Aller au contenu

Photo

THE Morrigan Discussion and Research Thread *Infested with Bugs Yet Again!*


16179 réponses à ce sujet

#15201
Terra_Ex

Terra_Ex
  • Members
  • 631 messages

*pops in*

Here, a beautiful fanart of Morrigan & Kieran by Shalizeh:

tumblr_nnffpt0DXr1sk51m7o1_500.jpg
Source: http://shalizeh7.tum...from-dragon-age

*pops out*

Yeah, that's just phenomenal- a really beautiful depiction of the two.

I would totally buy a print/litho of that ^

Seconded.

That is quite possibly perfect.

Yeah, only one thing could improve upon that.



Could be. I thought I just noticed some of the other random ravens in the open world sharing the odd red markings and figured that BioWare was just doing that to all ravens, but I haven't looked at the actual models close up or anything.

As for Morrigan in dragon form, I think the actual dragon model is exactly the same as the regular guardian dragon you get when Morrigan doesn't drink from the WoS. The only difference being that Morrigan Dragon is all purple and maybe the eyes are a yellowish color? I remember taking some screens a while back while messing with the DAI Cinematic tools:

It's sort of similar to Flemeth's dragon form in terms of color and roughly the horns, but they sort of overhauled how so many dragons look in DAI compared to Origins and DA2, it's hard to say how close Morrigan's dragon form resembles Flemeth's, since we didn't see dragon Flemeth in DAI. Flemeth's dragon form had a more normal looking mouth/snout with teeth while Morrigan's dragon form just had the big chunky looking jaw with no visible teeth.

I had a look at the dragons today to determine how similar they are:

Spoiler

To your points - as far as DAI's designs are concerned, the archdemon looks closest to a classic dragon imo, having a reasonably long snout and teeth. In terms of the head structure I think I prefer the original and DA2 style of designs to the new ones - a long mouth with lots of sharp teeth, though I do like the horns on some of the new dragons and the new ones also look more rugged overall while the old ones seemed a touch more elegant. Almost all the high dragons seem to have yellow eyes, except I think the western approach dragon which looks to have red. Some dragons sport distinct teeth and others do not. The horns dominate most of the facial appearances of the dragons imo and I think Morrigan's "horn type" strikes the best balance of all the designs.
  • Brockololly aime ceci

#15202
MisterJB

MisterJB
  • Members
  • 15 587 messages

Do you think Kieran is a mage only if he has Urthemiel's soul?

 

If you're playing a mage Inquisitor and ask "That is not such a bad thing, is it?" and he has the soul, he answers "I would be worse if you didn't have magic, like being blind" which makes sense for someone to whom magic is just another sense.

 

On the other hand, if he is just a normal boy, he answer "No, magic isn't as scary as everyone think" which makes sense for a young boy whose loving mother (and possibly father) is a mage but who is not one himself. Otherwise, he would have simply said "No, I'm one too."

 
 
 


#15203
BurningLizard

BurningLizard
  • Members
  • 153 messages

Do you think Kieran is a mage only if he has Urthemiel's soul?

 

If you're playing a mage Inquisitor and ask "That is not such a bad thing, is it?" and he has the soul, he answers "I would be worse if you didn't have magic, like being blind" which makes sense for someone to whom magic is just another sense.

 

On the other hand, if he is just a normal boy, he answer "No, magic isn't as scary as everyone think" which makes sense for a young boy whose loving mother (and possibly father) is a mage but who is not one himself. Otherwise, he would have simply said "No, I'm one too."

On his answer as a normal boy, I could also see him saying magic isn't scary from personal experience, though I see your point as well. My headcanon, until told otherwise, is that he's a mage no matter what, Morrigan just has herself some strong genes.

 

Another question for everyone. What family dynamic do you like best/think works best for our favorite little family? As in, mage HoF vs non-mage HoF. Do you prefer having him be a mage so he has something to relate to with Morrigan and Kieran and can teach Kieran along with Morrigan. Or do you prefer a non-mage who maybe doesn't have the same connection through their abilities but can provide a different viewpoint as a non-mage, and who can pass their own skills off to Kieran, be it knives, swords, or bows. 

