was this the Tevinter Imperium or just mages from Tevinter, in fact either way the leaders of Tevinter then & the mages will be long dead & I just feel its wrong to blaim an entire nation for what it has or its people have done in the past, the same reason I don't really like Loghain's Anti-Orlesian attitude.

But I guess both those cases have there points, Loghain's thing with his parents or whatever wasn't so long ago so fair enough but the Guardian has been sat in that temple for years, not only has he not seen the world since the temple was created (many years ago) but hes also not even done anything since then to help defeat the Tevinter's, which is quite lame of him.

#10408
Brockololly

Brockololly
  • Members
  • 9 037 messages
[quote]UFOash wrote...
In the comic you posted, is that or is that not Morrigan poking a Templars eyes out from the inside with Tree Roots?
I doubt Morrigan hasn't killed people in the same way Flemeth has while in the Korcari wilds.
Also Morrigan has seen the world she talks about visiting villages & towns and she also talks about men shes been with & such I doubt she met them in the Wilds.[/quote]
Oh, I think its Morrigan killing that Templar. And no doubt she has killed Templars and such who would no sooner kill her. The thing is though, that thats all she has been taught and conditioned by Flemeth- she hasn't had any opposing viewpoints on the world really until the Warden arrives. Its not like Morrigan enjoyed Flemeth's teachings either as is evidence in the banter:
[quote]
Hmph. My mother's stories curdled my blood and haunted my dreams. (VO note: with a bit of bitterness and resentment)

No little girl wants to hear about the Wilder men her mother took to her bed, using them till they were spent, then killing them. No little girl wants to be told that this is also expected of her, once she comes of age.[/quote]
So its not like Morrigan loves everything Flemeth taught her.

And while she has ventured out into the Lothering, thats hardly the world at large- she is shocked when she goes into the Denrim marketplace and says as much :
[quote]What I <emp>want</emp> is to see mountains. I wish to witness the ocean and step into its waters. I want to experience a city rather than see it in my mind. VO note: what she really wants is to experience life outside[/quote]
So its not just that she wants to simply go out into Lothering on her own, its that she wants to experience the world without Flemeth looking over her shoulder too. Heck, even Flemeth says as much:

[quote]It would be interesting to see what she does with her freedom. Enlightening, even. Would you give an old woman that?[/quote]
So it seems that Flemeth realizes Morrigan is open to becoming her own person once outside of her control and that Morrigan may develop her own ideas of the world once outside of her control- and the Warden is one of the people who will influence what sort of a person Morrigan likely becomes.

[quote]UFOash wrote...
Not sure when you referring to but Flemeth never really plays you she barely says anything to you & she did save you life thats something to remember[/quote]
Flemeth makes you her puppet from the very start by saving you at Ostagar. She might say it was just for fighting the Blight, but still, she is so evasive...

[quote]UFOash wrote...
What race was this? If its the Elves they are not destroyed.[/quote]
The elven immortality was destroyed by the Tevinters enslaving them- and much of their culture lost.[/quote]

[quote]UFOash wrote...
Now also was this the Tevinter Imperium or just mages from Tevinter, in fact either way the leaders of Tevinter then & the mages will be long dead & I just feel its wrong to blaim an entire nation for what it has or its people have done in the past, the same reason I don't really like Loghain's Anti-Orlesian attitude.[/quote]
Sure, but thats just how history works, no? The sins of the father and all that- Thats why we still have wars over religion and various other things that happened hundreds of years ago.

#10409
Morrigans God son

Morrigans God son
  • Members
  • 483 messages

Brockololly wrote...

Morrigans God son wrote...

Barbarossa2010 wrote..
Well the developers have clearly stated, and are on record, that Morrigan will return, so no nightmare scenario there.  Whether the Warden returns, and certainly the status of the OGB...well, those are definitely big question marks, and perhaps might be relegated to reference and Codex.  You could be right, since the OGB is clearly not a common denominator among all players. 

I, for one, certainly agree with you about Hawke.  His presence bodes poorly for what I was hoping for out of the franchise.  A revolving door of PCs and companions is uninteresting.



We don't even know if there will be a Dragon age 3 yet. So we can't be sure if Morrigan will return or not. Besides how much longer will we have to wait? 3,4 more years? Posted Image


Yeah, unless DA2 bombs and they never make another DA game again, Morrigan's story will get closure in some form, probably/hopefully DA3.

