Aller au contenu

Photo

Talking to Duncan... (HNF Origin Spoilers)


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
139 réponses à ce sujet

#101
sylvanaerie

sylvanaerie
  • Members
  • 9 436 messages
Esp Howe's (She shoots down my boy then the brazen hussy flirts with this old man?? WTF moment indeed for him)

Bryce has probably seen it all from his fierce girl (GAWD I love that NPC! I wish he was around longer) considering you can tell your brother right in front of both parents "I've got someone waiting for me in my bed"Image IPB

Modifié par sylvanaerie, 25 mars 2010 - 01:09 .


#102
Nhadalie

Nhadalie
  • Members
  • 945 messages

sylvanaerie wrote...

Esp Howe's (She shoots down my boy then the brazen hussy flirts with this old man?? WTF moment indeed for him)

Bryce has probably seen it all from his fierce girl (GAWD I love that NPC! I wish he was around longer) considering you can tell your brother right in front of both parents "I've got someone waiting for me in my bed"Image IPB


But Thomas was a drunkard apparently. According to what Nathaniel said. So he wasn't really a winner. :lol:


I love the Couslands. Anywhere else it'd be awkward, and you wouldn't want your family to know about you sleeping around. Nope, it just gets even funnier with them when you let them know. The reaction to this stuff on a HNM is the funniest, I think though. Especially if you play the HNM as a womanizer. ("No less than three, I hope." "Someday, brother, you'll meet a real woman. Someone who you'll want more than just a roll in the hay with.")


Alas, neither of my HNFs sleep with Dairren or Iona. So I can't pick those options on them.

#103
nranola

nranola
  • Members
  • 1 675 messages
The Couslands seem like they're a tightknit family, anyhow.

Oren: What's a wench? Is that what you pull to get the bucket out of the well?
Bryce: A wench is a woman that pours the ale in a tavern, Oren. Or a woman who drinks a lot of ale.

I love that line. xD

Modifié par nranola, 25 mars 2010 - 01:27 .


#104
sylvanaerie

sylvanaerie
  • Members
  • 9 436 messages

nranola wrote...

The Couslands seem like they're a tightknit family, anyhow.

Oren: What's a wench? Is that what you pull to get the bucket out of the well?
Bryce: A wench is a woman that pours the ale in a tavern, Oren. Or a woman who drinks a lot of ale.

I love that line. xD


Yea seeing this warm and loving functional family (in counterpoint to the dysfunction that was Nate's background) kind of made me ease up on Nathaniel a lot.  It unfortuneately also impacts you more when its all wrenched away from you by Howe.

Killing that bastard was my favorite battle in Origins.  Killing the AD was anticlimatic after that.

#105
HaloKT

HaloKT
  • Members
  • 188 messages

Axekix wrote...

I had no idea Teagan was this popular. I thought Cailan and Vaughn would be the female favorites.

Come on, even if you're not attracted to guys you simply have to see the appeal of Teagan. He's a strong man, physically and emotionally. He's at a pretty good age for a man, grown out of boyish airheadedness and not old enough to be considered "too old". He's polite and has rather good manners, yet isn't above a bit of flirting. No wonder he has a huge following. I guess I would join the Teagan fandom as well, if I weren't so completely enraptured by Leliana already.
Cailan is just a pretty face really. You take a look at him, yeah, he's cute of sorts... but when he opens hs mouth, it's all gone. Maybe decent for a purely sexual fling, but not full-blown romance material IMO.
Riordan, huh... never really though about him to be honest.

And as to Alistair objecting to the shameless FemWarden - Teagan flirting? Alistair isn't one to openly object I think. He's a follower, he likes being told what to do. He will suffer silently (and when you're alone with him, he'll go pretty passive aggressive on you I guess), but I don't think he has the guts to actually step up to Teagan and stop him. He's just too insecure. All cuteness aside, that's just not very attractive.

Oh, and about the HNM - Iona thing? Although a lady-in-waiting isn't typically considered to be a servant, she's still an Elf. And that just doesn't meet social requirements if you're a noble. Although the whole Iona matter does raise one question - can you seduce Iona if you're a HNF as well? Just asking... :wub:

Modifié par HaloKT, 25 mars 2010 - 02:02 .


#106
SurelyForth

SurelyForth
  • Members
  • 6 817 messages

HaloKT wrote...