 

Personally I like having the HoF be a non-mage because it means he can teach Kieran physical combat to supplement his magical abilities Morrigan taught him. Adult Kieran would be a complete badass that way. XD



#15204
Jedimaster88

Jedimaster88
  • Members
  • 287 messages

Another question for everyone. What family dynamic do you like best/think works best for our favorite little family? As in, mage HoF vs non-mage HoF. Do you prefer having him be a mage so he has something to relate to with Morrigan and Kieran and can teach Kieran along with Morrigan. Or do you prefer a non-mage who maybe doesn't have the same connection through their abilities but can provide a different viewpoint as a non-mage, and who can pass their own skills off to Kieran, be it knives, swords, or bows. 

 

Personally I like having the HoF be a non-mage because it means he can teach Kieran physical combat to supplement his magical abilities Morrigan taught him. Adult Kieran would be a complete badass that way. XD

 

I agree with you. The idea of Kieran combined with magic and sword skills sounds just so cool. He could become some sort of Jediknight in a way :D .

 

I like the idea that my Cousland warden teaches Kieran about swords, fighting, honor, family history etc. while Morrigan teaches everything she knows about magic.



#15205
Terra_Ex

Terra_Ex
  • Members
  • 631 messages

Do you think Kieran is a mage only if he has Urthemiel's soul?

 

If you're playing a mage Inquisitor and ask "That is not such a bad thing, is it?" and he has the soul, he answers "I would be worse if you didn't have magic, like being blind" which makes sense for someone to whom magic is just another sense.

 

On the other hand, if he is just a normal boy, he answer "No, magic isn't as scary as everyone think" which makes sense for a young boy whose loving mother (and possibly father) is a mage but who is not one himself. Otherwise, he would have simply said "No, I'm one too."

I think he's probably a mage in both, only with the soul he has more latent ability. It would seem odd considering who Morrigan is for her children not to have some form of magical prowess. You could maybe say that OGB Kieran's magic comes out on its own (hence why he can open the Eluvian) while regular Kieran needs more guidance/training I guess. I don't think the comment alone is enough to conclude that he isn't. If he had zero ability I wouldn't think the Crossroads would be the best place for him.

 

On his answer as a normal boy, I could also see him saying magic isn't scary from personal experience, though I see your point as well. My headcanon, until told otherwise, is that he's a mage no matter what, Morrigan just has herself some strong genes.

 

Another question for everyone. What family dynamic do you like best/think works best for our favorite little family? As in, mage HoF vs non-mage HoF. Do you prefer having him be a mage so he has something to relate to with Morrigan and Kieran and can teach Kieran along with Morrigan. Or do you prefer a non-mage who maybe doesn't have the same connection through their abilities but can provide a different viewpoint as a non-mage, and who can pass their own skills off to Kieran, be it knives, swords, or bows. 

 

Personally I like having the HoF be a non-mage because it means he can teach Kieran physical combat to supplement his magical abilities Morrigan taught him. Adult Kieran would be a complete badass that way. XD

This is also my preference. Having Morrigan catch HoF teaching Kieran how to fight when he's *supposed* to be studying- the admonishing look on her face, the two guys exchanging nervous glances, knowing a lecture is coming - it just all flows together nicely. This would also allow Kieran to bond differently with each of his parents due to the differing interests and knowledge which I think makes things inherently more interesting rather than just going for a magic overload. Besides that, a balance of abilities would be helpful if they were in a battle, having everyone be skilled with magic but poor in melee wouldn't help if the opponent was magic-resistant.



