Aller au contenu

Photo

Give up the option to kill Morrigan AFTER we defeat the Archdemon!


56 réponses à ce sujet

#26
Skellimancer

Skellimancer
  • Members
  • 2 207 messages

David Gaider wrote...

back pain wrote...
She cant do that if I take that specialization away from her.  Thank the maker for mods on the PC.

Well, don't forget to also mod in the ability to actually kill her and remove the options to talk to her about shapeshifting, because merely removing the specialization doesn't remove the fact that Morrigan is a shapeshifter.

At any rate, good luck with that.


Thanks.

Image IPB
  • Aren aime ceci

#27
Skellimancer

Skellimancer
  • Members
  • 2 207 messages
Image IPB

#28
MassEffect762

MassEffect762
  • Members
  • 2 193 messages
^ LMAO!!!



Good Job. Mission Accomplished. All is right in the World.
  • Aren aime ceci

#29
The Angry One

The Angry One
  • Members
  • 22 246 messages
Here's the thing about shapeshifting.. it has like a 2 second cast time.

My shield bash laughs at your 2 second cast time!

#30
Skellimancer

Skellimancer
  • Members
  • 2 207 messages

MassEffect762 wrote...

^ LMAO!!!

Good Job. Mission Accomplished. All is right in the World.


:lol:

#31
The Angry One

The Angry One
  • Members
  • 22 246 messages
You realise this is but the beginning of the avalanche of "kill Morrigan" mods that will come, oh yes.
See that's the problem with creating a Mary Sue in a videogame, especially one with a toolset. Everybody wants to murder them... and they will make it possible to do so... mahaha.

Modifié par The Angry One, 05 décembre 2009 - 02:24 .


#32
Kolaris8472

Kolaris8472
  • Members
  • 647 messages

The Angry One wrote...

You realise this is but the beginning of the avalanche of "kill Morrigan" mods that will come, oh yes.
See that's the problem with creating a Mary Sue in a videogame, especially one with a toolset. Everybody wants to murder them... and they will make it possible to do so... mahaha.


Oh Maker, yet another person who doesn't understand what a Mary Sue is.

#33
RunCDFirst

RunCDFirst
  • Members
  • 563 messages

Kolaris8472 wrote...

The Angry One wrote...

You realise this is but the beginning of the avalanche of "kill Morrigan" mods that will come, oh yes.
See that's the problem with creating a Mary Sue in a videogame, especially one with a toolset. Everybody wants to murder them... and they will make it possible to do so... mahaha.


Oh Maker, yet another person who doesn't understand what a Mary Sue is.


David Gaider is Morrigan?!?! :blink:

(or are Mary Sue's no longer author surrogates?)

Modifié par RunCDFirst, 05 décembre 2009 - 03:35 .

  • Aren aime ceci

#34
The Angry One

The Angry One
  • Members
  • 22 246 messages
Mary Sue/Gary Stus are not author surrogates. Of course. they can be. Looking att other videogames, Vivec in Morrowind for example is very much Michael Kirkbride's surrogate, as in GalCiv II Draginol is Brad Wardell's.

But those two are hopeless morons and I digress.



Mary Sues can also simply be characters favored by the author who have unrealistically fantastic traits (e.g. "you can't kill Morrigan! She'd turn into a griffon and fly away! Muahaha!") or don't suffer the consequences of their actions, etc.

In this case, Morrigan does a dark and dirty deed and gets off scott free. Whether this'll change in a sequel I can't predict, but I have the feeling it won't.

#35
Elanareon

Elanareon
  • Members
  • 980 messages
Why all the hate with Morrigan?

#36
Shillelagh Law

Shillelagh Law
  • Members
  • 35 messages

Krigwin wrote...

Wait a minute. I've never even thought of this before!

What happens to the baby when Morrigan shapeshifts? Does she remain pregnant in her animal form? DOES THE BABY TRANSFORM INTO A BABY OF WHATEVER FORM SHE IS INSTEAD OF A HUMAN?


Spider Babies!!

#37
Skellimancer

Skellimancer
  • Members
  • 2 207 messages

Elanareon wrote...

Why all the hate with Morrigan?


Why not?

#38
InvaderErl

InvaderErl
  • Members
  • 3 884 messages

The Angry One wrote...

Mary Sues can also simply be characters favored by the author who have unrealistically fantastic traits (e.g. "you can't kill Morrigan! She'd turn into a griffon and fly away! Muahaha!") or don't suffer the consequences of their actions, etc.
In this case, Morrigan does a dark and dirty deed and gets off scott free. Whether this'll change in a sequel I can't predict, but I have the feeling it won't.


That's a bit silly. Escaping punishment is not grounds for labeling one a mary sue and as a shapeshifter, um yeah that point is totally valid (a Griffon would be a bit much but you're the one who used that example - a crow or raven would be more likely) . Mary Sue-ing her would be to say "Oh no, Morrigan is oh so powerful she would laugh off all of your attacks." But being sly and quick is completely in line with Morrigan's characters/abilities.

Modifié par InvaderErl, 05 décembre 2009 - 03:46 .


#39
Krigwin

Krigwin
  • Members
  • 104 messages
Morrigan is not even close to being a Mary Sue, and going by the "Gaider likes this character!" argument, Alistair would also be one.

Just to be safe when I beat this game for the first time, I ran all of the companions through the Mary Sue Litmus Test. Surprisingly, the character that is most Mary Sue is Zevran, and the least is Oghren.

#40
Skellimancer

Skellimancer
  • Members
  • 2 207 messages

Krigwin wrote...