But for me, if they ignore or marginalize the events of Witch Hunt in it and try to reduce the Warden/OGB to a codex entry, thats incredibly stupid and for me, would pretty much ruin DA.

As for DA3, well, we'll probably be waiting another 2-3 years after DA2 comes out- so that means 2013 or 2014, unless  they cram Morrigan into an expack or something to DA2.

Ugh! That would be terrible if DA2 got an expansion pack for Morrigan, and DA:O is left with the cheap DLC?
I don't know about you guys, but I feel as if the warden should be dealing with Morrigan/Flemeth not Hawke, or some future superhero. *The next greatest person in Thedas*

#10410
UFOash

UFOash
  • Members
  • 1 095 messages

Brockololly wrote...

Oh, I think its Morrigan killing that Templar. And no doubt she has killed Templars and such who would no sooner kill her. The thing is though, that thats all she has been taught and conditioned by Flemeth- she hasn't had any opposing viewpoints on the world really until the Warden arrives. Its not like Morrigan enjoyed Flemeth's teachings either as is evidence in the banter:

Hmph. My mother's stories curdled my blood and haunted my dreams. (VO note: with a bit of bitterness and resentment)

No little girl wants to hear about the Wilder men her mother took to her bed, using them till they were spent, then killing them. No little girl wants to be told that this is also expected of her, once she comes of age.

So its not like Morrigan loves everything Flemeth taught her.

And while she has ventured out into the Lothering, thats hardly the world at large- she is shocked when she goes into the Denrim marketplace and says as much :

What I want is to see mountains. I wish to witness the ocean and step into its waters. I want to experience a city rather than see it in my mind. VO note: what she really wants is to experience life outside

So its not just that she wants to simply go out into Lothering on her own, its that she wants to experience the world without Flemeth looking over her shoulder too. Heck, even Flemeth says as much:


It would be interesting to see what she does with her freedom. Enlightening, even. Would you give an old woman that?

So it seems that Flemeth realizes Morrigan is open to becoming her own person once outside of her control and that Morrigan may develop her own ideas of the world once outside of her control- and the Warden is one of the people who will influence what sort of a person Morrigan likely becomes.

I don't know if you've played Mass Effect but Garrus was similar (albeit much more boring & less hotPosted Image) but in ME2 he always ends up the same way.
I doubt your going to change Morrigan by convincing her she could've been a chantry mage.

Its hardly unusual I mean all young adults want to leave the nest & find their own views, Morrigan herself says that Flemeths teachings had helped her survive & had been necessary to their survival in the Koracari Wilds as not only Apostates but known witches.

She may not like what Flemeth told her, but she uses it constantly (shes willing to sleep with the likes of Loghain, Alistair or any **** Warden for her OGB).

Granted, Flemeth is strict & often uncaring that her daughter was only a child.
That quote from Flemeth wasn't said in any kind of hostile way, interest in how her daughter grows up is hardly a bad trait, Flemeth may well be evil but we have scarce proof of any actual evil from Flemeth so far.

Brockololly wrote...

Flemeth makes you her puppet from the very start by saving you at Ostagar. She might say it was just for fighting the Blight, but still, she is so evasive...


She is very evasive, no doubt that has helped wind these stories up & it implies she has done evil things (if you ask Flemeth about the tales or whatever she normally just laughs or dodges the question, as you say) but lets not forget Morrigan was with her for all her life (whats like like 20 something years?) I'm sure not only has she seen Flemeth's goings on but has probably participated in whatever she does.

She never, however, makes you her puppet.
Their is no catch to saving her except taking Morrigan (which considering the thread were on is not to be taken as a bad thing) & she lets you do whatever you want never asking anything of you even allowing you to "kill" her.

Brockololly wrote...

UFOash wrote...
What race was this? If its the Elves they are not destroyed.

The elven immortality was destroyed by the Tevinters enslaving them- and much of their culture lost.

Brockololly wrote...

UFOash wrote...
Now also was this the Tevinter Imperium or just mages from Tevinter, in fact either way the leaders of Tevinter then & the mages will be long dead & I just feel its wrong to blaim an entire nation for what it has or its people have done in the past, the same reason I don't really like Loghain's Anti-Orlesian attitude.

Sure, but thats just how history works, no? The sins of the father and all that- Thats why we still have wars over religion and various other things that happened hundreds of years ago.


Well the way I thought about this was that Tevinter is based on the Ottomans, yes?
Now the Ottomans did some pretty bad stuff (just ask the Armenians) but it would be harsh to hate Turkey completely & state you will not rest until it is obliterated.