#15206
Lord_Anthonior

Lord_Anthonior
  • Members
  • 555 messages

Another question for everyone. What family dynamic do you like best/think works best for our favorite little family? As in, mage HoF vs non-mage HoF. Do you prefer having him be a mage so he has something to relate to with Morrigan and Kieran and can teach Kieran along with Morrigan. Or do you prefer a non-mage who maybe doesn't have the same connection through their abilities but can provide a different viewpoint as a non-mage, and who can pass their own skills off to Kieran, be it knives, swords, or bows. 

 

Personally I like having the HoF be a non-mage because it means he can teach Kieran physical combat to supplement his magical abilities Morrigan taught him. Adult Kieran would be a complete badass that way. XD

 

I always go with a rogue Cousland, he is all about strategy and tactics, setting the area of fighting to his advantage to strike from the shadows. All my main characters are also invested in the Assassin's path, so a mage son who can also strategize, use the strongest spells, the quickest ways to incapacite or even defend himself is all good for the family. Also a knowledge in botany and poisons while Morrigan knows about alchemy and spells. 

 

I watched the video of the path of Morrigan backstabbing Abelas. I'd like to think that the dagger she used in such situation is a gift from the Cousland, in case of been magical incapacitated by templars or other mages she can always carries a small hidden but deadly blade to defend herself. I guess that in my situation since my main HoF is a dual blade rogue, then he doesn't really go fighting and stand in the front line of battles, instead he chooses the areas for ambush or high grounds, with Morrigan by his side using fire and ice, arrows or backstabbing from the shadows the couple could be deadlier than the entire party.

 

I suppose that's one thing the HoF could teach Keiran, use everything to his advantage as well as the Cousland motto, "A Cousland always do his duty" with a slight change into: "Family and Duty above all."   



#15207
SgtSteel91

SgtSteel91
  • Members
  • 1 898 messages

I like a non-Mage Warden and Morrigan raising Kieran; teaching him the best of both worlds of combat. I also imagine Morrigan as the one who learned the secrets of the Arcane Warrior from the Bercilian Ruins (in hindsight with what happens in Inquisition this seems like something Morrigan would do), so Morrigan also weaves in Arcane Warrior skills into the martial training with the Warden and Kieran.



#15208
Lord_Anthonior

Lord_Anthonior
  • Members
  • 555 messages

Now that I think of it since it's not my main world state, so...if the HoF is a human mage then that makes Hawke Keiran's uncle! and Morrigan and Hawke are cousins in law haha!

 

I think I prefer they remain from the Cousland family tree than from the Amell, Guerrin or even Mac Tir family tree hehe.  



#15209
MisterJB

MisterJB
  • Members
  • 15 587 messages
 

"He asked me to teach him. And It's important. What if he has to defend himself near Templars or against them?

 

My love, your logic is sound. What bothers me is not that Kieran be trained in martial forms of combat but rather that he is seven years old and you PLACED A STEEL SWORD WITH AN ACTUAL EDGE IN HIS HANDS!

 

But...he can't hurt me and I wouldn't hurt him. Besides, it's important to become accostumed to the feel of actual steel in one's hands from an early age and it will make him strong. It's how I was taught..."

 

(Morrigan disaproves -20)"

 
 

  • line_genrou aime ceci

#15210
line_genrou

line_genrou
  • Members
  • 989 messages

On his answer as a normal boy, I could also see him saying magic isn't scary from personal experience, though I see your point as well. My headcanon, until told otherwise, is that he's a mage no matter what, Morrigan just has herself some strong genes.

 

Another question for everyone. What family dynamic do you like best/think works best for our favorite little family? As in, mage HoF vs non-mage HoF. Do you prefer having him be a mage so he has something to relate to with Morrigan and Kieran and can teach Kieran along with Morrigan. Or do you prefer a non-mage who maybe doesn't have the same connection through their abilities but can provide a different viewpoint as a non-mage, and who can pass their own skills off to Kieran, be it knives, swords, or bows. 