And as to Alistair objecting to the shameless FemWarden - Teagan flirting? Alistair isn't one to openly object I think. He's a follower, he likes being told what to do. He will suffer silently (and when you're alone with him, he'll go pretty passive aggressive on you I guess), but I don't think he has the guts to actually step up to Teagan and stop him. He's just too insecure. All cuteness aside, that's just not very attractive.



I think it’s even simpler than that- he doesn’t interject because he sees it for what it is: harmless, courtly flirtation. If you openly propositioned Teagan he would interject (a la Isabela) but as it is, it’s neither deep enough nor meaningful enough for him to get het up about.

#107
sylvanaerie

sylvanaerie
  • Members
  • 9 436 messages

HaloKT wrote...

Axekix wrote...

I had no idea Teagan was this popular. I thought Cailan and Vaughn would be the female favorites.

Come on, even if you're not attracted to guys you simply have to see the appeal of Teagan. He's a strong man, physically and emotionally. He's at a pretty good age for a man, grown out of boyish airheadedness and not old enough to be considered "too old". He's polite and has rather good manners, yet isn't above a bit of flirting. No wonder he has a huge following. I guess I would join the Teagan fandom as well, if I weren't so completely enraptured by Leliana already.
Cailan is just a pretty face really. You take a look at him, yeah, he's cute of sorts... but when he opens hs mouth, it's all gone. Maybe decent for a purely sexual fling, but not full-blown romance material IMO.
Riordan, huh... never really though about him to be honest.

And as to Alistair objecting to the shameless FemWarden - Teagan flirting? Alistair isn't one to openly object I think. He's a follower, he likes being told what to do. He will suffer silently (and when you're alone with him, he'll go pretty passive aggressive on you I guess), but I don't think he has the guts to actually step up to Teagan and stop him. He's just too insecure. All cuteness aside, that's just not very attractive.

Oh, and about the HNM - Iona thing? Although a lady-in-waiting isn't typically considered to be a servant, she's still an Elf. And that just doesn't meet social requirements if you're a noble. Although the whole Iona matter does raise one question - can you seduce Iona if you're a HNF as well? Just asking... :wub:


yes, both Dairren and Iona can be seduced by a PC of either sex....though not BOTH at the same time.  Then I think they get mad at you.

#108
sylvanaerie

sylvanaerie
  • Members
  • 9 436 messages

SurelyForth wrote...

HaloKT wrote...

And as to Alistair objecting to the shameless FemWarden - Teagan flirting? Alistair isn't one to openly object I think. He's a follower, he likes being told what to do. He will suffer silently (and when you're alone with him, he'll go pretty passive aggressive on you I guess), but I don't think he has the guts to actually step up to Teagan and stop him. He's just too insecure. All cuteness aside, that's just not very attractive.



I think it’s even simpler than that- he doesn’t interject because he sees it for what it is: harmless, courtly flirtation. If you openly propositioned Teagan he would interject (a la Isabela) but as it is, it’s neither deep enough nor meaningful enough for him to get het up about.


Exactly. I took it more as a "Get his mind off this craphole situation for even just a few minutes" than an actual attraction tween the two.  Though that little wistful line he says by the windmill makes me go all fuzzy inside and think maybe he took it just a bit seriously.

#109
DWSmiley

DWSmiley
  • Members
  • 1 431 messages

sylvanaerie wrote...

Killing that bastard was my favorite battle in Origins.  Killing the AD was anticlimatic after that.


Oh, yeah.  My only HN was an archer but I switched to daggers for that fight because settling the score with Howe had to be up close and personal.  I wish Bioware had done a special animation for the killing blow.

#110
Zy-El

Zy-El
  • Members
  • 1 614 messages

HaloKT wrote...

Axekix wrote...
Oh, and about the HNM - Iona thing? Although a lady-in-waiting isn't typically considered to be a servant, she's still an Elf. And that just doesn't meet social requirements if you're a noble. Although the whole Iona matter does raise one question - can you seduce Iona if you're a HNF as well? Just asking... :wub:


Oh yeah!  You sure can with HNF!  Caught me off guard when we woke up in bed together.  But, of course, Iona doesn't last long after that.  Met her daughter in the Alienage and was sad that I couldn't do anything for her - not even give her a keepsake from her mother.  Image IPB   Well, at least Iona had one "good" night.  Image IPB

Modifié par Zy-El, 25 mars 2010 - 02:12 .