The Tevinters are presented mostly as evil people but whether this is the case or not (this is a game, after all) in reality I find it hard to comprehend that any entire nationality of people is evil or bad.

Also I think you'll find in reality at least feuds can dissolve quite quickly, look at Britain (which Ferelden is based off), they allied with American & Russia in the Wars despite being at war with them only years earlier.

Orlais wasn't long ago (it is stated on the loading screens most Fereldens can still remember vividly Orlesian rule) but Tevinter's time in Ferelden & the black city was long ago & lets not forget the Fereldens themselves enslaved Elves too so were as much to blame, besides everyone else has to live mortal lives its not that big a deal & the Dalish still retain Elven culture so they weren't hit that badly.

#10411
Shade of Wolf

Shade of Wolf
  • Members
  • 426 messages

UFOash wrote...

Well the way I thought about this was that Tevinter is based on the Ottomans, yes?
Now the Ottomans did some pretty bad stuff (just ask the Armenians) but it would be harsh to hate Turkey completely & state you will not rest until it is obliterated.

The Tevinters are presented mostly as evil people but whether this is the case or not (this is a game, after all) in reality I find it hard to comprehend that any entire nationality of people is evil or bad.

Also I think you'll find in reality at least feuds can dissolve quite quickly, look at Britain (which Ferelden is based off), they allied with American & Russia in the Wars despite being at war with them only years earlier.

Orlais wasn't long ago (it is stated on the loading screens most Fereldens can still remember vividly Orlesian rule) but Tevinter's time in Ferelden & the black city was long ago & lets not forget the Fereldens themselves enslaved Elves too so were as much to blame, besides everyone else has to live mortal lives its not that big a deal & the Dalish still retain Elven culture so they weren't hit that badly.

A lot of things in Dragon Age are based on things that are/were real, and also a lot of mythology (I noticed a lot of Irish), but that doesn't mean that they have to strictly convert what happened in the real world to the fantasy world of Dragon Age.
Just because Ferelden is based on Britain, it doesn't have to copy everything that happened, I mean I think the DA games are controversial enough as they are (with all the metaphors to real life) and I think that what they have is good.Posted Image

#10412
UFOash

UFOash
  • Members
  • 1 095 messages

Shade of Wolf wrote...

UFOash wrote...

Well the way I thought about this was that Tevinter is based on the Ottomans, yes?
Now the Ottomans did some pretty bad stuff (just ask the Armenians) but it would be harsh to hate Turkey completely & state you will not rest until it is obliterated.

The Tevinters are presented mostly as evil people but whether this is the case or not (this is a game, after all) in reality I find it hard to comprehend that any entire nationality of people is evil or bad.

Also I think you'll find in reality at least feuds can dissolve quite quickly, look at Britain (which Ferelden is based off), they allied with American & Russia in the Wars despite being at war with them only years earlier.

Orlais wasn't long ago (it is stated on the loading screens most Fereldens can still remember vividly Orlesian rule) but Tevinter's time in Ferelden & the black city was long ago & lets not forget the Fereldens themselves enslaved Elves too so were as much to blame, besides everyone else has to live mortal lives its not that big a deal & the Dalish still retain Elven culture so they weren't hit that badly.

A lot of things in Dragon Age are based on things that are/were real, and also a lot of mythology (I noticed a lot of Irish), but that doesn't mean that they have to strictly convert what happened in the real world to the fantasy world of Dragon Age.
Just because Ferelden is based on Britain, it doesn't have to copy everything that happened, I mean I think the DA games are controversial enough as they are (with all the metaphors to real life) and I think that what they have is good.Posted Image


So what are you saying? Its irrational to expect Ferelden's (who whatever people from Ferelden are called) to get over the Orlesian occupation or were you just making out a general point? Posted Image

It may be a bit early but I think they shouldn't dwell too long.

Modifié par UFOash, 04 octobre 2010 - 10:35 .


#10413
Brockololly

Brockololly
  • Members
  • 9 037 messages

UFOash wrote..
Well the way I thought about this was that Tevinter is based on the Ottomans, yes?
Now the Ottomans did some pretty bad stuff (just ask the Armenians) but it would be harsh to hate Turkey completely & state you will not rest until it is obliterated.

Tevinter is based in part on The Byzantine Empire more than anything.

The Tevinters are presented mostly as evil people but whether this is the case or not (this is a game, after all) in reality I find it hard to comprehend that any entire nationality of people is evil or bad.