 

Personally I like having the HoF be a non-mage because it means he can teach Kieran physical combat to supplement his magical abilities Morrigan taught him. Adult Kieran would be a complete badass that way. XD

 

Not only that but I believe Kieran himself would want to learn his father's skills with the sword and shield (my canon is warrior Cousland)

Young boys usually think their father is a BAMF, plus he's a grey warden. I think Kieran is completely fascinated by his father powerful presence and want to be like him.

Imagine him watching Cousland and Alistair awesome sparring match.


  • MisterJB et BurningLizard aiment ceci

#15211
Miss Golightly

Miss Golightly
  • Members
  • 233 messages

I think even if Kieran is a normal boy, he'd still have magical abilities. Morrigan would have some pretty strong genes as far as magic goes, so it seems unlikely that she would have a "muggle" son. I think if Kieran is the OGB, that power is just more pronounced. If he's a regular child, it's still developing.

 

I have warrior Cousland as Kieran's father. I like the idea of Kieran being adept in both magic and swordplay. He'd be pretty kickass as an adult. I think having the HoF as something other than a mage would allow for even more special bonds to form with each parent. I think Kieran is a real mama's-boy, but I can also see him following his father around all day and asking him all sorts of questions.

 

I just have this image in my head of Morrigan scolding Kieran for sneaking out to practice the sword skills his father taught him instead of studying in the Skyhold gardens.


  • Lord_Anthonior aime ceci

#15212
MisterJB

MisterJB
  • Members
  • 15 587 messages

One day, Cousland catches Kieran holding Vigilance and nearly has an heart attack. Not only is the thing inhabited by the malevolent spirit of an ancient High Dragon, it can cut through Silverite armor as if it was a linnen shirt.

It's one of the very few times Cousland raises his voice with his son and punishes him severely.

 
 
 

  • BurningLizard aime ceci

#15213
Terra_Ex

Terra_Ex
  • Members
  • 631 messages

One day, Cousland catches Kieran holding Vigilance and nearly has an heart attack. Not only is the thing inhabited by the malevolent spirit of an ancient High Dragon, it can cut through Silverite armor as if it was a linnen shirt.

It's one of the very few times Cousland raises his voice with his son and punishes him severely.

Sentinel armour looks pretty menacing in and of itself too, I'm unsure as to whether Kieran would be impressed or terrified when he first sees HoF in his best gear. An imposing figure in jet black armour adorned with the image of a glowing dragon steps through the door, wanting a hug from his son. The boy takes off posthaste.

8TqE6qy.png


  • BurningLizard aime ceci

#15214
BurningLizard

BurningLizard
  • Members
  • 153 messages

 

 

"He asked me to teach him. And It's important. What if he has to defend himself near Templars or against them?

 

My love, your logic is sound. What bothers me is not that Kieran be trained in martial forms of combat but rather that he is seven years old and you PLACED A STEEL SWORD WITH AN ACTUAL EDGE IN HIS HANDS!

 

But...he can't hurt me and I wouldn't hurt him. Besides, it's important to become accostumed to the feel of actual steel in one's hands from an early age and it will make him strong. It's how I was taught..."

 

(Morrigan disaproves -20)"

 

"Not even TEN voodoo dolls of Alistair will get you out of this one, my love." 



#15215
Ash Wind

Ash Wind
  • Members
  • 674 messages

On his answer as a normal boy, I could also see him saying magic isn't scary from personal experience, though I see your point as well. My headcanon, until told otherwise, is that he's a mage no matter what, Morrigan just has herself some strong genes.

 

Another question for everyone. What family dynamic do you like best/think works best for our favorite little family? As in, mage HoF vs non-mage HoF. Do you prefer having him be a mage so he has something to relate to with Morrigan and Kieran and can teach Kieran along with Morrigan. Or do you prefer a non-mage who maybe doesn't have the same connection through their abilities but can provide a different viewpoint as a non-mage, and who can pass their own skills off to Kieran, be it knives, swords, or bows. 