#111
HaloKT

HaloKT
  • Members
  • 188 messages

SurelyForth wrote...

HaloKT wrote...

And as to Alistair objecting to the shameless FemWarden - Teagan flirting? Alistair isn't one to openly object I think. He's a follower, he likes being told what to do. He will suffer silently (and when you're alone with him, he'll go pretty passive aggressive on you I guess), but I don't think he has the guts to actually step up to Teagan and stop him. He's just too insecure. All cuteness aside, that's just not very attractive.



I think it’s even simpler than that- he doesn’t interject because he sees it for what it is: harmless, courtly flirtation. If you openly propositioned Teagan he would interject (a la Isabela) but as it is, it’s neither deep enough nor meaningful enough for him to get het up about.

Ah, I never thought of that. Might be because I cannot fully respect him. It's like Morrigan says, he is the elder Warden and yet he leaves all the decisions to the new recruit who doesn't even have a clue about the Wardens yet. And he's like that all throughout the game. Always leaving decisions and "important" things (like, you know, running a country) to others. On my first (and only :crying:) playthrough Anora completely crossed me, telling the Landsmeet that I wanted to kill her, proving to be an absolute b*tch. Yet Alistair was squiggling like a worm to get out of being king himself. I eventually got them both married, just because I don't see Alistair fit enough to rule on his own, even if I really hate Anora.

And thanks for the Iona answer sylvan. I might try that out. She's just a very minor character, but she's just sooo adorably shy. Or it's just that I have this thing for Elven maids? Can't get Shianni out of my head either :whistle:

Edit:
Oh, and in case it wasn't apparent enough, I never flirted with Teagan. I just read it and projected my rather nasty prejudices of Alistair onto it. I'm not a nice person I guess :(

Modifié par HaloKT, 25 mars 2010 - 02:19 .


#112
sylvanaerie

sylvanaerie
  • Members
  • 9 436 messages

HaloKT wrote...

SurelyForth wrote...

HaloKT wrote...

And as to Alistair objecting to the shameless FemWarden - Teagan flirting? Alistair isn't one to openly object I think. He's a follower, he likes being told what to do. He will suffer silently (and when you're alone with him, he'll go pretty passive aggressive on you I guess), but I don't think he has the guts to actually step up to Teagan and stop him. He's just too insecure. All cuteness aside, that's just not very attractive.



I think it’s even simpler than that- he doesn’t interject because he sees it for what it is: harmless, courtly flirtation. If you openly propositioned Teagan he would interject (a la Isabela) but as it is, it’s neither deep enough nor meaningful enough for him to get het up about.

Ah, I never thought of that. Might be because I cannot fully respect him. It's like Morrigan says, he is the elder Warden and yet he leaves all the decisions to the new recruit who doesn't even have a clue about the Wardens yet. And he's like that all throughout the game. Always leaving decisions and "important" things (like, you know, running a country) to others. On my first (and only :crying:) playthrough Anora completely crossed me, telling the Landsmeet that I wanted to kill her, proving to be an absolute b*tch. Yet Alistair was squiggling like a worm to get out of being king himself. I eventually got them both married, just because I don't see Alistair fit enough to rule on his own, even if I really hate Anora.

And thanks for the Iona answer sylvan. I might try that out. She's just a very minor character, but she's just sooo adorably shy. Or it's just that I have this thing for Elven maids? Can't get Shianni out of my head either :whistle:

Edit:
Oh, and in case it wasn't apparent enough, I never flirted with Teagan. I just read it and projected my rather nasty prejudices of Alistair onto it. I'm not a nice person I guess :(


well in Alistair's defense I also see gaming perspective coming into play here.  If he was the leader your PC wouldn't be making the hard choices you as the player needs to make.  He would just say "do this and go there" and you would be compelled to do it.  Not much opportunity to RP there.

Also if you harden him (Did you harden him on your playthrough?  He's a lot more tolerable when you do) he's much more a step up to the plate and accept his responsibilities man (and makes a pretty good king). However if you don't he really is a rubbish king cause he doesn't want to be.  He even surprises Anora when you marry them and she helps him with learning how to be a good king and he does.  (Alistair married to Anora makes a one two punch to Ferelden politics that can't be beaten by any combo not even HNF marrying him and frankly I think its really the best solution though I usually have my HNF marry him I just don't wanna share him).