I don't think anyone is saying every single denizen of the Tevinter Imperium is pure evil- its more along the lines of them having slavery as a core tenent of their society, along with being ruled by mages- who most in Thedas view as ticking time bombs and if you believe in the Chantry, screwed everyone over with their hubris by invading the Golden City and starting the Blights.

Also I think you'll find in reality at least feuds can dissolve quite quickly, look at Britain (which Ferelden is based off), they allied with American & Russia in the Wars despite being at war with them only years earlier.

I think you're dealing with more along the lines of an Israel v Palestine type feud or  something along the lines of the Crusades when you're thinking of the animosity between Tevinter and other nations in Thedas, especially with the fact that the Chantry is split  with the Black Divine in Tevinter.

Orlais wasn't long ago (it is stated on the loading screens most Fereldens can still remember vividly Orlesian rule) but Tevinter's time in Ferelden & the black city was long ago & lets not forget the Fereldens themselves enslaved Elves too so were as much to blame, besides everyone else has to live mortal lives its not that big a deal & the Dalish still retain Elven culture so they weren't hit that badly.


Eh.. Orlais only was kicked out of Ferelden about 30 years ago. And if you read the Stolen Throne, they weren't exactly kind benefactors during their stay. But as far as the elves go- I don't think there are any out and out slavers operating in Ferelden-thats kind of the point behind the outrage at Loghain at the Landsmeet when you present the evidence he was dealing with slavers from Tevinter in the Alienage. It may happen underground, but it happens right out in the open to this day in the Tevinter Imperium- slavery is the foundation of their society.

And the elves losing their immortality and much of their culture is a big deal to them. They were pretty much the strongest race on Thedas thousands of years ago, only to be reduced to either indentured servants and slaves or wandering nomads basically.

#10414
UFOash

UFOash
  • Members
  • 1 095 messages

Brockololly wrote...

Tevinter is based in part on The Byzantine Empire more than anything.

Well, Ottomans were pretty much the new Byzantine's really, same capital, pretty much the same territory, so...

Brockololly wrote...
I think you're dealing with more along the lines of an Israel v Palestine type feud or  something along the lines of the Crusades when you're thinking of the animosity between Tevinter and other nations in Thedas, especially with the fact that the Chantry is split  with the Black Divine in Tevinter.


Well my point still stands, on your example them not all Israeli's/Jews are imperialists just because Israel invaded alot of land.
My point is that the people of Tevinter can't really be persecuted for everything the Tevinter Imperium has done.

Brockololly wrote...

Eh.. Orlais only was kicked out of Ferelden about 30 years ago. And if you read the Stolen Throne, they weren't exactly kind benefactors during their stay. But as far as the elves go- I don't think there are any out and out slavers operating in Ferelden-thats kind of the point behind the outrage at Loghain at the Landsmeet when you present the evidence he was dealing with slavers from Tevinter in the Alienage. It may happen underground, but it happens right out in the open to this day in the Tevinter Imperium- slavery is the foundation of their society.

And the elves losing their immortality and much of their culture is a big deal to them. They were pretty much the strongest race on Thedas thousands of years ago, only to be reduced to either indentured servants and slaves or wandering nomads basically.


I think it says somewhere about Ferelden's also enslaving Elves (before they became just lower-class citizens.).

Anyway since everything I said about Morrigan/Flemeth seems to have been "left out", I think this discussion should end as it is now completely off topic.

#10415
MoSa09

MoSa09
  • Members
  • 1 526 messages

UFOash wrote...

Well my point still stands, on your example them not all Israeli's/Jews are imperialists just because Israel invaded alot of land.
My point is that the people of Tevinter can't really be persecuted for everything the Tevinter Imperium has done.


Ninja post :ph34r:.

No one is saying everyone born in Tevinter is an evil being. But sadly, the world is not that way. While most people would agree that not individual being is born evil, the very same people have strong prejudices, fear or hatred towards other people born with a certain set of belief system, a certain national background or whatever.
History shapes our understanding of the world, and between two conflicting nations with a violent history, most people from both sides treat their mutual opposites with fear, cautiuon or open hatred. Thats not fair, and it shouldn't happen,  but thats how the world is like, and DA is no different.

#10416
Brockololly

Brockololly
  • Members
  • 9 037 messages
This thread is in desperate need of Morrigan

Posted Image



Stupid, inane Morrigan question for the day:

Morrigan's favorite movie/book/band?



Discuss! XD

#10417
Guest_PureMethodActor_*

Guest_PureMethodActor_*
  • Guests

Brockololly wrote...