 

Personally I like having the HoF be a non-mage because it means he can teach Kieran physical combat to supplement his magical abilities Morrigan taught him. Adult Kieran would be a complete badass that way. XD

I'd prefer non-magical HoF to compliment Morrigan's magical instruction. My canon Warden can teach Kieran to be something neither Hawke, the Inquisitor nor any of their companions can be… Duel Wield Warrior! B) Now if he could just find Starfang.



#15216
Terra_Ex

Terra_Ex
  • Members
  • 631 messages

 

 

"He asked me to teach him. And It's important. What if he has to defend himself near Templars or against them?

 

My love, your logic is sound. What bothers me is not that Kieran be trained in martial forms of combat but rather that he is seven years old and you PLACED A STEEL SWORD WITH AN ACTUAL EDGE IN HIS HANDS!

 

But...he can't hurt me and I wouldn't hurt him. Besides, it's important to become accostumed to the feel of actual steel in one's hands from an early age and it will make him strong. It's how I was taught..."

 

(Morrigan disaproves -20)"

 

Is HoF still having to manage Morrigan's approval meter, 7 years on? That's rough.


  • BurningLizard aime ceci

#15217
Ash Wind

Ash Wind
  • Members
  • 674 messages

Is HoF still having to manage Morrigan's approval meter, 7 years on? That's rough.

A few pieces of jewelry should fix that.



#15218
Miss Golightly

Miss Golightly
  • Members
  • 233 messages

With all this talk about Kieran being a mage with some combat prowess, would anyone else be remotely interested in having Kieran as a possible companion in a future DA game?



#15219
BurningLizard

BurningLizard
  • Members
  • 153 messages

With all this talk about Kieran being a mage with some combat prowess, would anyone else be remotely interested in having Kieran as a possible companion in a future DA game?

Oh lordy yes. However, I don't see it happening. They're not going to give a companion spot to a character that may not even exist in a player's worldstate. And that definitely doesn't exist in the basic worldstate.



#15220
line_genrou

line_genrou
  • Members
  • 989 messages

If the warden is in a romance with Morrigan and reject the DR, she's already pregnant when she leaves

Does that mean that maybe Morrigan was pregnant before sugesting the DR in any case (rejecting or  agreeing with the ritual)? She didn't know she was but the DR changed her already conceived child. Maybe that's why the old god soul seems to trouble Kieran, instead of just being a natural part of him.



#15221
Brockololly

Brockololly
  • Members
  • 9 032 messages

If the warden is in a romance with Morrigan and reject the DR, she's already pregnant when she leaves
Does that mean that maybe Morrigan was pregnant before sugesting the DR in any case (rejecting or  agreeing with the ritual)? She didn't know she was but the DR changed her already conceived child. Maybe that's why the old god soul seems to trouble Kieran, instead of just being a natural part of him.


Heh... so how would that work if you were in a romance with Morrigan, turned down the DR but had Alistair or Loghain do it instead? All of a sudden now you'll need a Thedas version of Maury Povich to have a paternity test for Kieran. "Alistair, you are NOT the father!" *cue Alistair dancing*

Oh lordy yes. However, I don't see it happening. They're not going to give a companion spot to a character that may not even exist in a player's worldstate. And that definitely doesn't exist in the basic worldstate.


I agree in that I don't see it happening either due to the fact that BioWare seemingly wrapped up Kieran and anything really unique about him in Inquisition by having Flemeth snap up his Old God soul.

That said, if they simply had some mysterious mage/warrior hybrid character as a companion in some future game that looks like Kieran, maybe you only uncover his real identity if you import some world state where Kieran existed. Otherwise you never uncover his backstory and he stays some mysterious figure. Kind of like Canderous Orto in KOTOR and then he's just Mandalore in KOTOR2.

I don't know that I like the idea of Kieran being a companion that much since it likely means aging him up another 10 years or so and that means we're getting into middle aged Morrigan / Warden territory.

#15222
MisterJB

MisterJB
  • Members
  • 15 587 messages
 

Yeah, I don't think we will be seeing Kieran again, unfortunately.