Morrigan is not even close to being a Mary Sue, and going by the "Gaider likes this character!" argument, Alistair would also be one.

Just to be safe when I beat this game for the first time, I ran all of the companions through the Mary Sue Litmus Test. Surprisingly, the character that is most Mary Sue is Zevran, and the least is Oghren.


But i killed Zevran. I think a lot of people did for different reasons.

#41
The Angry One

The Angry One
  • Members
  • 22 246 messages

InvaderErl wrote...

The Angry One wrote...

Mary Sues can also simply be characters favored by the author who have unrealistically fantastic traits (e.g. "you can't kill Morrigan! She'd turn into a griffon and fly away! Muahaha!") or don't suffer the consequences of their actions, etc.
In this case, Morrigan does a dark and dirty deed and gets off scott free. Whether this'll change in a sequel I can't predict, but I have the feeling it won't.


That's a bit silly. Escaping punishment is not grounds for labeling one a mary sue and as a shapeshifter, um yeah that point is totally valid (a Griffon would be a bit much but you're the one who used that example - a crow or raven would be more likely) . Mary Sue-ing her would be to say "Oh no, Morrigan is oh so powerful she would laugh off all of your attacks." But being sly and quick is completely in line with Morrigan's characters/abilities.


Mary Sues come in degrees of blatancy. And I was being sarcastic with the griffon thing.
The fact is when the author jumps in and blatantly tells everyone "hahahaha you'll never kill my character!" it doesn't matter whether it won't be killed either because it'll destroy everyone who tries, or will always escape, it's still overtly silly.
  • Aren aime ceci

#42
David Gaider

David Gaider
  • BioWare Employees
  • 4 514 messages

Skellimancer wrote...
Thanks.

I see you succeeded. Congratulations. I trust that makes you feel better, now.

Modifié par David Gaider, 05 décembre 2009 - 08:05 .


#43
Tianwyn

Tianwyn
  • Members
  • 45 messages
On one hand, I think Morrigan is a complex character. On the other, I do think she has Mary Sue-ish traits. (She wins way more conversations than anyone else).



As someone who's a complete book nerd, I can say with certainty that Mary Sues do not have to be author inserts. They can also be someone's ideal man or woman (I mean, look at Edward from Twilight, or Arya from Eragon).



I'm not accusing Mr. G of this sort of thing, since on the whole I think his writing is excellent. However, Morrigan does show signs of being a developer favorite, and therefore her importance in the storyline grates on those of us who are less than fond of her.

#44
The Angry One

The Angry One
  • Members
  • 22 246 messages

Tianwyn wrote...

On one hand, I think Morrigan is a complex character. On the other, I do think she has Mary Sue-ish traits. (She wins way more conversations than anyone else).


This too. She wins against Shale, damnit. SHALE.

#45
Curlain

Curlain
  • Members
  • 1 829 messages

Skellimancer wrote...

Image IPB


Morrigan Disapproves -90 Image IPB

#46
Sylixe

Sylixe
  • Members
  • 465 messages

David Gaider wrote...

There's also the fact that Morrigan no doubt disappeared right after the archdemon was killed, perhaps turning into an animal and vanishing into the shadows. She's not stupid. :)


I don't see how should could since anyone with half a brain got the respec mod and removed her points into a Shapeshifter and made her a Spirit Healer. Image IPB

#47
menasure

menasure
  • Members
  • 440 messages

Sylixe wrote...

David Gaider wrote...

There's also the fact that Morrigan no doubt disappeared right after the archdemon was killed, perhaps turning into an animal and vanishing into the shadows. She's not stupid. :)


I don't see how should could since anyone with half a brain got the respec mod and removed her points into a Shapeshifter and made her a Spirit Healer. Image IPB


morrigan is also a spirit healer for me (besides shapeshifter) but i can't help that; wynne is so touchy about killing the circle of mages and for once it did not seem to be a knock-out fight so her job was vacant and the number of candidates to fill it VERY limited. :whistle:

Modifié par menasure, 05 décembre 2009 - 09:17 .


#48
David Gaider

David Gaider
  • BioWare Employees
  • 4 514 messages

The Angry One wrote...
Mary Sues come in degrees of blatancy. And I was being sarcastic with the griffon thing.
The fact is when the author jumps in and blatantly tells everyone "hahahaha you'll never kill my character!" it doesn't matter whether it won't be killed either because it'll destroy everyone who tries, or will always escape, it's still overtly silly.

I think "it's a Mary Sue" has become shorthand for "I don't like that character" just like "it breaks my immersion" has become shorthand for "I don't like that feature".

But if it makes you feel better, I do think Morrigan is better than you. So there. Image IPB

#49
The Angry One

The Angry One
  • Members
  • 22 246 messages

David Gaider wrote...

The Angry One wrote...
Mary Sues come in degrees of blatancy. And I was being sarcastic with the griffon thing.
The fact is when the author jumps in and blatantly tells everyone "hahahaha you'll never kill my character!" it doesn't matter whether it won't be killed either because it'll destroy everyone who tries, or will always escape, it's still overtly silly.

I think "it's a Mary Sue" has become shorthand for "I don't like that character" just like "it breaks my immersion" has become shorthand for "I don't like that feature".


You may be correct, I won't deny it. Damn evil witch.

But if it makes you feel better, I do think Morrigan is better than you. So there. Image IPB


Better at manipulation, I'll give her that..

#50
tmp7704

tmp7704
  • Members
  • 11 156 messages

The Angry One wrote...

In this case, Morrigan does a dark and dirty deed and gets off scott free.

So does the player's character, multiple times for this matter. If that's somehow proof of Marysuism then, welp.