#113
Gill Kaiser

Gill Kaiser
  • Members
  • 6 061 messages

DWSmiley wrote...

sylvanaerie wrote...

Killing that bastard was my favorite battle in Origins.  Killing the AD was anticlimatic after that.


Oh, yeah.  My only HN was an archer but I switched to daggers for that fight because settling the score with Howe had to be up close and personal.  I wish Bioware had done a special animation for the killing blow.

I switched to the Cousland Family Sword for the killing blow.

#114
SurelyForth

SurelyForth
  • Members
  • 6 817 messages

HaloKT wrote...
Ah, I never thought of that. Might be because I cannot fully respect him. It's like Morrigan says, he is the elder Warden and yet he leaves all the decisions to the new recruit who doesn't even have a clue about the Wardens yet. And he's like that all throughout the game. Always leaving decisions and "important" things (like, you know, running a country) to others. On my first (and only :crying:) playthrough Anora completely crossed me, telling the Landsmeet that I wanted to kill her, proving to be an absolute b*tch. Yet Alistair was squiggling like a worm to get out of being king himself. I eventually got them both married, just because I don't see Alistair fit enough to rule on his own, even if I really hate Anora.



Alistair's unwillingness to lead isn't because he's weak, it's because he knows what needs to be done and he doesn't believe that he can accomplish it (because he's been conditioned for self-doubt and was indoctrined to be a follower in the Chantry). If you harden him, he becomes a much more confident person. He gets to a really good place for a potential ruler to be- he's optimistic that he can be a good king but he realizes that it will be difficult and that he'll need help. That philosophy is in direct opposition to Loghain and Anora who cause a lot of problems because they see themselves as the only ones capable of saving Ferelden.

#115
Urazz

Urazz
  • Members
  • 2 445 messages

sylvanaerie wrote...

well in Alistair's defense I also see gaming perspective coming into play here.  If he was the leader your PC wouldn't be making the hard choices you as the player needs to make.  He would just say "do this and go there" and you would be compelled to do it.  Not much opportunity to RP there.

Also if you harden him (Did you harden him on your playthrough?  He's a lot more tolerable when you do) he's much more a step up to the plate and accept his responsibilities man (and makes a pretty good king). However if you don't he really is a rubbish king cause he doesn't want to be.  He even surprises Anora when you marry them and she helps him with learning how to be a good king and he does.  (Alistair married to Anora makes a one two punch to Ferelden politics that can't be beaten by any combo not even HNF marrying him and frankly I think its really the best solution though I usually have my HNF marry him I just don't wanna share him).

Yeah, I pretty much always harden Alistair in the playthroughs I had with him marrying Anora.  I actually think a hardened Alistair might actually have a chance to be happy with Anora if given the chance.

#116
SurelyForth

SurelyForth
  • Members
  • 6 817 messages

Urazz wrote...

Yeah, I pretty much always harden Alistair in the playthroughs I had with him marrying Anora.  I actually think a hardened Alistair might actually have a chance to be happy with Anora if given the chance.


I agree that Hardened Alistair/Anora are a very effective pair, but I'll only marry them off when I spare Loghain (this is to keep Alistair from throwing his life away). If I'm just making Alistair king, he usually ends up alone. I even prefer to do this as a FHN because there's the heir issue with the PC and he really doesn't want to marry Anora. I don't like my PC's being another person in his life coercing him down a path he'd rather not take.

#117
sylvanaerie

sylvanaerie
  • Members
  • 9 436 messages

Urazz wrote...

sylvanaerie wrote...

well in Alistair's defense I also see gaming perspective coming into play here.  If he was the leader your PC wouldn't be making the hard choices you as the player needs to make.  He would just say "do this and go there" and you would be compelled to do it.  Not much opportunity to RP there.

Also if you harden him (Did you harden him on your playthrough?  He's a lot more tolerable when you do) he's much more a step up to the plate and accept his responsibilities man (and makes a pretty good king). However if you don't he really is a rubbish king cause he doesn't want to be.  He even surprises Anora when you marry them and she helps him with learning how to be a good king and he does.  (Alistair married to Anora makes a one two punch to Ferelden politics that can't be beaten by any combo not even HNF marrying him and frankly I think its really the best solution though I usually have my HNF marry him I just don't wanna share him).