Bioware probably realized the madness it would be trying to actually make someone who might or might not exist, who might or might not be normal, who might have three different fathers, etc an important part of the story.

So, they backtracked, gave us five minutes with him and then gave the Old God's soul to a character who is always around. At least then, there is only one variable and Solas or Flemeth are already powerful to being with and thus, having or not Urthemiel's soul is something that can be easily written around.



#15223
Miss Golightly

Miss Golightly
  • Members
  • 233 messages

I see where you guys are coming from. I think at best we'll get cameos or he'll be mentioned. 

 

As for the whole Morrigan already being pregnant when she suggests DR. I suppose it's a possibility, but what if the Warden romanced her and then made Alistair do the DR?

I always saw it as different realities.

Reality A - Warden romanced Morrigan but rejected DR. Morrigan runs off not knowing that she's already carrying a child. 

Reality B - Warden accepts DR. Morrigan isn't pregnant until ritual is preformed.

 

I don't know if anyone else here is slightly familiar with the Naruto manga/anime, but I always saw Old God Kieran that way. Sometimes irritated and bothered and maybe even tempted by the the Old God Soul. I don't think Urthemiel is as much a part of him as Mythal is to Flemeth though. Whether that's because of his age or how he was conceived compared to other people who carry such entities within themselves, I don't know.



#15224
Terra_Ex

Terra_Ex
  • Members
  • 631 messages

Oh lordy yes. However, I don't see it happening. They're not going to give a companion spot to a character that may not even exist in a player's worldstate. And that definitely doesn't exist in the basic worldstate.

I'm now of the opinion that they need to drop all the old Origins characters and plot threads personally, for a variety of reasons but chief among them being HoF's inability to show up and the returning companions inability to exhibit differing motivations in big plot moments. It renders certain aspects of the continuity as running gags and diminishes the apparent "ending" of the player's original character. Ironically, by seeking to avoid "offending" people with "mishandling" of a HoF return they arguably do it even more harm by rendering them as eternally offscreen, with only references in entirely inconsequential dialogues.

 

With all this talk about Kieran being a mage with some combat prowess, would anyone else be remotely interested in having Kieran as a possible companion in a future DA game?

I can probably see him being a temporary tagalong for a quest at best. Of course, having HoF & Kieran descend from the skies on griffons with Morri in dragon form will always be the dream.

 

If the warden is in a romance with Morrigan and reject the DR, she's already pregnant when she leaves

Does that mean that maybe Morrigan was pregnant before sugesting the DR in any case (rejecting or  agreeing with the ritual)? She didn't know she was but the DR changed her already conceived child. Maybe that's why the old god soul seems to trouble Kieran, instead of just being a natural part of him.

While it's an interesting thought, regular pregnancy Morrigan was only ever an ironic fallback for Morrigan being denied the DR, I'm fairly sure Morrigan specifically says OGB Kieran was conceived on the eve of the final battle or something along those lines.  Much of the nuance that can occur in Origins isn't accounted for - if you sleep with Morrigan instantly in DAO for example, she should already have had a child by the end of the game, yet it isn't accounted for. If you go about her romance the other way - become her friend first, then agree to become more after killing Flemeth it's easy enough to instantly lock yourself out of sex with her outside of the DR. I'd favour Morrigan bodging some part of the ritual over that explanation personally. Although regular Kieran's existence does make you wonder how far back "changed" Morrigan was planned... But simply put, if the DR was done and the player slept with her at some point, the game assumes Morrigan was not pregnant at the time of the DR, otherwise she is. It needn't be any more complex than that.

 

Besides this, I wonder if some of you aren't putting a little too much stock into the whole nightmares business and troublesome aspects of the OGB soul. MisterJB brought it up a few pages back but I forgot to respond to it.  iirc, he only says that lyrium gives him nightmares (as shown below), while he just talks about dreams to Flemeth in the fade, which could be referring to anything. So you need to decide if Morrigan's summation of their life tallies up with the other evidence. If Kieran's nightmares were so all-encompassingly terrifying as to ruin his life, I'd expect things would have been handled differently.