Stupid, inane Morrigan question for the day:
Morrigan's favorite movie/book/band?

Discuss! XD


I'm afraid I probably shouldn't answer this question. My views are different enough, as is, that if I answered this it would turn into heated debate that I don't really want to get into :blush:

I DO, however, have an stupid, inane question at a later date once this question is exhausted ^_^



EDIT: btw, Brock, that is a very nice Morrigan portrait. Very beautiful and seductive. Who's the artist that did this?

Modifié par PureMethodActor, 05 octobre 2010 - 03:55 .


#10418
Brockololly

Brockololly
  • Members
  • 9 037 messages

PureMethodActor wrote...

Brockololly wrote...

Stupid, inane Morrigan question for the day:
Morrigan's favorite movie/book/band?

Discuss! XD


I'm afraid I probably shouldn't answer this question. My views are different enough, as is, that if I answered this it would turn into heated debate that I don't really want to get into :blush:

I DO, however, have an stupid, inane question at a later date once this question is exhausted ^_^

EDIT: btw, Brock, that is a very nice Morrigan portrait. Very beautiful and seductive. Who's the artist that did this?


Bah! Go ahead and discuss! I'll say Morrigan might listen to NIN... I'll have to think about the book/movie....

Here is the page from deviantart for the Morrigan drawing: http://quizzicalkiss...-tent-149695255

The expression and the eyes in particular are just perfect

#10419
Zjarcal

Zjarcal
  • Members
  • 10 841 messages
NIN seems fitting for Morri. I'd say Morrigan would also like "Garbage".



As for books and movies... toughie. I'm not a book connoisseur so I'll avoid giving an opinion there, but I think she would enjoy watching "The Ring" especially if Alistair is around, so she could constantly tease him if he gets scared.

#10420
KnightofPhoenix

KnightofPhoenix
  • Members
  • 21 527 messages
Any book that might increase her knowledge or power would be her favorite. But I don't think she'd read for pleasure's sake.

As for movies. Not sure. Most movies these days are not good enough for her.

#10421
Zjarcal

Zjarcal
  • Members
  • 10 841 messages

KnightofPhoenix wrote...

As for movies. Not sure. Most movies these days are not good enough for her.


Too true!

#10422
ximena

ximena
  • Members
  • 769 messages

KnightofPhoenix wrote...

Any book that might increase her knowledge or power would be her favorite. But I don't think she'd read for pleasure's sake.


To the contrary, I somehow see her sneaking away novels which can be about anything - romance, adventure, etc. Why? Morrigan also wants to experience the world beyond the wilds and books are kind of an escape.

#10423
KnightofPhoenix

KnightofPhoenix
  • Members
  • 21 527 messages

ximena wrote...

KnightofPhoenix wrote...

Any book that might increase her knowledge or power would be her favorite. But I don't think she'd read for pleasure's sake.


To the contrary, I somehow see her sneaking away novels which can be about anything - romance, adventure, etc. Why? Morrigan also wants to experience the world beyond the wilds and books are kind of an escape.


I think she'd rather experience all this herself and not read about it. I don't know.
In the Ashes temple, she does not seem a book enthusiast when she suggests burnign them for heat lol

#10424
lilmeezer

lilmeezer
  • Members
  • 43 messages
I was watching Dancing with the Stars tonight and this Jennifer Grey dance (as teacher/student) just made me think of the "Teacher Morrigan" pics which were posted earlier (strangely, though I know you guys really like them, they kinda creep me out LOL). But I could just picture "Teacher" Morrigan and the Warden doing this dance LOL (yes, it's silly I know!):



(looks like a taping from a television, so not the best quality, just be forewarned)



As far as music, Within Temptation? I'm on the fence about books, as, being a bookworm myself, I really get perturbed at her when she wants to burn books LOL but at the same time, she seems like she would be the one who sneaks books at her campfire when all is quiet at night. I was going to say "The Ring" also for movies. Or, what about "Dragonheart" since the Dragon and the Prince are connected. If she did read, I'd say she'd read flora & fauna books so she could learn more creatures into which she could shapeshift, but for fun, hmmm....I'm stumped. I'll keep thinking.

#10425
Zjarcal

Zjarcal
  • Members
  • 10 841 messages

lilmeezer wrote...

...just made me think of the "Teacher Morrigan" pics which were posted earlier (strangely, though I know you guys really like them, they kinda creep me out LOL)...


:(