Yeah, I pretty much always harden Alistair in the playthroughs I had with him marrying Anora.  I actually think a hardened Alistair might actually have a chance to be happy with Anora if given the chance.


I think so too. On my HNM he seems to be pretty okay with marrying Anora, she seems more irritated by it than he does.  (that scene where they walk up to the Reverend Mother to get crowned is SO CUTE with him trying to hold her hand. It always makes me giggle).

#118
HaloKT

HaloKT
  • Members
  • 188 messages

sylvanaerie wrote...

well in Alistair's defense I also see gaming perspective coming into play here.  If he was the leader your PC wouldn't be making the hard choices you as the player needs to make.  He would just say "do this and go there" and you would be compelled to do it.  Not much opportunity to RP there.

Also if you harden him (Did you harden him on your playthrough?  He's a lot more tolerable when you do) he's much more a step up to the plate and accept his responsibilities man (and makes a pretty good king). However if you don't he really is a rubbish king cause he doesn't want to be.  He even surprises Anora when you marry them and she helps him with learning how to be a good king and he does.  (Alistair married to Anora makes a one two punch to Ferelden politics that can't be beaten by any combo not even HNF marrying him and frankly I think its really the best solution though I usually have my HNF marry him I just don't wanna share him).

We will have none of that "logic" nonsense here! :D
I know, you're supposed to be The Hero, and a more aggressive Alistair might be killing that notion off right at the start. Still, makes it very difficult for me to respect him, when I see him as more of a child than a capable leader. But at the same time, I just cannot get myself to be overly rude to him. It's like kicking a puppy :(
God, I guess I'd make a horrible mother...

In that conttext, I did want my HNF to marry him as well. Just to see how that ending would play out. and what happened? Ended up in Leli's arms again :pinched:

#119
goofygoff

goofygoff
  • Members
  • 481 messages

Axekix wrote...

Well I remember the first time I saw Cailan I thought "wow, what a pretty man (no ******)."  He's got a heroic streak and he's a king!  What else is there? :lol:

I thought the gamer gurls would be all over him. 


To borrow a line from Seinfeld, "he's a mimbo".

#120
rak72

rak72
  • Members
  • 2 299 messages

Queen-Of-Stuff wrote...

nranola wrote...

I was browsing through the conversation trees earlier today, and I came across a very interesting exchange between the Human Noble Female and Duncan. This is immediately after the first dialogue, if you choose to speak to Duncan before leaving the room. In parenthesis are voiceover notes provided in the toolset:

Duncan: I'm sorry, but I believe your father wishes to talk to me and the arl alone. (polite; arl = lord)
PC: May we speak later?
Duncan: Your father has left you in charge of the castle? Then I will see you at dinner tomorrow, if not sooner. (polite chit-chat)
PC: I would prefer sooner.
Duncan: Then let us meet in the morning. I will seek you out before Ser Gilmore's testing. Will that be sufficient? (polite chit-chat; ser = sir)
PC: What about tonight... in my room? (IF PC IS FEMALE)
Duncan: I-I appreciate your enthusiasm, but it would be inappropriate for me to be in your quarters unescorted. (flustered, but a little amused)


LOLOL YOU PROPOSITION DUNCAN. I am so very amused. 8'D So tempted to replay the Human Noble origin just to watch this scene play out.




In front of your father and Arl Howe, no less. Hilarious. I can imagine their jaws dropping. Unless this is something the HN does so often that no one takes any notice of it anymore, of course.


The extra funny thing is that if Duncan tells you that he'll talk to you about the GW's after your father leave, THEN Bryce geta all in his face, "I'M STANDING RIGHT HERE".

#121
Addai

Addai
  • Members
  • 25 850 messages

Urazz wrote...

I actually think a hardened Alistair might actually have a chance to be happy with Anora if given the chance.

Can't agree with you there, because a hardened Alistair is less likely to be a doormat and that's the only kind of consort Anora wants and will tolerate.  If Loghain lives, A. even says something to the effect that Anora thinks she is going to get her way and that's not going to happen.