"Kieran: You're the Inquisitor. Mother never told me you'd be a mage.
> Is that a bad thing?
Kieran: No, it'd be worse if you couldn't touch magic at all. Like being blind.
> If you can sense that, don't ever become a templar.
Kieran: I can't, the lyrium gives me terrible nightmares.
> Who is your mother?
Kieran: Mother is the inheritor, she who awaits the next age."


Unless anyone can point out some other occurrences of Kieran's nightmares I'm gonna have to say you might be over-blowing that aspect of how Urthemiel has affected him. Are you not making an assumption that "no more dreams" means no more nightmares. I'm not convinced that all dreams = nightmares. They could be, but I don't recall it being confirmed either way. But this sort of brings us back to the WoS - if Morrigan is aware of the nightmares and they are as bad as you guys believe, that brings us back to BurningLizard's take on the WoS- that Morrigan feels she is a bad mother or has failed Kieran via the ritual's effects, which would/could lead to you interpreting Morrigan's desire for the Well as an act of punishing herself I suppose. On the other hand, if Morrigan is aware of the troubles Kieran faces (which she'd have to be to want to punish herself) then the WoS choice makes less sense since she'd be adding to Kieran's problems... I wonder if they should/could have presented/hinted at the WoS as having the knowledge required to split/remove the OGB soul from Kieran, if they've have gone with that rationale over "preservation, just because" it wouldn't have been so bad.

 


I always saw it as different realities.

Reality A - Warden romanced Morrigan but rejected DR. Morrigan runs off not knowing that she's already carrying a child. 

Reality B - Warden accepts DR. Morrigan isn't pregnant until ritual is preformed.

Yes, this is the correct way to look at how things play out, the scenarios are mutually exclusive.



#15225
BurningLizard

BurningLizard
  • Members
  • 153 messages

I see where you guys are coming from. I think at best we'll get cameos or he'll be mentioned. 

 

As for the whole Morrigan already being pregnant when she suggests DR. I suppose it's a possibility, but what if the Warden romanced her and then made Alistair do the DR?

I always saw it as different realities.

Reality A - Warden romanced Morrigan but rejected DR. Morrigan runs off not knowing that she's already carrying a child. 

Reality B - Warden accepts DR. Morrigan isn't pregnant until ritual is preformed.

 

I don't know if anyone else here is slightly familiar with the Naruto manga/anime, but I always saw Old God Kieran that way. Sometimes irritated and bothered and maybe even tempted by the the Old God Soul. I don't think Urthemiel is as much a part of him as Mythal is to Flemeth though. Whether that's because of his age or how he was conceived compared to other people who carry such entities within themselves, I don't know.

I've always assumed that the easiest explanation is that Morrigan being pregnant or not when she tells you about the dark ritual depends entirely on whether you accept or not. Though I think it's also possible that if she's in a romance and already pregnant, then who she performs the ritual with doesn't matter, what matters is the ritual, and if we assume the child had only just recently been conceived so it was young enough for the ritual to work? So if a romanced Warden DOES have Morrigan perform the ritual with someone else (blasphemy) then perhaps that means it's not actually Loghain or Alistair's kid, it is the Warden's kid but the performance of the ritual changes the fetus to something that can accept the soul. Which of course doesn't add up to the "Performed at the eve of battle" part of the ritual. Unless that wasn't actually part of the requirements, but Morrigan thought it was. 

 

I've also been playing around with the idea of a story that has two Warden protagonists, but only one of them becomes the warden and is a woman, the other would be a man (most likely a Cousland, because it's me) and is just a regular person who romances Morrigan and then the DR happens, the one romancing Morrigan can't perform it because in this canon he wouldn't be a grey warden, much angst happens, and then the ritual doesn't work because Morrigan was already preggers as per what happens if the ritual is refused. So the Warden dies, and everyone is pissed at Morrigan because they think she lied, and then they track her down and she admits to what went wrong.