#122
sylvanaerie

sylvanaerie
  • Members
  • 9 436 messages

HaloKT wrote...

sylvanaerie wrote...

well in Alistair's defense I also see gaming perspective coming into play here.  If he was the leader your PC wouldn't be making the hard choices you as the player needs to make.  He would just say "do this and go there" and you would be compelled to do it.  Not much opportunity to RP there.

Also if you harden him (Did you harden him on your playthrough?  He's a lot more tolerable when you do) he's much more a step up to the plate and accept his responsibilities man (and makes a pretty good king). However if you don't he really is a rubbish king cause he doesn't want to be.  He even surprises Anora when you marry them and she helps him with learning how to be a good king and he does.  (Alistair married to Anora makes a one two punch to Ferelden politics that can't be beaten by any combo not even HNF marrying him and frankly I think its really the best solution though I usually have my HNF marry him I just don't wanna share him).

We will have none of that "logic" nonsense here! :D
I know, you're supposed to be The Hero, and a more aggressive Alistair might be killing that notion off right at the start. Still, makes it very difficult for me to respect him, when I see him as more of a child than a capable leader. But at the same time, I just cannot get myself to be overly rude to him. It's like kicking a puppy :(
God, I guess I'd make a horrible mother...

In that conttext, I did want my HNF to marry him as well. Just to see how that ending would play out. and what happened? Ended up in Leli's arms again :pinched:


Sounds like you didn't harden him...try that the next time you play (its tied to his personal quest) I always harden him so I don't get when people say hes weak and whiny.  I don't see it cause well he isn't in my play throughs. It doesn't make him an ****, just makes him more confidant and ready to accept his responsibilities better and he's less willing to be pushed around.

#123
SurelyForth

SurelyForth
  • Members
  • 6 817 messages

Addai67 wrote...

Urazz wrote...

I actually think a hardened Alistair might actually have a chance to be happy with Anora if given the chance.

Can't agree with you there, because a hardened Alistair is less likely to be a doormat and that's the only kind of consort Anora wants and will tolerate.  If Loghain lives, A. even says something to the effect that Anora thinks she is going to get her way and that's not going to happen.


Anora is more likely to cotton on to Alistair if he is hardened because she respects him more. The sparing Loghain thing is a wrench in their (maybe) (potential) happiness, but if he dies at the Landsmeet it might work out for them.

But, like I said, I'm not pushing Ali down that road anymore. I was reading the comments in the toolset and it's clear that he is never happy about the arrangement and she really dislikes him. 

Re: Bryce. I always forget that he jumps in when you talk to Duncan about becoming a Warden. That makes the propositioning even more awesome, I think, since he is obviously eavesdropping.

#124
goofygoff

goofygoff
  • Members
  • 481 messages

Urazz wrote...

Yeah, I pretty much always harden Alistair in the playthroughs I had with him marrying Anora.  I actually think a hardened Alistair might actually have a chance to be happy with Anora if given the chance.


I agree, though it would most likely take time.

If you talk to Anora about it before the Landsmeet and tell her that you don't plan on stepping aside (I just wanted to see what she'd say), she will tell you that even though it would a political marriage, something more may develop down the road.  As was the case with her and Cailan.

If Loghain is out of the picture, and the PC romance has ended (or a non-factor), I think a hardened Alistair would have a good chance of eventually being happy with the arrangement.

#125
Nhadalie

Nhadalie
  • Members
  • 945 messages

goofygoff wrote...

If you talk to Anora about it before the Landsmeet and tell her that you don't plan on stepping aside (I just wanted to see what she'd say), she will tell you that even though it would a political marriage, something more may develop down the road.  As was the case with her and Cailan.


Yet from what I've gathered, the two were pretty much smitten with eachother long before they got married. :lol:

Eamon comments about how Cailan tripped all over himself to do whatever Anora wanted. And I think Loghain says something about how he had to keep Anora from giving into teenage hormones with Cailan all the time.

Personally, I like making Alistair king alone in a lot of circumstances. The whole announcing that you're going to marry him, and rule by his side always seemed awkward to me. Yes, it gives you the ability to make the choice. But I always thought the situation would go so much better if Alistair actually asked your HNF to marry him when he's hardened, and right after you make him king. Because declaring it without giving him a choice in the matter is just awkward. :P

Modifié par Nhadalie, 25 mars 2010 - 03:48 .